I’m a Downloading Demon

I’m a downloading demon. In the past six days, I’ve clocked 87 songs. And I wasn’t using Napster.
The name Napster was once synonymous with MP3s and as Winnie, a fellow NYC writer, said: “Free. Music. Download.”
But Napster had to shut down on July 2 to upgrade its filter. And when Napster comes back to life, which the company says will be before the end of the year, it’ll be a subscription-based service. Users will have to pay a small monthly fee to download songs.
Plus, the downloaded songs will only play in Napster, because the files will be converted to Napster’s own format, .nap. That means you can’t transfer the songs you download to a CD for mobile listening or back-up purposes.
Inspired by the Jerky Boys
Ah, for the good old days. My first encounter with Napster was in 1999. I was hanging with my friends when one of them, Richie, reenacted a Jerky Boys prank call about balloons. After we had caught our breath from laughing, we asked him where he heard this bit so we could listen to it, too. His response was Napster.
“Huh? Hamster?” I asked. “What’s that?”
“No. Not Hamster, Napster,” he replied. “It’s this program that lets you download any song you want.” He explained that all you have to do is type in the name of the artist and song, wait for results, and voila, you can listen to it to your heart’s content.
Songs at My Fingertips
When I went home that evening, I went to napster.com. It took me less than 15 minutes to download the peer-to-peer software application. For my first search, I typed in “Jerky Boys” in the “artist” field. Of the long list of files that came up, I didn’t see any files with “balloons” in the name, but I downloaded some other Jerky Boys’ prank calls.
Then I downloaded a few Tupac Shakur songs. I thought it was cool to have such a large selection at my fingertips-literally.
But I stopped using Napster after that night. Part of it was that I had better things to do, like school and hanging out with friends. But I was also against piracy of any sort and the idea of getting all these songs for free bothered me somewhat.
Not Like Bootlegging
Still, I returned to Napster several months later. I couldn’t resist my wanting to get Lenny Kravitz, Jimi Hendrix and unreleased Eminem songs all for the right price: nothing.
I decided that it wasn’t like I was a bootlegger, who makes copies of records or movies to sell for a profit. Bootleggers rip off artists and record companies because people buy their fake records instead of the legitimate ones, so the bootleggers get money instead of the record companies and artists.
My downloading songs from Napster was like borrowing a CD from a friend, and maybe taping a couple of songs. I don’t see anything wrong with that.
Trying Before Buying
Soon, I was swept away in the river of Napster. Whenever I had free time, I’d download a song or two or three. I started to listen to genres and artists I’d never considered before.
My interest in No Doubt, KottenMouth Kings, Musiq Soulchild, Black Sabbath, Beck, Oasis, Crystal Method and many others increased or started because I was able to inexpensively and easily sample their music.
I see the free exchange of music as something very beneficial to the consumer. Trying out music before you buy it is like trying on a pair of sneakers before buying them. I don’t want to pay $13 to $17 for a CD and an hour later find out that it doesn’t fit my tastes.
Testing Napster’s Filter
But the major record labels disagree with me. In December 1999, the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) sued Napster for copyright infringement.
Napster users exchanging MP3 files was like stealing, said the RIAA, since people got the songs without paying the record companies, songwriters, music publishers and artists any money.
After a court ruling in March 2001, Napster was forced to install a filter to keep users from accessing copyrighted songs.
I tested the filter a few months later by running a search for Eminem without any specified song title. After about 15 seconds (longer than usual), a usual 300+ list returned. Most of the file names were slightly altered, though; users were playing with copyrighted songs’ file names to get past the filter.
For example, I found Eminem’s “Stan” under file names like Stan4.mp3, Stn.mp3 and StanABC.mp3.
Napster’s Cousins Spring Up
Rather than deal with the confusion of altered names, many music sharers turned to alternative applications and sites. Cousins of Napster, like Aimster, Kazaa, Rapigator, Gnutella and Bear Share, started to surface when Napster’s legal battles intensified in February and March 2001.
At first, these peer-to-peer cousins had only a small fraction of Napster’s more than 1,000,000 available songs. But as Napster’s filter became better-or worse, depending on your position-its users started moving over to alternate sites.
Record Industry Wants Us to Pay
But the major record labels of the RIAA want to control the way people get music over the internet. They’re hoping that free file-trading applications and sites will be replaced by fee-based services-the new-look Napster and two new record-industry services, RealNetwork’s MusicNet and Pressplay.
MusicNet is backed by AOL Time Warner, EMI Group and Bertelsmann’s BMG. Pressplay is Sony and Vivendi Universal’s online music service. Both services plan to make room for independent labels, but haven’t yet planned to make room for their major label rivals.
Limited Selections
For example, if I was a Pressplay subscriber, I could get Destiny’s Child and No Doubt songs because Destiny’s Child is on the Sony label and No Doubt is on Interscope, a Universal label. But Madonna, the Red Hot Chili Peppers and Missy Elliot are all under AOL Time Warner, so I’d have to be a MusicNet subscriber to get their songs.
On either service, the music you download will only be playable on the computer to which you downloaded the file; you can’t transfer the music (yet) to any other devices or computers. And those files won’t have high, CD-quality sound.
Why Pay to Play?
Pressplay and MusicNet use a technique called streaming; instead of saving the file to your hard drive, you run the file directly from the site. That means you have to be online to listen to it.
And with streaming, there’s buffering to deal with. Buffering is when the song momentarily halts and waits for the data before it resumes streaming. The slower the connection, the more annoying buffering interruptions there are.
With all of these detractions, it amazes me that record companies believe these services will be widely used. It’s hard to believe that the 70 million ex-Napster users are going to flock to a pay-to-download service as long as there are over a dozen other applications that allow you to share music files for free and without any label limitations.
Free Music Sharing Keeps Going
But if these corporations knock out the competition through legal suits, the future of music file-swapping on the Internet is gloomy. Not only will we not be able to sample well-known musicians’ work, but our exposure to more obscure music will be limited, too.
Ever hear of Domestic Oblivion? Probably not, but you might discover some tracks from their first album (which my dad co-produced) through WinMX or another free file-sharing application. And while Napster’s free peer-to-peer cousins offer bootleg live recordings, unreleased compositions and freestyles, the music-label-based services won’t.
So far, though, it seems that for every Napster that goes down, there’ll be another application to take its place. At least for a short while, the free mainstream music-swapping business will be in business. And I’ll be home-downloading to my heart’s content.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.