I Thought Hispanics Were All Alike

Hispanic youth in New York City say they tend to be categorized as a single group. But not all Hispanics have the same culture.
“People seem to think that because we all speak Spanish we are all the same. Not true,” says Ariel Sepulveda, 17, from the Dominican Republic.
“The people just automatically think that we’re all alike. I never had this problem, but when I speak Spanish, people just don’t want to help me,” comments Gisela Joa-Mok, 19, of Cuba.
“They seem to think we speak the same language and have the same traditions more or less. People just bunch us up as one group,” says Marybel Villanueva, Adlai Stevenson HS, 15, a Puerto Rican.
Light vs. Dark Hispanics
Racial prejudice has often been a problem for some Hispanics-and often this prejudice comes from other Hispanics.
Erick, 17, from Puerto Rico, says, “Dark Hispanics are also prejudiced against White Hispanics, because since I have blue eyes, blond hair, and live in a mostly White neighborhood, they call me a fake Hispanic. But I’m proud of my heritage.”
Pablo, 17, of the Dominican Republic, says, “Many Hispanics discriminate against me and my friends because we are dark and Dominican. White Hispanics are just as bad as White Americans, because they judge us because of skin and not our mind. I think it’s sad, because we all belong to the same culture and you always feel the tension of racism.”
Some Hispanic teens feel that non-Hispanics have no knowledge of their cultures.
Unaware of Different Cultures
“I think that if they do discriminate, it’s because they don’t know anything about Hispanic cultures,” states Martha Flores, 19, of Nicaragua.
“Some of them know, but my problem is that I am very light-skinned, so I look like I only speak English,” Marybel says.
“People say that all Puerto Ricans are loud and criminals. Jewish people think that all Puerto Ricans are out to rob them,” commented Lupe Ortega, a 12-year-old Dominican at PS 19 in Brooklyn.
“People always think that I am Puerto Rican, but I am not,” she added. “I am from Santo Domingo (in the Dominican Republic). Maybe someday people will learn that there are other countries in Latin America besides Puerto Rico.”
Hispanic students have a strong reaction to being categorized.
“I identify more with Santo Domingo because that’s where I was raised and that’s the life that I know,” Gisela says.
“I still identify with my original country because it doesn’t matter where I am or where I go, I’ll always have my Puerto Rican culture inside of me,” responds Marybel.
Many of the teens that we spoke with are proud of their cultures.
Jose Ubiles, 17, from Puerto Rico, says, “I was born and raised in Puerto Rico. My parents taught me to be proud of it and no one could take that away.”
‘Proud to be Puerto Rican’
Marybel Villanueva says, “Of course I’m proud, because I’m Puerto Rican and I shouldn’t be ashamed of where I come from or who I am.”
Hispanic cultures do differ in many ways.
Martha Flores, of Nicaragua, says, “Our country has always been a hard-working country. They fight for their rights and for what they think is best for them. They’re still fighting for their human rights and will fight on to the end. Not every country is fighting for their rights like mine is.”
“The music and dance of my country is Merengue,” says Ariel Sepulveda of the Dominican Republic. “We eat sugar cane and we have beautiful beaches. When the Spanish came to my country, we were divided into five parts, then we got together as one. The culture differs by its music and also by the different types of Spanish spoken with different accents.”
Many Hispanics have seen and felt first-hand the effects of stereotyping. What can be done to stop this?
“We should let the people know that we could be just like them. We are all equal, both in our workplace and intellectually,” says 19-year-old Gisela from Cuba.
Some teens feel that prejudice cannot be stopped.
“There is absolutely no way to stop these stereotypes, because people are going to believe whatever they want, whether or not there is any truth to it,” remarked John Gonzales, a half-Black, half-Puerto Rican 17-year-old at Humanities HS.
“I think everyone has their own little belief in what they think an ethnic group is like,” he added. “You can’t stop people from thinking what they want. So I guess those who are criticized will just have to ignore it.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.