When I hear “Jerusalem,” I immediately think of war-killings, suicide bombings, riots-between the Palestinians and Israelis. The fighting has continued, on and off, for more than 50 years, as two groups of people struggle over the same land.
What’s it like to be a child growing up in Jerusalem, inheriting this historical and long-lasting conflict? That’s the question posed by Promises, a documentary film to be shown on PBS on December 13. The film presents the views and voices of seven Israeli and Palestinian kids from in and around Jerusalem.
Separated by Checkpoints
In Jerusalem, different worlds exist only 20 minutes apart. Take Palestinian Faraj and Israeli twins Yarko and Daniel for example: They live less than 15 minutes away from each other by car, but if not for their participation in this film, they’d have remained in their separate worlds.
Israeli checkpoints throughout Jerusalem limit Palestinian travel greatly by not allowing them into Jerusalem without a permit. This prevents Palestinians from interacting with Israelis, and from praying in the holy city of Jerusalem.
The thought of not being able to travel from one part of a country to the next if you’re from a certain group bothers me. It’s like if you lived in Brooklyn and you weren’t allowed to travel into Manhattan without a permit, but people from Manhattan could freely go to and from Brooklyn.
Father’s in Prison
The war displaced many Palestinians from their homes. Sanabel lives with her secular mother in Deheishe, a refugee camp. It’s only 10 minutes away from Jerusalem, but she’s never been there. Her journalist father has been in prison in Israel without trial for two years.
Eleven-year-old Mahmoud lives in Jerusalem’s Old City, which gives him access denied other Palestinians. He’s not content, however-not until the Jews who he feels have overrun “his” land are gone, and his people can liberate Jerusalem.
That won’t happen if Moishe has his way. From a Jewish settler family, Moishe, 10, has ambitious dreams of being Israel’s first “religious” prime minister.
The film’s other orthodox Jew, Shlomo, 13, is a rabbi-in-training. Born in Israel, he’s the son of a rabbi from the U.S. and speaks fluent English (most of the kids’ conversation is subtitled).
Children Talking Politics
Hearing these children talk about politics-something usually reserved for adults only-is astonishing. The way they articulate their opinions and the emotion that goes into what they’re saying is scary; you’d swear they were adults if not for their voices and still developing bodies.
Talking about the Jerusalem Day Parade, which goes through a Palestinian neighborhood, for example, Mahmoud says, “They say today is the celebration of the reunification of Jerusalem. But Jerusalem isn’t for the Jews. It’s for Arabs. This is just a provocation,” he says. “My heart wants to burst.”
In fact, it often seems like they’re just rehashing their parents’ views with maybe an inkling of their own thoughts on the matter. Maybe it’s just me being American and not used to these things, but I can’t understand how such young children can be so politically aware-and so strongly opinionated-on their own account.
Still Acting Like Kids
Still, it’s refreshing to see young people so engaged with politics and the world around them, as opposed to the U.S., where Dragon Ball Z, Harry Potter and Pokemon rule children’s minds.
But the kids in Promises are still children even though they may talk like adults. They still cry, like when Faraj barely loses a 100-meter dash. They play with friends. And they’re not shy about asking questions, like when the twins badger their grandfather over whether or not he believes in God.
And the kids’ views are shaken when they’re confronted with new information, or when they meet each other.
Throughout the film, Mahmoud is inflexible about not wanting to meet any Jews. B.Z., one of the film’s director/producers, catches Mahmoud by telling him that he, himself, is Jewish. Mahmoud is dumbfounded and tries to cover up by saying he was only talking about “authentic” Jews, not half-American ones.
Some Hope for Peace
Before seeing Promises, I wasn’t particularly up on the conflict. I’m still no expert, but after watching this film, I think that peace will be hard to achieve.
When Faraj and Sanabel meet the twins, they present a sense of hope for the peace process. During the get-together, race or religion aren’t issues; they just have fun playing soccer, firing slingshots, dancing, having pillow fights, wrestling and playing a hand-smacking game.
But if the rest of the kids are an accurate reflection of most other Palestinians and Israelis, there are going to be problems.
Connecting Through Burps
Shlomo and Moishe are unwilling to meet with the other side to help the peace process move along. Moishe believes that older people should be the movers of the process instead, preferably ministers and members of Parliament.
Shlomo tries not to see Palestinians as being human, but one scene shows how hard that is. Shlomo is speaking with B.Z. about how Israeli and Palestinian relationships exist among adults but not children, and a Palestinian boy interrupts with a forced burp.
Shlomo reciprocates with a forced burp of his own; this exhibition of gas control continues until Shlomo begins to laugh.
A Better Understanding
When some Palestinian kids are discussing whether they’re willing to meet Jewish children, one of Faraj’s friends says, “I believe all children are innocent.” But it’s only a matter of years before they’re adults determining their own actions in this ongoing conflict.
Promises opened my eyes to the Middle East conflict and gave me a much better understanding of the complicated situation there now.
Promises will be shown on WNET/13, Thursday, December 13, at 9 p.m.
Kids’-Eye Views of Middle East Conflict
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.