Six years ago, I was in my room listening to the radio when the Smashing Pumpkins’ “Bullet With Butterfly Wings” came on. The first line caught my attention: “The world is a vampire, sent to drain/ Secret destroyers, hold you up to the flames.”
A song about vampires seemed cool to 10-year-old me. When the song got to the chilling chorus in which the singer screeches, “Despite all my rage, I’m still just a rat in my cage,” I stopped what I was doing, completely transfixed by the whiny, eerily chilling voice coming out of my speakers.
Dark Side of Despair
Soon afterward, I bought the album, Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, and I’ve been a Smashing Pumpkins fan ever since. I liked the band’s sound, which featured de-tuned guitars marked with feedback, frequent use of the mellotron (an electric keyboard instrument), and string arrangements.
I’ve since learned that the song has nothing to do with vampires, but instead is about how the singer’s repressed anger is damaging to his mind.
Lead singer Billy Corgan’s lyrics, which usually leaned on the dark side of despair, appealed to me. His nasal whine struck me as the voice of a high school loser venting his frustrations with everything wrong in the world.
The Pumpkins meant something to me because I could feel Corgan’s pain. It seemed like he was all alone, without a friend in the world, just like I was feeling when I first heard them.
Like a More Mature Pumpkins
But after 13 years together, the band broke up. Now Billy Corgan is back with a new band, Zwan. On their debut album, Mary Star of the Sea, Corgan’s signature nasal whine is still sharp. And the music remains faithful to the Pumpkins sound, although it’s not quite as heavy.
The Smashing Pumpkins focused more on droning riffs, creating a static-like sound, while most of Zwan’s riffs are clearer and less distorted. Corgan retains his role as the rhythm guitarist, which allows guitarists David Pajo and Matt Sweeney to weave in and out with their leads.
Think of Zwan as a more mature version of the Pumpkins. Corgan no longer screams, instead focusing on the melody, backed by the vocals of bassist Paz Lenchantin. No one in the band tries to outdo the other, so that while there’s a lot going on in the background, it’s not so much that it confuses the listener.
‘Sunshine and Some Tea?’
Most of the song’s themes are about Corgan trying to convince someone to be with him. As one of the song titles suggests, he wants to “Settle Down.” For a first time listener, this might not be such a big deal, but to me, it’s strange hearing the former King of Gloom sing, “Sunshine and some teaâ and your love next to mine.”
I’m so used to him singing about how the world is coming to an end that it was a big disappointment finding the album filled with earnest love songs. I’m a pessimist, and Corgan’s Pumpkin’s-era music meant a lot to me. He was exorcising his demons, and I respected that.
Now he’s just exercising his lovesick heart, which is a sappy turnoff. I can’t relate to positive songs. In a way, happy songs make me feel worse than depressing ones because it feels like I’m missing out on something the singer is talking about.
Corgan Finds Religion
It’s obvious Corgan also underwent a religious transformation. In the Pumpkins song “Zero,” he sings, “Emptiness is loneliness and loneliness is cleanliness/And cleanliness is godliness and god is empty, just like me.” But in Zwan’s “Ride a Black Swan,” he’s singing, “I want us to solve our distrust of everyone/And trust in God.”
The album touches on faith in other songs, too, including the 14-minute epic “Jesus I/ Mary Star of the Sea.” The lyrics “Jesus, I have taken my cross/ All to leave and follow thee” are taken from a gospel hymn. It seems like the Zwan frontman has finally found a cure to the angst that made him famous.
The song starts off quietly with just a guitar and Corgan singing the hymn as if he’s praying to God. When the rest of the band joins him, the song picks up the pace and volume, only to slow down again into a more subdued, hypnotic interlude. Then the song accelerates again, into distorted feedback, and ends with the dueling guitars of Pajo and Sweeney.
Musically, A Welcome Return
The soft-loud pattern is a welcome return to the old Pumpkins sound. “Endless Summer,” “Baby Let’s Rock,” and “Yeah!” also carry a Pumpkins-like sound; they’re the heaviest and most sludge-like songs on the album.
Other standout songs include the upbeat rocker “Honestly,” and the opening track, “Lyric,” highlighted by the rhythmic drumming of fellow-Pumpkin Jimmy Chamberlin.
Those not deterred by Corgan’s change of heart should find Mary Star of the Sea a catchy, hard-rock album which musically doesn’t stray too far from the Smashing Pumpkins blueprint. The lyrics may be sappier, but it’s as close to the Pumpkins as we’re going to get.
Grumpy Pumpkin Becomes a Happy Zwan
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.