Good-bye Gold, Hello Ties: Dress Codes Are Coming Back

Dress codes are coming back. They can range anywhere from “No gold” or “No ripped jeans” to “Everyone must wear white shirts and dark slacks.” At Boys and Girls HS, Principal Frank Mickens plans to require males to wear ties.
At West Side HS in Manhattan the “dress code” is basically a safety precaution. Principal Ed Reynolds, doesn’t allow “big gold.” Before the code was installed there were four major incidents with gold. Two involved guns. “I twice found myself staring at a gun and I knew it had to be stopped,” said Reynolds. He also prohibits bandanas because they are usually gang related, as well as beepers and cellular phones.
Neither the teens nor the officials interviewed felt that students are trying to start trouble. “I don’t think kids wear certain things to cause disturbances,” said David Brown, 13, of Urban Academy HS. “Maybe [they dress a certain way] to attract attention, but if they know it is going to cause a disturbance and probably get them in trouble they won’t spend their money on it.”
Fashionable Clothes = Bad Grades
Frank Mickens thinks there may be more than one kind of trouble. “I have come to notice that the students who dress fashionably tend to be academically weak,” he said. He doesn’t allow shorts, sleeveless tops, excessive jewelry, mini-dresses, shearling coats or gold caps.
“The way you dress doesn’t affect the kind of education you get.” insisted Venus Mullen, 16, of Andrew Jackson HS.
But Mickens wants to make it clear that his school is a place to learn, not play. “Students should understand, they’re coming to school, not going to the beach or a party or a disco,” he said. Joy Small, 18, also of Andrew Jackson HS agrees. She said a lot of the students at her school dress like they are going to a party.
But most of the eight high school students interviewed felt that these regulations infringe on their self-expression. “Teens have a way of expressing themselves through clothes,” said Jorge Estrella, 18, of Urban Academy HS. “No one has the right to say we can’t wear something.”
One rule that troubles a lot of guys is “No hats.” Sasha Zielin, 15, of Urban Academy HS, said “They say hats are insulting and disrespectful.” He complained that they allow girls to wear them but not boys.
Some dress codes clearly go beyond issues of safety and even academics. “They [officials] get way out of line,” added Zielin. But Mickens wants to give students a sense of unity. In a very large school he said everyone can’t be doing his or her own thing. “When you have 3,600 kids, you sure as hell better find something to do together.”
Mickens also sees it as his responsibility to prepare students for “the dress code in the business world.”
This will probably be his last year as principal at Boys and Girls, according to Mickens, but if he were to remain Mickens said he would probably require students to wear a uniform consisting of dark slacks and skirts and white shirts and blouses. [According to The New York Times, Mickens plans to require all boys to wear light colored shirts and ties beginning February 1st.]
Boys and Girls HS is more than five times bigger than West Side. Each has a dress code which the principal feels works for his particular school.
Students interviewed recognize the safety issue but feel that when officials start to prohibit ripped jeans, hats or heritage symbols, they are going beyond their responsibilities and violating the students’ freedom of expression.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.