JFK: A Movie That Asks Questions

JFK is about one of the most mysterious and intriguing events in American history: the assassination of President John F. Kennedy.
Kennedy was shot on November 22, 1963, as his open car toured downtown Dallas. Less than two hours after the shooting, police arrested Lee Harvey Oswald, whom they suspected of shooting Kennedy and a Dallas police officer.
Oswald was an employee of the Texas School Book Depository, where the shots had apparently come from. He was in the building during the assassination and fled moments later.
Oswald insisted he had been set up and hadn’t killed anyone. As he was being moved to a county jail, he was shot and killed by Dallas nightclub owner and mobster Jack Ruby.
The new president, Lyndon B. Johnson, set up a special commission to investigate the assassination and Oswald’s subsequent murder.
In September, 1964, after interviewing hundreds of witnesses, police, and other experts, the Warren Commission concluded that: (1) Lee Harvey Oswald had acted alone, (2) Jack Ruby had acted alone and (3) there was no conspiracy to murder President Kennedy.
A Lone Gunman?
As soon as it came out, the report was sharply criticized for its many inconsistencies, as well as its conclusions.
For example, a “home movie” of the incident established that 5.6 seconds elapsed between the first and last bullets which struck the president. Experts have concluded that it would be impossible for anyone to reload Oswald’s rifle and fire three shots at a moving target in under six seconds. On top of that, Oswald was known to be a poor shot.
The film also shows Kennedy’s head being flung violently back and to the left the second time he was hit. This led many assassination experts to believe that the fatal bullet did not come from Oswald’s direction.
These and other inconsistencies strongly suggest that there was more than one gunman, and that the Warren Commission was wrong. In 1978, a congressional committee confirmed this, saying Kennedy “was probably assassinated as a result of a conspiracy.”
A Grand Conspiracy
Enter movie director Oliver Stone. His film chronicles real life New Orleans District Attorney Jim Garrison’s (Kevin Costner) investigation of the assassination.
Garrison prosecutes New Orleans businessman Clay Shaw (Tommy Lee Jones). Shaw, he claims, worked for the CIA and conspired with David Ferrie (Joe Pesci), a local pilot who knew Oswald, and former FBI agent Guy Banister (Ed Asner) to kill Kennedy in a “triangular crossfire.” According to Garrison, Oswald was their “patsy,” or scapegoat.
He ends up with a grand conspiracy theory that involves everyone from anti-Castro groups and the mafia to the FBI, CIA, and even then Vice President Lyndon B. Johnson.
But Garrison can’t convince the jury, and Shaw goes free.
Through Garrison, Stone is essentially putting the U.S. government on trial.
First, the director does a good job of condemning the Warren Commission and its ludicrous findings. Brilliantly using the real “home movie” footage, he recreates the tense atmosphere of that sunny November day in Dallas, and shatters the “lone-assassin” theory.
But Stone can’t resist tackling all the mechanics of the assassination-who did what when and exactly how. He bombards us with details and evidence to counter the official version. It’s an overdose, and if you don’t know a lot about the assassination, you’re likely to get lost in Stone’s forest of information.
When the movie finally gets around to the most important question behind the assassination-why anyone would want to kill Kennedy-Stone’s answer completely misses the mark. His conclusions are based more on his own personal feelings than Garrison’s investigation or the actual facts.
Stone clearly admires Kennedy. He depicts him as the President who wanted to pull troops out of Vietnam, end the Cold War, and normalize relations with Cuba. Stone believes these goals of Kennedy’s led the military-industrial complex to take out his hero.
The notion that a powerful network of weapons manufacturers, military and intelligence officials would be threatened by a dovish president makes a lot of sense.
The Real JFK
But the real John F. Kennedy was as much of a cold warrior as any CIA zealot. Stone fails to consider the Kennedy administration’s massive arms buildup, the failed Bay of Pigs invasion, and assassination of the President of South Vietnam.
Various troubling parts of JFK can be picked at, bit by bit. Stone even uses made-up characters and events to bolster his argument. The movie can perhaps be discredited for this (as the mainstream news media have tried to do.)
But ultimately JFK is much greater than the sum of these parts. In spite of its many flaws, the film should not be dismissed because it blurs fact with fiction or because it idealizes Kennedy and Garrison.
Even though its main point is unsupported, the important thing is that JFK is a story that asks all the right questions about power in this country: who has it, how they use it, and to what extent some people will go to preserve their influence.
Disturbing Questions
It is a film which leaves the viewer questioning the circum-stances around other assassinations-Martin Luther King, Jr., Robert F. Kennedy, and Malcolm X. It also provokes questions about Watergate, Iran/Contra, and the October Surprise.
In the end, a citizenry that knows how to ask questions and that challenges its government is something far more dangerous to those in power than any conspiracy theory.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.