I Wanted to Be Pretty and Popular

I Wanted to Be Pretty and Popular

As a freshman, I thought that I wasn’t beautiful enough for people to like me at my high school. That was difficult to deal with because I wanted to be popular.
I’m originally from Haiti. There, I felt gorgeous. I felt as if I didn’t have to do anything to fit in with people at school. We had to wear uniforms, which meant we didn’t worry about who was more stylish.
I didn’t have to worry about being popular because I’d spent six years in the same school and more than enough students knew who I was.
Focus on Mariah and J.Lo
But once I arrived here at age 11, I began to feel insecure. My cousin would talk about stars like Mariah Carey and Jennifer Lopez, saying how beautiful they were and that she wished she had their kind of body.
Back in Haiti, girls my age didn’t really go on about the bodies of stars. But after listening to my cousin, I began to think about how I looked. I wasn’t sure if I was as sexy or beautiful as these stars.
I also felt insecure because my cousin was smaller than me, which was devastating. I wanted to have the same kind of body she and her friends had.
Sometimes when I looked in the mirror, I saw one of the ugliest girls in the world. Ever since I was little, I’d been getting bumps on my face from eating peanut butter and chocolate. My doctor said it was an allergic reaction.
I tried to stop eating these foods but I couldn’t help myself. When I had these bumps, my mother sometimes said that my face looked ugly, which made me sad. It hurt my feelings to hear that from my mother.
Wanted the Latina Look
My looks were still an issue when I started 9th grade at Brooklyn’s International HS. But instead of wanting to have my cousin’s body, I wanted to look like the Spanish-speaking girls there. I thought they were beautiful.
At International HS, around half of the students are Latina. It was mostly the Latina girls who wore very tight pants, and some had belly-showing shirts. Many of the other girls covered their bodies, particularly if they were Muslim.
I thought the Latina girls’ styles made them look very sexy. Some of them had the body that I dreamed of having. They had almost the perfect butt and chest size. They had slim hips and beautiful faces.
Their hair was longer than mine and looked soft. Some of them also liked to wear lipstick and eye shadow. Since I didn’t feel beautiful, I wanted to have their look.
I Thought ‘Popular’ Meant ‘Pretty’
A particular set of Latina girls was well-known in the school. When I first saw them, I thought that they were popular only because of their style and because they had the attitude of girls who like to have fun.
And since they were the most beautiful in the school in my eyes, I thought that the only way a girl could be popular was if she was pretty too. I didn’t realize the other reason for the Latina girls’ popularity was because the school was mostly Spanish-speaking.
I envied them. I was jealous because I wanted to be surrounded by so many friends. I was already friends with some Haitian girls I’d known from junior high. But some of them would talk about me behind my back and create drama. So I felt I’d be happier if I made new friends.
I wanted to befriend the Latina crew. I wanted to get to know them not only because of their looks and popularity, but because they were older and seemed to treat each other with respect. (Of course, I had no way of really knowing this.)
Changed My Eating Habits
I wanted to be one of them so much that I decided not to eat some of the things that I knew could make me gain weight, like McDonald’s, pizza or any other junk food, for a whole month. I also stayed away from peanut butter and chocolate to prevent the bumps.
I started going to a gym near my house to work out every weekend. Then one day, a month after I started to go to the gym, I made another change. I bought lipstick, eye shadow, face powder, lip liners and eye liners. I went home and gave myself a makeover. I put on my tight jeans and belly-showing T-shirts.
I looked new. I looked like the kind of person who lots of people would think of as beautiful.
I was satisfied. I started to carry a mirror in my book bag to look at the pretty face that I’d created. That’s when I started to call myself “Sabrina the Princess.” As a result, I felt stronger and more confident.
Mom Didn’t Like the Princess
But my mother didn’t like what I’d done to myself. Every time I wore one of my shirts, she said “You are going to wear something over that, right?” I would say “yes,” and leave with a shirt closed over my midriff; then, when I got to school, I’d open it.
But I was still the same person, and I didn’t like that. I was quiet around anyone I met, so I decided to change my attitude, too. I thought the only way to be popular was to be like the Spanish-speaking kids, who seemed very outgoing.
So I gave my attitude a little touch up and started acting like the popular Latina crew. I started to look tough and walk sexy. Still, not many people talked to me.
I did make some new friends because they were in my class. But I wanted to be friends with the most popular Latinas because I wanted everybody in school to know who I was.
Trying to Connect With the Popular Crew
I spent the rest of 9th grade trying to connect with those girls. I sometimes sat next to them in English or social studies class. But they would say nothing to me.
I tried to start conversations with them by saying “Hi.” They said, “Oh, hi.” And that was it. I had no clue what would work to get them to acknowledge me.
I was upset and didn’t know how to handle my feelings. So my sweet self started to change into the kind of person I would’ve never wanted to become. I started to not do my homework. I also started to ignore my mother when she was talking to me.
Remembered an Old Promise
During the summer after 9th grade, I thought a lot about what happened. I remembered when I was 10 and knew I was coming to America. My uncle was worried that I would become too Americanized, so I made a promise that I wouldn’t change myself for somebody to like me.
I thought about my promise now as I wrote down my thoughts in my journal. I felt horrible writing about how I was acting because I wasn’t listening to my true feelings. But making friends was more important to me than anything else. And I thought to make friends I had to change.
Maury to the Rescue
Then one morning in September, before the fall semester started, I turned on the TV and began to watch The Maury Povich Show. It was about girls who wanted to be popular so badly that they tried to make themselves smaller.
They would spend days without eating. Their mothers were worried about them, so they asked Maury for help.
Maury gave the girls advice that I also needed to hear. He said, “Don’t try so hard to be popular in school. If you do want to be popular, just be yourself and if the kids don’t like you as you, then they don’t deserve your friendship.”
That made me think about what I was trying to do. Then I realized that I had to be me, Sabrina, and be happy with who I am and not change myself for anybody.
That same day, I wrote in my journal about what Maury had said and what it meant to me.
I wrote: “Changing myself to fit in a certain crowd is not what I want to do. My mother always taught me how to respect myself and this time I didn’t.
“I disrespected myself by thinking that they’d become my friends if I changed my looks and the way I act. I don’t have to change myself for them to like me.”
Back to School
I soon returned to school to start 10th grade. The girls I wanted to be friends with last year were in some of the same classes as me. I decided to show them the real me. The Sabrina who is sweet and funny and doesn’t obsess about how she looks.
In math class, for instance, I started helping them by explaining problems they didn’t understand. That made it easier for us to start talking about other things, like boys!
Eventually, as we got to know each other better, we started going to the Manhattan Mall to hang out and buy stuff that we didn’t need, like sunglasses and clothes. We soon became good friends.
We now tell each other secrets and help each other with our homework. We laugh at each other’s jokes. I feel like I belong and that they’re going to be some of my best friends for a long time, no matter where they are.
Popular on My Own Terms
I’ve also become popular in school by just being myself. Before, I thought that if the Spanish-speaking crew were my friends, everybody else would know who I was.
But I’m pretty well-known among both students and staff members by interacting with them on my own rather than just being automatically known as one of the popular girls. (Doing your work and having a sense of humor helps.)
I still wear makeup and belly-button showing tops, but not as much as I used to. And I’ve gone back to eating chocolate and peanut butter despite my bumps.
My appearance right now doesn’t matter as much to me. I love myself for who I am.
I always go back to read old journal entries. When I get to the page where I wrote about what Maury said about changing who you are to fit into the popular crowd, I realize I never want to go back to that planet again.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.