There are 26 young men living on a ranch in the middle of the desert. They wake up early in the morning to bale hay, make breakfast, or graze the cattle. Except for holidays, they are forbidden to leave. Would you say that this is, (a) a training ground for future cowboys, (b) a prison, or (c) a college? The answer is (c), Deep Springs College in California.
When many people think of college they think of lectures, exams, grades, majors, fraternities, and sororities. But not all colleges fall into the same category. There are some just for people who cringe at the thought of sitting in a large classroom memorizing what the teacher tells them.
“I’m not interested in another four years of structured high school education,” said Demitra Zervopoulous, 17, of South Shore HS. “I’m interested in being able to call my own shots.”
Demitra has applied to Eugene Lang, a small alternative college in the Village that lets you design your own program. Many non-traditional colleges like Lang let you decide what classes you want to take. Instead of just picking a “major” and fulfilling the requirements, you get to do what you want to do.
At Hampshire College in Massachusetts there’s a heavy emphasis on independent projects and research-you can actually design your own individual classes. Students draw up a “contract” with a committee of professors who then help guide them through their studies. Erin Dozier, a graduate of Hampshire, said that their system creates a different kind of atmosphere. “At the more traditional schools people take classes only because it’s required,” she said. “At Hampshire people take classes because they want to.”
You Need To Be Independent
But according to Ollie Saurs, a counselor at Options, a college counseling center in Manhattan, that means you have to know what you want. “When you have to design your own program you have to have ideas in your mind, and be able to be independent,” she said.
Students I spoke to from several non-traditional colleges had interests that ran the gamut from Chinese to Zoology. Erin focused on African American politics and history. Demitra is interested in poetry and the arts, which she feels aren’t emphasized enough at traditional colleges. At Antioch College in Ohio, several students I talked to were interested in Environmental Studies. Many are also involved in social and political causes.
A lot of people at these colleges would be considered “different” in a more traditional school. Veronica Chambers went to Simon’s Rock, a college in Massachusetts that accepts students in their junior or senior year of high school. She said the students there were people who “didn’t fit in” but were also smarter and more mature than the average high school student. “Students are weird,” she added. “There were 60’s hippie kind of people with dyed hair and tie dye clothing.”
While the people at Hampshire also tend to be “different,” Erin said that in many ways they were “all the same.” They all listened to the same alternative music, they all wore the same alternative clothes, and they all wanted to be politically correct. “I kind of felt fooled,” she said. “I thought you could be yourself.”
Different But the Same
Political correctness, or a way of talking about social issues in a way that won’t offend anyone, was another issue that came up more than once. According to Jeannie Gosline, 20, of Eugene Lang College, “People [at Lang] are liberal, sometimes to the point of being one-sided.” Veo Karns, 18, another Lang student, agreed: “Everybody is always so quick to defend their beliefs, even when nobody’s challenging them.”
Students at non-traditional colleges also complain that there is not enough ethnic diversity among the students. At Lang, 17% of the students are “minority,” while at NYU, a traditional university just a few blocks away, that number is 35%-more than double. Only 9% of Hampshire’s enrollment are minority students. “Coming from a diversified environment like New York you find that you don’t really think much about diversity,” said Erin. “Here, [at Hampshire] you find yourself thinking about it all the time.”
During her time at Hampshire, Erin transferred to City College for a semester because it offered a lot more in her “concentration”-African American studies. “At City College there were all kinds of people,” she said. “There were Dominicans, Puerto Ricans, African Americans. Some people went full-time, some people went part-time. Some people were 18, some people were 50.”
But one of the reasons Erin was able to go away for a semester was that Hampshire allows students to pursue their interests even if it means going off campus.
Going Out Into the World
Some non-traditional colleges also have special programs that allow you to go out into the real world. Antioch actually requires you to get full-time work experience in order to graduate. Students travel and work all over the country. If you are a journalism major, for example, you might work all winter as a reporter for The Miami Herald and in the summer be an intern at The Boston Globe.
Other colleges, like Colorado College, have what’s called a “block system,” in which you study only one subject at a time-intensively. In other words, if you decide to take a class on “Feminist Literature,” that’s all you study for three months.
All these colleges are different in one way or another. Some, such as Antioch, Hampshire, and the University of Michigan’s residential program (a small, alternative college within a larger university) give no grades. Instead, the student gets written evaluations, a chance for the professors to tell you exactly what they thought about your work, and how they feel you can improve. “They’ll tell you everything,” said Erin. “You can’t hide behind an A or a B. They’ll tell you straight out what you did wrong or what you did right. Evaluations let you do the work for the purpose of doing the work, not for the purpose of getting the grade.”
Close faculty-student relations are one of the big benefits of going to one of these colleges. Most have small, discussion-type classes, usually with only about 10 to 15 students. Often there are one-to-one tutorials where you are the only person in the class. “They really help you a lot,” said Erin. “And they treat you like you’re on the same level, not as if you’re a student and they’re the teacher. They really work you out.”
Veronica agreed. “I got a C on a paper and the professor sat with me for two hours and explained to me what I did wrong and how I could improve my work.”
Just As Much Work
Many people think that alternative colleges are easier and that they are only for people who can’t get into a “real” college. This is a myth. In fact, at Deep Springs College (the one in the desert) most students scored above 1300 on the SAT, and were also accepted to colleges like Yale, Harvard, and Cornell.
The work at alternative colleges is just as demanding as the work at traditional schools. “If a student chooses a non-traditional college to do less work they are at a disadvantage,” warned Ellen Turner, director of college counseling at Northfield Mount Hermon School in Massachusetts. “At a non-traditional college you do the same amount of work, just in a different way.”
The key word is different. Alternative colleges are right for people who want something other than the typical college experience. “We have a lot of assumptions about how people should learn and how they should live,” explained Monique Devane, a former admissions officer at Brown University. “Most traditional institutions tend to be very conformist with those assumptions.”
Devane said that alternative schools look for ways to “test those assumptions” so they can better serve a particular kind of student. “To assume that everyone should go to a traditional college,” she said, “is like saying that everyone looks good in the same suit.”
Those who are well suited for non-traditional colleges actually seem to enjoy the experience. As Craig Sanes, 23, of Eugene Lang College, put it, “I didn’t want to go to school just to go to school, I came here to learn.”
Hold the Lectures: College: Have it Your Way
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.