Giving out free needles is like giving out free drugs. This would not control the high drug rate or the spread of the HIV virus and AIDS. Instead, it would encourage intravenous (IV) drug users to remain addicted rather than seek treatment.
When an addict desperately needs a fix, she’s not going to care whether the needle she’s using is sterile or not. An addict won’t care if she’s sharing needles either. The knowledge that she is more susceptible to getting the AIDS virus will not really make a difference. An IV drug user’s mind is set on one thing-getting high.
It Sends the Wrong Message
“We must focus on expanding our resources to help these people get placed into treatment programs-whether that is through adding slots, creating new programs or providing effective outreach as a constructive bridge until treatment slots can be obtained,” argued Congressman Charles B. Rangel, chairman of the Select Committee on Narcotics Abuse and Control in the U.S House of Representatives. “There is absolutely nothing to be gained by pushing needles.” Rangel also said that a free needle program would be “morally and spiritually wrong” and it would send the wrong message.
If needles are going to be made available to IV drug users, I wonder how they’re going to encourage the drug users to get them. Who is going to say in the middle of shooting up, “Wait! These needles are not clean, we might get AIDS. Let’s go to the clinic and get some clean ones.” They are not going to be able to even think rationally, let alone stop what they’re doing to worry about clean needles.
Treatment Programs Needed
The majority of the 200,000 IV drug users in New York City are poor Blacks and Latinos. It wouldn’t be fair for the government to provide them free needles instead of drug treatment programs. If the majority of IV drug users were middle class White people, surely the government would provide treatment programs for them.
Instead of fighting the war on AIDS by distributing free needles, we should be fighting the war on drugs so that there would be fewer addicts, including IV drug users.
I believe if the government wants to do something about the spread of AIDS then they should put money and resources into finding a cure for AIDS and into drug treatment programs and the so-called war on drugs instead of providing free needles. It is cheaper to provide free needles than to really address the problem.
IV drug users don’t care about getting AIDS. They only care about getting high. They need help- building more treatment centers would provide some of the help they need. Free needles would not encourage them to get help. It would only encourage them to remain addicts.
Free Needles Encourage Drug Use
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.