Having legal immigration status is an important part of planning for the future. When youth age out of foster care with no status, they are stuck. They probably won’t be able to get a job or qualify for other services to help them, and they can be deported.
Undocumented youth do have rights. To find out more, I interviewed Katherine Fleet, a staff attorney in the Immigration Law Unit of the Legal Aid Society. Fleet is a fellow of Kids in Need of Defense, a national organization that works with unaccompanied immigrant youth.
It’s important to remember, though, that every case is different. The answers here are for informational purposes and not the same as legal advice. If you have questions about your own immigration status, you should contact an immigration lawyer who can look at your circumstances and provide the appropriate advice for you.
Q: What does it mean if you’re in the U.S. illegally?
A: Being undocumented means you don’t have documents from the U.S. government saying that you have legal status-basically, you don’t have official permission to be here.
Q: So if you’re an undocumented immigrant in foster care, does that mean your rights are different from other kids in foster care?
A: Here in New York City, Children’s Services (ACS) will accept any eligible youth into foster care, regardless of immigration status. While in foster care, every child should get medical care, education programs, housing, and help planning for the future.
However, they don’t have the right to work, so they won’t have access to most employment programs. Paying for college is also difficult for undocumented youth because they can’t get federal financial aid.
Q: What’s the difference between a visa and a green card?
A: They are different forms of permission to be here in the U.S. A visa is usually more temporary and lets you come here to do a specific thing, like travel or study. Visas are only valid for a certain amount of time. The moment the visa expires or you violate its terms, you’re in the U.S. without status and you can be deported.
A green card, on the other hand, lets you stay in the U.S. as a “lawful permanent resident.” Getting a green card can eventually lead to citizenship. Being a permanent resident allows you to work, study, and come and go from the U.S. But you can still be deported if you break the rules.
You have to renew a green card, usually within 10 years. Consult an immigration expert before applying to renew your card to be sure you won’t have any problems.
Q: How do you apply for a green card?
A: For youth in foster care, the most common ways are through Special Immigrant Juvenile Status (SIJS, discussed below) or the U visa, which is for victims of certain crimes. There are also other ways, and it’s important to consult with a lawyer to figure out your options.
If you’re in foster care, your foster care agency should refer you to an immigration expert. It’s important to take care of this well before you age out. But don’t contact immigration authorities or make an application on your own without first getting guidance from a lawyer; sometimes, contacting immigration can lead to being deported.
It’s also really important to be careful if you travel or get arrested and are in contact with police, jails, certain courts, etc. If you are ever arrested and go to court, make sure your lawyer knows your immigration status.
Q: What is Special Immigrant Juvenile Status?
A: SIJS is a way for foster care youth (and certain other youth), to stay in the country, work, and eventually get a green card. If you’re in foster care and are undocumented, talk to an immigration lawyer to find out if you qualify for SIJS.
Each state is a little different. But generally, to qualify for SIJS, you have to be separated from at least one of your parents due to problems like abuse, neglect, or abandonment. You have to be involved with a court (if you’re in foster care, you probably are already) and the judge has to say it’s not best for you to go back to the country you’re from. You have to be under 21, and, in some states, you must be under 18 by the time you file.
Q: What is a U visa?
A: A U visa is a temporary status that can lead to a green card later on. It’s for people who have been victims of certain crimes, like domestic violence, rape, torture, or trafficking [tricking or forcing someone to work for little or no pay, often in dangerous jobs like prostitution or hard labor], and who help law enforcement with investigations or prosecutions. Many youth in foster care qualify because they are domestic violence victims.
Q: Can you be deported if you are in foster care and don’t have legal status?
A: Yes. But you have the right to appear before a judge to make the case for why you shouldn’t be deported, and being in foster care may give you some extra protections.
Q: What should you do if you’re in the U.S. illegally?
A: Get advice from an immigration lawyer as soon as you can and stay out of trouble with the law. If you commit a crime, that will make it harder to get legal status in the future. In some places-though not everywhere-police will give your name to immigration authorities if you get arrested. And sometimes immigration officials conduct interviews in jails or detention centers.
If you’re charged with a crime, make sure your lawyer knows your status. If you’re questioned by immigration, it’s probably best not to sign papers or answer questions until you speak to a lawyer. Also, it’s probably best not to travel outside the U.S.; once you leave, you may not be able to come back legally.
Definitely don’t lie and say you’re a U.S. citizen when you’re not. This could hurt your chances of ever getting a green card, and it might get you deported.
Q: Can having a child in the U.S. help you become legal?
A: No. A child can only help its parent get papers if the child is a U.S. citizen and is over 21. And even then there are a lot of other requirements that make it very difficult.
Q: What if your parents are in the U.S. illegally?
A: Getting a green card through SIJS won’t help your parents. The U visa can help parents and siblings, depending on the circumstances. If your parents are crime victims, that may also be a way for you to get legal status.
Q: Can your parents be deported if they’re in the U.S. illegally when you apply for a green card?
A: I haven’t seen parents being targeted for deportation when their child goes through the process for SIJS. But there are lots of other ways people who are undocumented can get identified.
Q: What will happen to you if your parents get deported?
A: If you’re in foster care, family court usually decides what’s in your best interest. It’s up to them whether it’s better for you to go with your parent or stay here. What’s in your best interest depends on a lot of different things, including who you’d live with and what your life would be like here or in the other country.
If you want to remain in the U.S., tell your lawyer. It’s very unlikely that a court would allow a child-even if the child is undocumented-to be deported with an abusive parent.
Q: So what if you’re in foster care and you don’t really feel like you’re getting support with your case?
A: You’ve got to be persistent. Start with the lawyer representing you in court. Ask them to put you in touch with an immigration lawyer. If your lawyer doesn’t help you, ask your caseworker or his/her supervisor. If you don’t want to give them information about your immigration status, just say you want general information about immigration and make sure they send you to talk to someone. If you feel like people aren’t doing what they’re supposed to, go to your family court hearings and tell the judge.
A longer version of this interview, including information about getting an I.D., passport, and other documents, appears on our website. Follow this link: http://tinyurl.com/yafvl9s
The Dream Act
There are bills now in Congress that would help undocumented youth. One is a proposal called The Dream Act. It would provide legal status to certain youth who came to the U.S. before they were 16 and who go to high school or get a GED, and then go on to college or the military. There is also a new immigration reform bill that would include the Dream Act and a lot of other improvements for immigrants. For more information, visit www.dreamact2009.org
Helpful Resources
Nationwide
The Immigrant Legal Resource Center has helpful general information: (415) 255-9499
www.ilrc.org
Kids in Need of Defense can connect you with help in your area: (202)â824-8680
www.supportkind.org
You can also ask your lawyer for the best contacts in your area.
In New York
The Door (212) 941-9090
www.door.org
The Legal Aid Society
(212) 577-3300
www.legal-aid.org
Lawyers for Children
(212) 966-6420
www.lawyersforchildren.org
Immigration and Foster Care
What You Need to Know
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.