In November I went to a press conference at the Board of Education where students from each high school in the city got a chance to meet Chancellor Rudy Crew and talk to him about their schools. The press conference was to be an update for all high school students and an opportunity for both students and Dr. Crew to get an insight into how different schools are doing.
I was asked to speak on behalf of my school, Stevenson HS in the Bronx, and I was looking forward to going.
I began to make up questions, with the help of other students and teachers.
I had a lot of questions that I wanted to get answered, but the chancellor showed up about 15 minutes late and when students asked questions that he didn’t seem to want to answer, he just dodged and said he would answer when the TV cameras stopped rolling. But when the cameras went off, he left.
Our Questions Weren’t Answered
Not only that, but because we only had an hour to meet with him, each student was only allowed to ask one question.
We brought up a lot of issues that needed to be addressed, but it seemed to me that our questions weren’t heard, nor were they answered. Students walked out of there knowing as much as they did walking in (not much).
Students want to know more about how the school system operates and how we can help improve our schools, because most of us care about getting an education.
And we needed Dr. Crew to respond to our needs. He did have a positive attitude and he did listen, but I think the meeting could have been better.
I wanted to talk generally about how they decide to spend money for the schools, what improvements they have planned, whether they are planning to create more after-school activities, what the chancellor is doing to make classes smaller, and whether they are building new schools to fix the overcrowding.
Basically, I wanted to know when and how they are going to change and improve the education I am getting.
Improve Our Schools-Now
Dr. Crew said the Board of Education is working to create remedies. Despite a low budget, he’s trying to find space, to build new schools and to reduce classroom size.
He never got into what the remedies were, though. These issues need to be addressed now.
We still have problems such as schools being heated by coal and school buildings falling apart. The Board of Education contractors take years to fix broken items in schools.
In my school, lockers, bathrooms and football fields haven’t been maintained. Dr. Crew called those things minor issues that can be addressed whenever.
Avoiding the Real Issues
The answer I expected to hear was that the things in our schools that are falling apart will be fixed soon. I know the schools don’t have much money, but I think my expectations were reasonable.
We use things like broken lockers and bathrooms on a daily basis, and they should be maintained. It’s the Board of Education’s job to see to that.
Maybe they don’t think it’s a problem because they’re not the ones who have to deal with poor school conditions every day.
Dr. Crew didn’t seem to want to talk about problems in our schools that could be fixed by having more money and better management.
Instead, he focused on school safety and whether the NYPD should police our schools.
Well, I don’t doubt that school safety is important, but why can’t we talk about the bigger issues that are harder to fix?
Students Aren’t Learning Enough
After the press conference, I felt pretty annoyed, so I started reading articles in the newspaper about our school system.
I found out that it’s not just high schools that are in trouble and it’s not just school buildings that are falling apart. It seems like kids in all grades in the city could be learning a lot more.
Recently I read in The New York Times about the unfortunate accomplishments of 3rd graders in NewYork City compared to 3rd graders in the rest of the state.
The scores show that 35% of 3rd graders in the city are reading below remedial level (meaning that they are a year or more behind where they should be). In the rest of the state, only 6% of 3rd graders fell below the remedial level in 1997. A Long Failure List
I was surprised to read that, because I thought it was only high school students who were doing badly. But it’s not just us-it’s the whole system.
Not only that, but on Nov. 13, state education officials took 18 New York City schools off the failing schools list, but added 21 other schools, bringing the total to 97-the most schools on the failing list in a decade.
It also makes me feel angry that Dr. Crew said at the press conference that we don’t have money for every little thing-but the city still found enough money to give Dr. Crew a raise.
A few months ago, the chancellor got a $50,000 raise, so he now makes $245,000-more than the mayor, the governor or the president.
We Need More Money
Dr. Crew has a hard job, and many people think he’s doing a better job than people before him, so maybe it’s not his fault that things are so bad. But if that’s true, then I think the state and the city have to work harder to figure out how to improve our schools.
Maybe it’s impossible for a chancellor to really improve the schools without having more money. If that’s true-and I think it is-then they need to find that money.
I think Dr. Crew’s priorities should be to hire more guidance counselors, to make our classes smaller, to improve our school buildings, to figure out how to improve attendance, and to increase the after-school programs that schools offer.
My school could use a Gateway (math and science) program, Virtual Enterprise (a business program), and a program in which a business forms a partnership with schools, hiring students based upon their academic performance.
Activities Make School More Interesting
We could also use after-school drama clubs, a newspaper and some sports teams besides basketball.
Maybe we could even start activities with other schools, like performing concerts, having dances and competing in debates. I know I would like to do some of these things.
These activities might make school seem more relevant to students’ interests and goals. And they might make students more likely to come to school, because they would be looking forward to fun learning with their friends after classes end.
The activities that a school provides can make students feel like it’s worth coming to school.
The way things are right now, I’m not sure these changes-big or small-will ever happen, because the chancellor doesn’t seem very in touch with what students need.
Teens: Speak Up!
At the press conference, what upset me most was how student voices were not being heard by the adults in charge-partly because the adults were not listening.
If we want to improve the situation, students need to speak up more and adults need to respond.
Teens can make their voices heard by sending letters to the chancellor. Their parents should write letters, too.
Dr. Crew’s press conference was a start, but it was not enough. Dr. Crew, or someone else at the Board of Education, should hold one every month. That way we can know that we are being heard and that the chancellor is aware of the problems we see every day.
Send letters to: The Office of the Chancellor, Rudy S. Crew, 110 Livingston St., Brooklyn, N.Y. 11201.
Hey, Rudy Crew! I’m Talking to You!
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.