House Arrest

When my Father Died, I Became My Brother's Prisoner

My father died four years ago, when I was 14. Since then, my older brother has taken control of my life. This is the worst thing that’s ever happened to me.
My brother is only one year older than me, but after my father’s death, the rest of the family said that he had to take the place of my dad.
My Brother’s the Boss
Now my mom listens to him and gives him whatever he wants because he is her favorite. The two of them can talk about anything. If my brother has a girlfriend or gets into any trouble, he will talk to my mom about it.
But if I try to talk to her about certain things-like if I want to go out with my friends or have a boyfriend-she just gets mad. My brother is allowed to party, hang out with friends and go on dates. I am not.
It was different when my dad was alive. He trusted me and I could talk to him about anything. He always helped me when I was in trouble and always made me feel important.
My brother is even worse than my mother-overprotective and controlling. He is always telling me what to do. I can’t wear short clothes. I can’t talk on the phone longer than 15 minutes because he will say, “I’m not paying the bill.”
If I go to the gym in the evening, I have to come home no later than 9 p.m. If I am hanging out with my friend right in front of our house, he will tell me to come inside. He is always telling me, “If you don’t do what I say, you have to leave the house.”
Old-Fashioned Ways
My family is from Guyana and has the old-fashioned ways. They believe that if a girl wears short clothes, or hangs out with guys, or goes to clubs, she is disgracing the family.
They believe that if you are going out with a guy, he has to become your husband-no dating lots of different guys before you get married.
Even when I was living back in Guyana, these rules were a problem for me. I was never allowed to go out shopping by myself or wear jeans or bring friends to my house.
These things didn’t bother me when I was in school because I was thinking of my studies. But when I started working, at age 16, that changed. I started to rebel.
I would go out by myself and invite my friends to my house. But my mom and brother always made comments like, “Why are you bringing your friend over? Why can’t you keep by yourself?”
I Want a Life!
Having no freedom was hard to take when I was 16 in Guyana. Now that I am 18 and living in New York City, it’s unbearable.
In Guyana, some girls cannot leave their parents’ house until they are married, but in New York it is different. I see that girls my age are allowed to do anything, like go to clubs and hang out late at night.
But my mother and brother want my life to consist of just school and work, because they think that will keep me from doing anything “wrong,” like having a boyfriend or hanging out with friends or drinking or getting into fights.
They want me to always wear long dresses or jeans, never a miniskirt. In my free time, they want me to stay home, watching TV or reading.
I can’t stand it. I want to have a social life. “All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy,” as the old saying goes.
My mom says, “When you get married, you can do what you want or what your husband allows you to do.” But I don’t want to wait that long to have a good time.
Compared to me, my friends are having a wonderful life. When I tell friends what I am going through, they say, “You got a heart to take it.”
Every weekend they ask me if I am going out with them. When I refuse because my family won’t allow it, they get mad at me.
It’s hard to keep friends when you are not allowed to go out at night. And it’s impossible to have a boyfriend. I meet a lot of guys, but the relationships don’t last because I cannot go out on dates.
Sometimes I Break the Rules
Even though I don’t do anything wrong, my mother and brother treat me like I do. I am sick of being a good girl and not getting any reward for it, so sometimes I break the rules.
I buy short clothes and hide them under my bed so my mom won’t find them, and then I wear them to school. I make sure I get home early, before my mother and brother. Or I wear them when I work nights because they’re usually asleep by the time I get home.
So far I haven’t gotten caught, but if I ever was, my mother would throw all my short clothes away.
My brother and I are always getting into arguments because I try to fight for my rights. I get mad and tell him that he doesn’t have any right to control me. Then he gets mad.
‘You are the Problem’
Sometimes he hits me, but I told him I’m going to call the police the next time he does that.
Other times he says he is going to move out and live by himself. When he says that, my mom gets mad at me and says, “I prefer you leave because you are causing the problem.”
My mom always takes my brother’s side. He was her first child and she likes him more than me. Sometimes she tells me that I came into this world by mistake because she was not planning to have another baby.
Sometimes I wish I was not born, because what is the use of living when you cannot have any fun? I try to occupy my time with working, going to school and going to the gym, so I don’t have to spend much time at home.
Sometimes I feel like running away because my family makes my life miserable if I don’t do what they say. But I don’t want to leave the house now because I am going to school full-time and working part-time. The money I make is enough to buy my clothes and lunch, but it’s not enough to pay rent.
I Was Daddy’s Girl
I wish my father were alive. I don’t feel the same without him. I was daddy’s girl. I could tell him when I was in trouble and he would give me advice. He always had faith in me and said I would be a better person than my brother. If he were here, my life would be completely different.
I know this because, when I was 13, a guy wrote me a love letter. My mother found it and she started hitting me. Then my father came in and rescued me.
I had already told him about the guy and he said having a boyfriend or someone close was OK, as long as there was no hugging or kissing.
He said I should know myself and be careful. I still broke up with the boy who wrote me the letter because my mom told me that if I continued the relationship, she would take me out of school.
My Father Listened
I know that even if my father was alive, I wouldn’t always get my way. There would be disagreements between my parents because my father would want to allow me to do certain things and my mom would not.
He might not always win the argument, but at least I would have someone who listened to me and took my side. And that would make all the difference in the world.
But I have to deal with the situation as it is. The fact that I have rebelled and argued with my mother and brother over the the rules I consider unfair has made things a little better. Now at least they let me go shopping by myself and I can have my friends visit my house.
If I hadn’t fought them, I would still be shopping with my mom and only seeing my friends at school. I feel better because I have gotten them to give up a little of their control over me.
I Want Out
Right now though, what I really want to do is start college so I can move out of my house. (Even though I finished high school in Guyana, I have to do the GED over here, so that I can go to college.)
I will finish my GED in December, and I will apply to college for the spring semester. I want to live in a dorm, so I can go to parties and hang out with friends and have a social life. I know my mom will be mad at me if I go and live in a dorm but I don’t care.
My mother wants me to wait until I get married to have a life but that’s not the right solution for me. Before I get married, I want to travel, party, have fun with friends and get a good job.
Most of all, I want to be in control of my life and have the freedom to make decisions for myself.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.