I’ve had enough of all the bull. It’s time for a conclusive, ’90s answer to the age-old question: can men and women really, truly be friends?
Based on the people that I spoke to, the answer is a definitive “maybe.”
The girls I spoke to were strong believers in male-female friendships. Most agreed with Julia Joseph, 18, of Humanities HS, who said that in friendships with guys, “there’s no competition like there usually is among girls.” Simona Barta, 18, also of Humanities, agreed that there “isn’t the problem of who’s going to get the guy.”
Simona also said that a male friend is generally more trustworthy than a female friend. “He’ll always tell me the truth,” she said, “and he’ll never make me look bad.”
Another thing girls like about having a friend who’s a guy is getting a totally different point-of-view on things. It “gives you insight into the other sex,” said Julia. Cynthia Cunningham, 18, of Bronx Science HS, agreed. “It dispels myths, like all guys are like this, or that,” she said.
You can even get advice from a male friend that helps with your romantic relationships. “If you’re in trouble with your boyfriend, he can tell you how to handle it,” said Tanya Benjamin, 15, of Far Rockaway HS.
A Hassle-Free Relationship
A lot of girls said that in a platonic friendship with a guy, you get the best of both worlds. “They don’t get jealous of me, they always pay for me, I basically tell them what to do, and they respect me a lot,” said Simona. In other words, all the benefits of a boyfriend without the headaches.
The guys I spoke to were a little more wary. A few said they liked having female friends because they’re easier to talk to than other guys. Josh Nichols, 19, of the School of the Visual Arts, says that girls are good to “bounce ideas off of.”
Seth Dolce, 18, said, “You can talk much more on the phone [with a girl]. Most guys aren’t into talking on the phone.” And both Josh and Seth agreed that having female buddies is a great way to meet girls that you can get romantic about.
Not all guys agreed with this rosy picture. Matt Shiffman, 18, of Humanities HS, insisted that male-female friendships can’t work because sex always gets in the way. Matt’s opinion is based on personal experience. He told me that he tried to be friends with a girl once.
Sex Ruins Everything
“We started talking and doing things and then we’d hang out all the time,” he said. But it didn’t last. “One night, I took her home and banged her and now we’re not friends anymore. Hence, men and women cannot be friends.”
Others I interviewed were more optimistic. Cynthia said that “as long as one of you isn’t lusting after the other one it should be fine.”
Unfortunately, one person often does start to feel attracted to the other and that can be the death-knell of a male-female friendship. Simona admitted that sex is always a major problem in her friendships with guys.
“When you start spending a lot of time together you could either decide to do something or to not do something,” she said. “Either way the relationship changes.”
According to Seth, a friendship is “impossible” when there is a physical attraction. And Julia said that a serious downside to her friendships with a guy is the “fear that they may be attracted.” This has happened to her before, she said, and “I get angry at them for ruining a good friendship.”
Fortunately, physical attraction can work both ways. If that happens, what was a friendship can turn into something more. “Then,” said Seth, “it’s not a problem.”
Guys and Girls: Why Can’t We Be Friends?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.