If you haven’t heard of Jackie Chan, get some cash and buy yourself a clue.
Chan is known to anyone who watches Asian Cinema as the first and last action hero (sorry, Arnold). He is notorious for performing his own stunts (especially to those in the medical profession who have had to patch him back together again on many occasions).
Famous all over the world (except in the U.S.), he has been called everything from “the next Bruce Lee” to a “legend in his own time.” Twenty years into his career, the star of such movies as Project A and Drunken Master is finally giving American audiences a taste with Rumble in the Bronx.
I was introduced to Jackie Chan before I even saw his films. When I was young, I always heard his name associated with some phat Kung Fu flick that I never got the chance to see. I finally saw his Snake and Crane Arts of Shaolin about a year ago and I was hooked.
So I’ve been dying to see Rumble in the Bronx but I was also a bit skeptical. Because even though I like Jackie Chan, his movies are a mixed body of work. (I’ve seen four or five of his movies now and while some are really good, others are just excuses to collect paychecks.)
A Cop From Hong Kong
Rumble in the Bronx takes place in…(read the title, stupid) and concerns Keung (Chan), a Hong Kong cop who comes over here to help run his uncle’s supermarket which is “conveniently” located in what seems to be the worst part of New York. The neighborhood features your standard ghetto decor, with graffiti-scrawled buildings, trash and homeless people all around. And, of course, one of the first things Keung sees in the Bronx is cops chasing a robber.
Keung’s uncle ends up selling the store to a new owner, neglecting to tell her about the local gangs that terrorize the place for money and food (sweet person, isn’t he?). The uncle then leaves for Hong Kong but Keung stays behind to finalize the deal and soon finds himself protecting the store from a motorcycle gang. There is also a subplot concerning Keung’s friendship with a young wheelchair-bound boy named Danny whose sister Nancy happens to be the gang leader’s girl.
His Stunts Deserve the Hype
Rumble has a lot of good elements to it. The action scenes are a lot better than most martial artist/actor flicks (people like Mr. How-can-anyone-appear-so-boring-and mechanical? Seagal and Mr. We’re-tired-of-seeing-you-do-the-damn-split-already Van Damme come to mind). And the stunts are all they are hyped up to be. In the course of just one chase scene, Chan jumps out of a van that’s falling off the top floor of a parking lot; gets pinned between a wall and a moving van; and makes an amazing leap of four or five stories from off the roof of one building onto the balcony of another.
But enough praise. On to the faults of the movie.
White Gang Terrorizes the South Bronx?
For one thing Rumble in the Bronx goes overboard in its BDP (Burnt Down Projects) portrayal of the Bronx (especially since it was filmed in Vancouver). And I don’t know, maybe it’s because I’m a New Yorker, but the idea of a mostly White motorcycle gang terrorizing the South Bronx strikes me as ridiculous even for the movies.
But the most faulty thing about Rumble in the Bronx is the plot. It has too many loose ends, like the unresolved romantic tension between Keung and Elaine (the lady who bought the supermarket) and Keung and Nancy (the gang leader’s girl). One moment Elaine seems like a possible love interest for Keung, the next she is comic relief. Then it seems like Nancy and Keung are about to get involved but nothing happens.
An even bigger problem is that the plot changes in the middle of the picture-it goes from being about the supermarket to being about a chase for stolen diamonds.
The Plot Goes Haywire
This happens when a member of the motorcycle gang steals diamonds from a crime lord named the White Tiger and hides them in Nancy’s brother’s wheelchair. One minute, Keung is unleashing a can of ass whupping on the gang and the next minute, he’s helping them escape the wrath of the White Tiger. The whole thing is very confusing. The subsequent chase to recover the jewels has its moments but ends on a flat note.
Now I have to say that even though Rumble in the Bronx has plenty of flaws, it’s still a lot better than most action flicks. Jackie’s sense of humor is a welcome change from the “you killed my brother” tone of most action movies, and his acrobatic antics are always fun to see. Rumble displays this but not to the same degree as much better Jackie Chan movies like The Fearless Hyena or Spiritual Kung Fu.
So for those of you hoping to see Jackie Chan’s greatest work in Rumble in the Bronx, here’s a head check for you: the movie gives you kicks and punches and flips, but if you want a story, carry your own script.
Jackie Chan: The First and Last Action Hero
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.