Kicked to the Curb

Is California violating the human rights of youth aging out?

Imagine it’s your high school graduation day. You come home, still in your dress clothes, and your foster parent informs you that you can no longer live there, because you’ve recently turned 18 and are now out of school. Your social worker, who hadn’t warned you this was coming, confirms what your foster parent tells you and drives you to a homeless shelter. You can stay in the shelter for only four months.
It sounds crazy, but that’s what happened to one young woman in California. Her story was told in a recent report on California’s foster care system that shows how failing to prepare youth for leaving care can have serious consequences. And state budget cuts are making the problems young adults face when they age out even worse.
The report is called “My So-Called Emancipation: From Foster Care to Homelessness for California Youth,” and it was published by Human Rights Watch (HRW), an organization that investigates human rights abuses around the world. HRW believes that California’s foster care system is doing such a bad job at preparing youth for emancipation, or aging out, that it violates their human rights.
“California is failing in an essential duty to children in its care: to prepare them for adulthood and to survive independently,” said Elizabeth Calvin, the lead author of the report.
Represent recently visited the New York office of Human Rights Watch and interviewed Calvin in Los Angeles by video phone. She explained that kids in foster care have rights under international law, including the right to shelter and proper care.
Once a child is taken out of his home, the state has the same duties as a parent. That includes preparing youth to transition into adulthood. She told us that HRW chose to put the spotlight on California’s foster care system because the state has such a large number of children in care-more than double any other state.
Not Prepared
Many foster youth in California leave the system without a job or permanent place to live and end up homeless. Between 2003 and 2008, more than 26,000 youth aged out of state care and about 5,300 became homeless, according to the report.
Calvin interviewed 63 homeless youth between the ages of 18 and 24 who had aged out of the foster care system. Some lived in shelters and transitional living homes; others lived on the street or in tents.
Out of the 63 young people she interviewed, 57 had no source of income. More than half had not graduated from high school and had no health insurance. Ninety percent had no source of income when they left care and no adult they felt they could turn to, even for simple things like getting a ride to the doctor.
The youth Calvin spoke to often hadn’t had a chance to learn the skills they needed to be ready for survival on their own, like job and house hunting, money management, cooking, health, and relationships. The report found that some kids leave foster care in California with no plan, even though state and federal law requires child welfare agencies to work with youth on a plan for what they’ll do after care.
“If you are going to put kids in foster care, at least give them what they need to survive,” said Tony D., one of the youth interviewed by Calvin at a homeless shelter.
More Time, More Skills
For Tony and many others, the lack of support led to homelessness soon after they left care. In many cases, the system only provided them with shelter temporarily. Many end up sleeping under freeway overpasses, in cars, parks, storage sheds, and other unsafe places.
Tiffany was taken from her foster home once she graduated high school and went to a shelter, where she was allowed to stay for two months. After that she was kicked out. When Calvin interviewed her, she was living at an emergency shelter, number 25 on a waiting list for a transitional housing program. She should have been on a waiting list before being emancipated.
On the day that Roberta became free from the foster care system she had not yet graduated high school and had no housing or job, so she slept on the streets, or in motel rooms, or couch-surfed at the homes of friends.
Roberta went into foster care because her father had been abusive; he would hit her regularly with sticks and constantly tormented her emotionally. Yet the hardships she endured after leaving foster care made her wonder if life with her father would have been better. She said she’d had only one life skills class-just one week before leaving care.
“Now that I’m on the streets, I honestly feel I would have been better off in an abusive home with a father who beat me-at least he would have taught me how to get a job and pay the bills,” she said.
People Who Really Care
Youth also need more than just survival skills. Calvin said another pattern she noticed among the youth she interviewed was a feeling that no one cared. That’s a problem, because having social connections and bonding with people who care about you is crucial for success.
Calvin spoke of the need for a “deep commitmentâin fulfilling the needs of children in care”-a commitment from social workers, foster parents, mentors, and others that would go beyond legal obligations. In other words, foster youth need people who really care and are not just doing things because it’s their job.
“People are much more happy and successful when cared about,” Calvin said. She believes that mentoring can help a young person be successful, but only if mentors show sincere concern and a willingness to help.
Fighting New Budget Cuts
There are laws in California that are supposed to make sure children get what they need to become independent adults. But like many other states, California is broke, and politicians have been making huge cuts to all kinds of state departments and programs.
In January, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger proposed cuts of $80 million to the state’s child welfare services and then threatened to end a program called THP-Plus, which provides housing and life skills training for youth leaving foster care.
The program was showing good results, like keeping youth in stable housing, helping them complete their education, and helping them make positive connections in the community. In the long run, that actually saves the state money by keeping youth employed, off the streets, and out of prison.
Foster care advocates, including many youth in care, were outraged about the cuts. Teens from California Youth Connection, a youth advocacy group, even met with members of the state legislature to demand that the THP-Plus program be protected. In that case, people power worked: The program was saved.
Using her report, Calvin is now working with foster care advocates to push state politicians to pass a law known as AB 12 that would extend foster care in California to age 21. Studies have shown that youth who stay in foster care beyond age 18 do better than those who leave the system at 18. And under a new law passed by Congress in 2008, the federal government will match the amount of money that states spend on changing the age of emanicipation from 18 to 21.
But budget problems are making it hard for states like California simply to fund current programs, much less spend more money. Still, is that a good enough reason not to extend care to 21?
“Most young adults in the U.S. get emotional and often financial support from their families well past their 18th birthdays,” said Calvin. “High- and low-income families all give emotional and financial support into their mid-20s, and that’s not happening for people in foster care.”
Growing Up Takes Time
I agree. Becoming an adult is not something that occurs overnight at 18 (or even 21). It’s a process that takes place gradually, along with life lessons. In California, youth are sometimes able to stay in care until 19, but that’s only if they are going to school, have a job, or are participating in a program to help with job searching. It will be a big deal if California passes AB 12, and it might encourage other states to extend foster care to age 21 as well.
In its report, Human Rights Watch exposed a problem that foster youth, alumni, and many professionals who work in child welfare have been talking about and working on for a long time. If people in power are reminded that the United States, like the rest of the world, has a duty to protect the rights of vulnerable children and young adults, maybe they will think twice before cutting programs that may be the only thing standing between youth in care and the streets.
And maybe, just maybe, politicians will realize that discharging youth before they’re ready is not only a violation of human rights-it may end up costing more money in the long run.
To learn more, visit hrw.org and search for the report by title.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.