Kids Behind Bars

In case you haven’t been reading the paper, there have been a whole lot of cases in the news recently where teens committed horrible, violent crimes.
Most recently, in Oregon, a 15-year-old boy was arrested and charged with killing his parents, and then shooting into a crowded cafeteria in his school, killing two students.
And way over in little Jonesboro, Arkansas, for instance, two boys 11 and 13 years old decided to go up to their school and open fire, killing four students and one teacher.
Their classmates speculated that they did it because one of them had been rejected by a girl he liked, and he wanted to get revenge. But because they’re so young, Arkansas laws say they may only get sentenced to a few years.
Murder in Central Park
In New York, a 15-year-old girl and her 16-year-old friend were convicted of killing of a man in Central Park.
They stabbed him repeatedly, slit his throat, and cut out all of his insides so he would sink in the lake easier. The girl was sent to an adult court and pleaded guilty to first-degree man-slaughter.
Now, I’m quite sure people are wondering, why are these kids committing crimes you’d think only some sick adult would do? And why don’t some of them get harsher penalties for their crimes?
Kids Doing Adult Time
These questions are going through many people’s heads in just about every state there is. And they’re especially on the minds of the judges and state legislators who really get to decide what happens to all these kids.
Many people think that if a kid does the crime, then he should do the adult time. And now laws are being passed that will enable kids to be tried as adults-in some states as early as 13 years old.
Now when I say tried as an adult, I don’t mean the kid being referred to as a Mr. or a Ms. What I mean is that he or she would go to an adult criminal court, receive an adult sentence, and be sent to an adult prison.
If a kid is sent to an adult prison, he doesn’t get much rehabilitation. Instead, he’ll be in a community of constant violence and will be surrounded by nothing but negativity.
The Laws May Get Tougher
On May 7, 1997, the House of Representatives passed the Juvenile Crime Control Act of 1997, which would make it easier to try juveniles as adults in the federal system.
This bill would provide $1.5 billion over 3 years to states that agree to change their juvenile codes and get tougher on youth offenders.
One of the provisions is that all juveniles who commit certain violent crimes be automatically sent to adult court. (If you’re 13, you’d only be sent to adult court if you murder someone. But if you’re older, you could be tried as an adult for a bunch of other crimes.)
Your lawyer could make a special request that you be sent back down to juvenile court, but it would be up to the judge to decide whether or not she wanted to give you a break.
The state would also have to impose increasing penalties against repeat offenders. And the state would make public the records of minors who commit more than one crime.
There are several other rules in the bill, but you basically get the idea. And this year, the Senate is expected to debate a similar bill. It’s not law yet, but if the Senate passes the bill, it could be.
Should Teens Be On Death Row?
Given the above cases, maybe these proposed laws sound good to you.
But it’s important to look at some other facts about teens who commit crimes, because once you look more closely, it’s not at all clear that these laws make any sense.
I mean, of course if a teen murders someone, he has to suffer some pretty serious consequences. But currently, in some states like New York, you can get tried as an adult for burglarly, or even if you’re just part of a group that goes and robs someone’s home, even if you don’t actually take anything yourself, said Susan Decker, director of the juvenile justice program for the DOME project here in New York.
In other states like Illinois, you can be tried as an adult for drugs or weapons possession within 1,000 feet of a school or housing project, according to an article in The New York Times.
And in other states, they even have a few teens waiting to receive the death penalty.
Easy Jailhouse Bait
What’s more, some studies show that sending kids to jail doesn’t help rehabilitate them; it teaches them how to be better criminals the next time they get out of jail.
In adult prisons, juveniles are more vulnerable to physical and sexual abuse than the adults, which may explain why they come out with even more problems than when they went in.
“Kids are being beaten and raped in these jails,” said Ms. Decker.
“They have their possessions taken away, they get cut up. It’s not at all a wonderful place to be, not at all,” she said.
Those experiences could make anyone mean. And, often, that’s what it does.
Even More of a Menace
A study published last year in the journal Crime and Delinquency showed that in Florida, a state where lots of juveniles are tried as adults, sending kids to adult jails increases the chance that these kids will go back to jail once they’re released.
It showed that those who had gone through the adult system were more likely to get in trouble again once they were released than the ones who went through the juvenile system.
And if being treated like an adult doesn’t help juvenile offenders turn their lives around, it also doesn’t help make society safer.
After all, kids may stay in jail longer, but when they come out-which, if they’re kids, you can pretty much bet they will-it’s very likely that they’ll commit more crimes.
So if you send a kid to prison, he’ll probably become more of a menace to society.
Now, I think that some kids will probably never be reformed. But I also think that others just need serious help getting back on track.
A kid who commits a crime needs to be punished. But sometimes he also needs to be in a safe, disciplined place like a juvenile detention center or a group home, where he’ll have a chance to develop into someone who’s about something good in life.
When I think back on the things I used to do, like steal and fight with my family, I’m glad I stopped, and that I got sent to a group home where the staff helped me as well as disciplined me.
But if I hadn’t gotten help, and if the system had just said I was bad and needed to be punished, I wouldn’t be anywhere near where I am now-going to school, preparing for college and getting a head start on my career.
A System Filled With Minorities
Besides, Ms. Decker told me that 90% of the kids in the juvenile justice system in the state of New York are minorities, and most of them come from tough neighborhoods like Harlem and the South Bronx.
Personally, I think that alone should tell you why so many people in our society don’t care about what happens to these kids. They hardly see any of them because they’re living somewhere out in the suburbs or in the country.
“It’s like society’s willing to pay for these kids to be warehoused away, but they’re not willing to pay for them to get an education,” said Ms. Decker.
When I think about things like this, I really have to wonder if there’s something very wrong with our system, and if we should think twice before trying kids as adults.
Is Juvenile Justice Just a Joke?
On the other hand, since I’ve had the opportunity to live in a group home, I’ve seen kids sent upstate and return the next day just to do the same dumb things all over again.
Some sell drugs, steal and rob houses. Some belong to gangs and get into all sorts of serious fights.
But many of them feel that because they’re juveniles, they can’t get in too much trouble, so they continue to do these things.
They get lots of chances to reform, but they keep on acting like they just don’t care.
Learning the Real Deal
So sometimes I can see why society would want to try a kid as an adult. If that kid had a record of always being in trouble, then maybe he should be sent to an adult prison so he can see what the real deal is.
So many things play a role in why kids do the things they do. The problem is, it just takes too long to try and figure out in a courtroom why a kid killed someone, or why he stole something, or joined a gang.
It’s nothing you can find out in just one day, and courts just don’t have that much time in the first place.
But because it’s so hard to find out the real reason why a kid did what he did, we just say, “Put him in jail.”
One Last Chance
If we do change the laws to be stricter on teens, I think maybe the way to go is to adopt the laws they have in Minnesota and some other states, where teens who commit violent crimes get something called a “blended sentence.”
If a juvenile gets a blended sentence, he is issued both a juvenile and an adult sentence.
If the juvenile follows the terms of his juvenile sentence, he’s released without any record, and he doesn’t have to go to an adult facility.
But if he messes up, the judge can revoke the juvenile time and give him the adult sentence.
At least this gives kids a chance to think things over carefully.
If a kid is sent to jail with a bunch of grown men, the only thing he’ll want to think about is his life and how to keep it.
Throwing Kids Away
I also think that instead of using all this money to go and build new jails, they should take this money and build more group homes, or shelters, or give more money to foster parents.
And they should invest in more programs and social services to keep teens out of trouble in the first place.
I think we really need to think twice before we decide to treat kids like adults-because they’re not adults. And sometimes kids react to situations without knowing the consequences.
If society can’t spare a second chance for a kid, then if that kid is sent to jail and gets out, he won’t think of sparing someone else’s life.
Many kids who are involved in the juvenile justice system have weaknesses as well as strengths.
If they’re sent to prisons, their weaknesses will become their strengths, and their strengths their weaknesses.
In other words, some of these kids could have talents that they may not even know they have.
If a kid is unjustifiably sent to jail, all of his dreams will fade away faster than a late-night bonfire, leaving in its place a pile of ashes waiting to be thrown out.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.