When I went into care, I thought that foster parents would help me out and care for me unconditionally. I had no idea that they got paid, so I thought all these people were incredibly kind and generous. But I found out that many of them aren’t. I also found out that the foster care system has a lot of flaws.
I went into care five years ago, when I was 12. My friend’s mother reported my parents when her son saw my father beating me with a milk crate and my parents arguing violently with each other. Children’s Protective Services (CPS) came over and in half an hour, they rendered their verdict. My father was arrested and my three brothers, my sister, and I were carted off to Kings County Hospital to be examined.
We returned home early the next morning to find our mother sitting on the front stoop. Without a word, we all went upstairs and climbed into bed. Everyone was tired, and we all wanted some peace. About a week later, we went to a CPS office, and they told us that they were taking us to a new home, with kind strangers who wouldn’t abuse us. “Everything will be alright,” one of the CPS workers in the office told me. My three brothers, my sister and I were all sent to different homes.
I was relieved to be away from the violence and abuse in my parents’ home, but it seemed wrong and unnatural being apart from my siblings, the people who look so much like me. I missed sharing jokes with my sister and watching TV with my brothers.
My foster care agency made a bad assumption that I’d be better off staying in the same neighborhood I grew up in. The agency tried to keep everything in my life besides family consistent-neighborhood, school, and friends. But living in the same area made me feel exposed and vulnerable. My “friends,” who had lived on the same block as me for years, knew the play-by-play of my parents’ violence. I was embarrassed of my family and my life situation.
Respect Our Privacy
I was happy to finally get away from the physical and emotional abuse, but I was ashamed that everyone knew our business. I wish the agency had consulted me on where I wanted to live.
I also wished that my teachers in school had been paying closer attention all along. For years, no one seemed to care what went on between my parents and us kids or even notice that my parents behaved like savages. Our cuts and bruises went unnoticed underneath the long sleeve shirts we had to wear as part of our school uniform. My siblings and I never tried telling anyone about it. What could we say? “Mommy was mad at Daddy, so Daddy hit me for spilling a plate of food?”
There was no way that I could comfortably discuss what went on in my family. Even if they’re being abused, kids might be ashamed or protective of their parents. If an adult suspects abuse, s/he should ask, “How are things in your home between your parents and siblings?” I think most kids don’t like to open up about the things that bother us, but it’s easier if the person offers help. don’t make the kid you’re asking feel like you’re interested only in the story and the gossip, and not his feelings or fate.
Even after my siblings and I went into care, people didn’t follow through on their initial offers of help. Teachers would ask me if I was alright, or if there was anything that I wanted to talk about. The kids from my block wanted to know if my father was in jail. But after that, I was never asked how I felt, or if I was OK where I was. It made it hard to look at and talk to classmates, teachers, and staff, without feeling like they were pitying, looking down on, or shunning me.
Better Ways to Help
I saw a therapist, once a week, for about a year. She had me talk about what I was feeling, and at the end of each session, she’d offer suggestions to help with my various issues. She showed me that she wanted to help me find solutions, not just talk endlessly. I decided I could open up to her. We connected, and she helped me to get some of the more negative ideas out of my head.
My caseworkers weren’t much good at helping me feel like a human and not a statistic. They came over to visit the foster home and check out how everything was going. They wanted to talk to the foster parents, and only asked me foster care-related questions. No one asked me about any good books that I’ve read or what movies I’d like to see. There wasn’t a personal connection. It seemed as if they weren’t concerned with me at all, just with having things to report to their bosses, co-workers, and courts.
Getting beaten with a milk crate is about as low as a person can go, so moving in with my first foster mother, Ms. Reynolds, was an improvement. She was an older woman, and we lived in a house with her two other children and another foster kid. My foster brother and I got along. Ms. Reynolds bought us Christmas presents, and there were videogames to play and a computer to Instant-Message friends. Occasionally, Ms. Reynolds would have us eat dinner with her, or make us breakfast. She even took us to Atlantic City once with her daughter, son-in-law, and grandson.
Ms. Reynolds and I had a honeymoon period of about five or six months. But even in that time, she sometimes spoke to me harshly. She told me off for making sandwiches that were too big, for talking on the phone for too long, and for spending all my allowance to buy my own cellphone.
Worst of all, six months after moving in with her, I still only had about a week’s worth of clothing. When I came into care, my clothes were in bad condition, and Ms. Reynolds told me to throw away everything that wasn’t “decent and presentable.” But she wouldn’t buy me any new clothes. When I would ask, she kept saying that she didn’t have the money, and I believed her. It’s expensive to maintain a household-I knew that from my mother’s constant remarks of how high the electricity bills can be.
Bombshell
And then my caseworker dropped the bombshell: Foster parents get paid. And they get a clothing allowance for each child.
I was appalled! For six months, I’d had to wash the same clothes over and over. How can a person work, have other people who work in the house, and get money to take care of foster kids, but not buy us the things we need? I asked Ms. Reynolds that and she replied, “What I do with my money is my business. The check is in my name. Guess who it belongs to, then?”
The honeymoon ended then. She said I was out of line and intrusive. I felt like I was asking the things that I desperately needed to know. We never saw eye to eye after that.
We both agreed that the best course of action was for me to be removed from her home. After Ms. Reynolds’s I was moved five times. I requested three of those moves. In one home, my foster mother volunteered me for her friend’s day camp just to have me supervised for free while she worked. And she didn’t give me any food money so I had to go all day without eating. Another foster mother had a chore system that allowed us to earn up to $10 a week. As a form of punishment, she would deduct whatever amount she thought was justifiable. Ten dollars a week wasn’t enough to go to the movies with my friends, or to even buy food during a long school day. And she called me greedy for wanting more.
The only foster father I’ve had talked to his family about me right in front of me, as if I were a poster on the wall. He disrespected me in my presence to teachers and caseworkers when he heard something about me he didn’t like.
Learning that the system was really a business made me feel like an object. Just a name on a bunch of papers sitting in a file cabinet. I was promised that I’d be taken care of and nurtured and that I wouldn’t have to worry about a thing, but my foster parents seemed to be using the money for their needs and not mine. I felt let down by the entire world. I wish that foster parents could put themselves in our shoes. We depend on them for so much, and the way they treat us leaves a lasting impression.
The Right Way to Foster Parent
But after five lousy foster homes, I finally have a comfortable placement. I am exceptionally fond of my foster mother. Wanda’s home – it’s just Wanda, her daughter, and me-is different because we communicate. She and I are straight up with each other, without the awkward moments that sometimes pop up when we discuss personal issues and agendas. I call her Auntie, Ms. Wanda, or simply Miss.
I can tell her that I’m going to see my mother or siblings, and she’ll say, “Have fun! Tell your mother I said hi!” She isn’t trying to keep me from meeting with them; she acknowledges my family. Instead of leaving it up to me to figure out how I’ll deal with an issue, she helps in whatever way she can. She approaches me in a manner that is respectful and unthreatening. She doesn’t make me feel like I’m stupid, or worthless, or a waste of time, space, money, and energy.
She lets me know that, “Your opinion may not always count, but I’m still going to run things by you.” Once, Wanda wanted to go to the casino with her girlfriends, and she gave me two days’ notice to make an all-day plan because I couldn’t stay home alone. I told her I had nowhere to go, so she gave me $50 so I could go to a movie, buy lunch, and stop off at a friend’s house later. In other foster homes, the parents would just put me out and let me figure out what to do without giving me spending money.
Ms. Wanda’s helping me prepare for college by taking me shopping for some of the things that I’ll need on campus. Most foster parents aren’t concerned with your school life until they get a call with bad news. But Ms. Wanda asks if I did my homework or when the next report card is. She treats me like a part of the family. On the Fourth of July, she insisted that I hang out with the rest of the family, even though I’m not really much for social events. But she wasn’t forcing me to do it. She said it in a way that hinted that I was included, and my presence would be missed.
The intention of the foster care system is very noble: to provide homes for youth in precarious situations. But people’s thoughts and feelings must be accounted for in this complex equation: Foster care isn’t as black and white as running a business, and too often the youths aren’t listened to or treated compassionately.
When the system does work, it’s because of individuals making the effort to communicate. The best way for a foster parent and foster youth to get along is to talk. Approach each other from many different angles and try to imagine yourself in the other person’s shoes. Be open-minded and listen to each other.
don’t Suffer in Silence
Here are toll-free phone numbers for child abuse hotlines in every state. If you are being abused or neglected, call your state’s 800 number and report it: bit.ly/abusehotlines.
