My friends and I were watching MTV one weekend when we heard the news-Napster would be blocking access to copywritten songs in mid-March.
I knew this was going to happen eventually because everybody had been talking about it for months. I just didn’t think it would be so soon. When I heard the news, I was upset because Napster, the easiest music-sharing system on the Internet, was my favorite way to explore different songs for free.
Found ‘Lazy Eye’ on Napster
After I learned about Napster from a friend last year, I put the service on my computer. The first song I downloaded was the Goo Goo Dolls’ “Lazy Eye.”
The song was in the movie Batman and Robin, but I’d never heard it on the radio. But I did recognize the Goo Goo Doll’s sound in a commercial for the film.
I wasn’t sure of the song’s name, but when I typed in the band’s name and “Batman and Robin,” about 30 versions of “Lazy Eye” popped up on my screen. They were all the same song, but on the computers of different people. So, I just picked one and downloaded it.
I thought it was cool that everyone could freely share songs with each other around the world. I was amazed to find almost any song I typed in. From then on, I started to use Napster whenever I wanted to download tracks I wasn’t familiar with.
Record Industry Gets Heated
But because Napster made swapping songs for free so easy, music labels and performers got upset. Some record industry officials said Napster had violated the rights of artists and record companies. The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) claimed that people getting free music online without giving the artists or record companies any money was an act of piracy.
Some musicians were also against Napster because they feared the service would cause their record sales to go down since people had access to their songs for free. Metallica and Dr. Dre were among the first musicians to speak out against Napster for copyright violations.
They sued in April 2000. In May, a U.S. district judge ordered Napster to stand trial for copyright infringement. The company lost the case, but managed to continue operating by appealing the decision.
In order to keep alive, Napster formed an alliance with Bertelsmann (BMG), one of the world’s largest record companies, to develop a service in which users would have to pay a fee. In February 2001, the company also offered labels $1 billion for the right to allow copyrighted music to be traded on its network. But the RIAA said no.
And Napster lost its appeal. To comply with the court rulings, it had to take away all copyrighted music.
Napster Helped Me Buy CDs
Despite everyone’s concerns about the record industry and artists losing money because of Napster, Napster helped me buy CDs. Before purchasing a CD, I listen to samples of its songs.
Before I bought the Blink182 album, for instance, I downloaded two of its songs from Napster. I really liked the tracks, so I bought the CD. Since I have a limited income, I don’t want to take a chance on wasting money on CDs I’ll dislike, particularly since they cost $14-20 nowadays. So I refuse to buy albums unless I’ve heard song samples from it beforehand.
Some would argue that’s what the radio is for. But many songs don’t get radio play if they don’t fit a certain format. The band 3 Doors Down had a hit, “Kryptonite,” which I heard all the time on the radio, but I wanted to get a sense of their other songs before buying their CD.
So I downloaded “Loser,” which I never heard on the radio and only heard on MTV once. I liked the song, so I bought the CD. In this sense, Napster can be seen as an aid to the recording industry.
CD Packaging Important
People weren’t going to stop buying CDs because of Napster. CDs offer benefits that downloading doesn’t. I buy albums because they have packaging, usually with art, photography and sometimes lyrics, that makes them a worthwhile investment for music lovers.
I could invest in a CD burner and make my own CDs, but that wouldn’t allow me to have the CD’s artwork and production notes at my disposal. And that’s important for many music fans.
Also, CDs allow you to have faster access to songs than downloading. Napster tracks usually take half an hour for me to download because I use a modem connection for my downloads. Plus, these files take up a lot of space on my computer’s disk drive, which is an inconvenience.
Always Have Free Options
I understand some artists may feel cheated out of getting money for their work, but I believe there will always be some way of getting free music, whether it’s from sites similar to Napster or taping music from the radio or CDs, or distribution of bootlegged copies of albums.
And having these options doesn’t mean that traditional ways of distributing music will be destroyed. When the VCR came out, people were worried that everyone would stop going to the movies. But people still do. So the RIAA needs to stop worrying.
Looking Into Alternatives
I think many people will leave Napster with its new restrictions. (Internet research firm Webnoize reported the average number of daily Napster users has dropped 25 percent.) There are other alternatives, like OpenNap and Gnutella.
I’ve started to check out other websites that offer free music. I tried Gnutella. It’s similar to Napster in that you type in the song or artist you’re looking for and a bunch of outcomes show up.
But when you click on the song you want to download, there may be a chance that it’s busy, meaning too many people are downloading it. That never happened to me with Napster.
And then, sites like Audiofind.com, Findsongs.com and Audioseek.net, have more limited selection options. For instance, when I looked up Aerosmith’s “Janie’s Got a Gun,” only two songs came up.
These sites are adequate for checking out singles before I buy a CD, but they’re no Napster.
Killing Napster for No Reason
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.