“Ghosts of Mississippi”: What Happened to Medgar Evers?

“This story is true.”
This sentence appears in stark white letters against a plain black background at the beginning of Rob Reiner’s newest movie, Ghosts of Mississippi. And it is in these words that the movie’s main problem lies.
Ghosts is about something that really happened-the murder of civil rights leader Medgar Evers and subsequent efforts to bring his killer to justice. Unfortunately, the story has undergone a process common to historical films; it has been Hollywoodified.
Like many big screen dramas, Ghosts blindly attempts to categorize everyone and everything as either Good or Evil. Not only does the movie leave out the gray areas that are part of every real life story, it also manages to take the focus away from a real hero-Medgar Evers-and place it on someone less worthy: the White prosecuting attorney who re-opens Evers’ case 25 years after the murder.
Shot in the Back
The movie gets off to a good start. In a powerful opening sequence, Reiner takes us back to June 12, 1963-the night that Evers was shot in front of his home, by a White racist named Byron De La Beckwith (James Woods).
As a dying Medgar Evers crawls up his driveway to the arms of his crying wife, Myrlie (Whoopi Goldberg) and his children, Reiner manages to capture the true emotion of the event. A Black man, whose only crime is fighting for basic human rights, is shot in the back by a White racist who is too much of a coward to confront his victim face-to-face.
When the shot is fired and Evers’ small children drop to the floor as they have been taught to do at the sound of gunfire, Reiner shows us the dangers that Southern Blacks faced every day during the civil rights era. Unfortunately, the very real tension that’s captured in this scene is not felt again through the rest of the movie.
A Hung Jury
Byron De La Beckwith is tried twice for the murder and leaves the courtroom a free man both times, due to hung juries. Despite overwhelming evidence against him, the chance of a White man being convicted for the murder of a Black person, especially a civil rights leader, was slim. This point is emphasized by the only scene we see of the first trial. It shows the then-governor of Mississippi shaking hands with De La Beckwith during Myrlie Evers’ testimony.
After the second trial, the case is put on the back burner. The D.A.’s office refuses to touch it again and crucial evidence is lost.
A Crusading Lawyer
The movie then fast-forwards 25 years to 1989 and we meet Bobby DeLaughter (Alec Baldwin), the attorney who will eventually retry the Evers case. At this point, the movie starts falling back on the kind of cliched one-liners that trailers are made of. “How can one man shoot another man in the back in front of his family?” DeLaughter asks, rhetorically. From this point on, the movie revolves around DeLaughter’s search for the missing evidence and his struggle to gain the trust of Myrlie Evers so that he can hold on to the case.
Baldwin’s performance is less than stellar. It’s unfortunate that such a bad actor was chosen to play the biggest and most important role in the movie. Throughout Ghosts, Baldwin wears one poker-faced expression. He responds to all the events in DeLaughter’s life-from his sudden divorce from a Southern belle bigot to almost losing his chance to prosecute the Evers case-in the same unflinching manner. His passionless demeanor is especially incomprehensible during the courtroom scenes. The fact that Baldwin cannot seem to hold on to his Southern accent further weakens the movie.
Two Performances: One Awful, One Excellent
James Woods, on the other hand, is excellent. We get a glimpse of how powerful this movie could have been in an explosive scene when De La Beckwith and DeLaughter meet in the courthouse bathroom during the new trial. Woods so effectively portrays his character’s viciousness that I felt fear and revulsion in my heart as I watched his performance. I only wish he had a larger part. The way he captures his character’s arrogant belief that his actions were justified goes right to the heart of Medgar Evers’ story. It allowed me to step inside and understand the mind of a person who committed a vicious and evil act, while also showing me what the Civil Rights Movement was fighting against.
Sadly, that message gets lost during the rest of Ghosts. The irony of this movie is that it commits the same sin that it accuses the people of Mississippi of. It forgets about Medgar Evers. Where are the stories of his achievements as a civil rights leader, or the agony his family went through after his murder? No one leaves the theater having learned what Evers was fighting for or why he was killed. There’s no understanding of the way the man gave up his life trying to fix a problem that has yet to be solved.
Who’s the Real Hero?
In the end, Ghosts of Mississippi isn’t about the injustices done to Blacks, or the fact that Medgar Evers was literally forgotten by most Americans for 25 years. Instead, it’s the cliched story of a White guy struggling to live with the sins of his fathers by fighting against a racist community that’s still committing the same kind of sins. It’s about a well-meaning White man who manages to bridge the gulf between the Black and White communities, winning accolades for his great achievement. The movie hides Medgar Evers in Bobby DeLaughter’s shadow.
Ghosts of Mississippi has committed the ultimate sacrilege, telling us that it’s “a true story” when it’s really not.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.