Foster Care on Stage

Musical theater portrays real life in care

My first look inside The Possibility Project was on a chilly autumn night in 2011, nine weeks before opening night of their play, A Place for the Night . I and some other Represent writers visited the dance studio they used as rehearsal space for a group interview. The room had floor-to-ceiling mirrors and windows overlooking Manhattan’s theater district. Two heaps of post-adolescent kids sprawled on the floor, talking loudly and affectionately.
I was struck by the closeness among the cast members. They played with each other’s hair and platonically cuddled. They also teased and racked each other’s nerves like brothers and sisters do. They seemed like a family. Some had worked together the previous year or two, and those who had joined this year had been working together on A Place for the Night for about five months.
The Possibility Project (TPP) is a nonprofit organization that runs three youth-oriented theater groups: Saturday, After School (for any teenager), and the Foster Care Program, which was created in 2009. The foster care theater program recruits youth from foster care agencies in New York City. As with all their shows, The Possibility Project picks these participants through a series of non-competitive auditions. Kids are chosen not because of talent or ability, but by showing willingness to collaborate and commit to the show, and a desire to make a change. A Place for the Night is the third foster care play.
Paul Griffin, along with a group of teenagers, founded The Possibility Project, which was first called City at Peace, in 1994. This was in Washington D.C., which was suffering from much violence and racism at the time. City at Peace gave teens a safe place to do something productive that addressed the city’s problems. Between 1994 and 1998, City at Peace added programs in California and Israel. The program started up in New York in 2000 and in six other U.S. cities after that.
Paul Griffin is still leading The Possibility Project and was the artistic director for A Place for the Night . He has 20 years of experience working in the field of youth development and the arts and has been the creative force behind 64 musicals by youth. I could see from the rehearsals I attended that he provides a positive space for foster care youth to develop their skills in the arts, and to cultivate themselves as people. He seems like a great leader, and an excellent listener. During rehearsals I saw him take at least a few minutes to talk to each kid on the side, about the play or their personal lives. He seems like a big part of The Possibility Project’s family feel.
Many Stages
A Place for the Night , like all of The Possibility Project’s plays, is based on the personal stories of cast members. Writing the script is an intense and long process. It usually takes seven months from beginning to show. ( A Place for the Night took nine months because they had trouble finding a theater.)
First, TPP runs social change workshops for 12 weeks. Most of the activities come from Allan Creighton and Paul Kivel’s book, Helping Teens Stop Violence, Build Community, and Stand for Justice . These workshops engage the cast in discussion about diversity and violence prevention and the teens’ place in society. In one exercise, cast members line up, then take a step forward if they answer a question “yes.” Questions include, “Please step forward if you’ve ever been hit by an adult” and “Please step forward if you’ve been told’You don’t act like someone in foster care.'”
This exercise literally shows kids where they stand in relation to each other’s experiences and bonds them. The workshops also give a larger social context to the tough personal stories that go into the script. At the same time as the workshops, the cast members are, Paul says, “learning dance and singing and creating material. And team-building. And having fun.”
The next stage in the process is Life Stories. Every cast member can-but doesn’t have to-go up in front of the room and tell his or her life story in four to eight minutes. Everyone else listens. Paul points out that “nothing in that exercise is used in the show; it’s an exercise to understand each other.”
Then the Production Team, a group of seven youth returning from the previous year’s cast, plus Paul and assistant artistic director Elizabeth Howard go on a retreat in upstate New York. Using the stories that have been told, they find the most crucial issues for that group. Then they create an outline of five storylines. In A Place for the Night , one storyline shows 17-year-old Kendal’s troubled relationship with her mom, who neglects her daughter in favor of her own erratic boyfriend. Another is Quentin’s struggle to survive in his residential treatment center (RTC) while dealing with trauma from his abusive family.
Stories in shows are composites, says Program Manager Kelly Claus, “so everybody’s stories end up in a storyline.” They change details like gender and location so the stories don’t identify the kids they happened to. After the retreat, the artistic director casts participants in roles, and the Production Team gives the cast an outline of the show. Nobody plays his or her own story.
Together, the group starts writing the show through guided improvisation. Paul and Elizabeth, along with three actor volunteers, watch and take notes. They note the reactions to various things and get the youth to explore the character. To avoid cliche, they study the dialogue, and ask questions such as “would she really say that?” And the script is getting made this whole time.
Not everyone works the same way. Some cast members sat around a computer writing together while others created the dialogue through improv. Each storyline has four or five scenes and each scene takes about two or three weeks to write. The final scenes are written the week before the show because, according to Kelly, “the resolution is the hardest. The earlier scenes are about what’s happened to them. we’re challenging them to look for solutions, and that’s more difficult if you’ve never experienced resolving a conflict before.”
I was impressed with the work the cast did writing this script. They were not only conveying their painful stories onto paper, but they were still dealing with them in real life. It’s hard to write a story with an ending when you haven’t found a resolution to your own problems. The team avoids trite happy endings to these painful stories. Kelly said, “We had to put in rules in one show: No hugs. A hug is not a solution.”
The Players Testify
The long process of building the play from their own traumatic experience clearly helps the participants learn about themselves and grow. In our group interview, Production Team member Gabrielle Garcia said, “When I first came here Iâ didn’t have strong emotional ties to anyone, to people my age and even to people like my mother. I would fight a lot.” But, she said, being in this program unlocked something inside. She found herself crying every day at rehearsal and then connecting with others in a way she never had before. “The streets make you think you are one way and when you come in here, you see a different picture of yourself,” she said.
In the group interview, most of the youth said they started the program introverted and uncomfortable sharing their personal stories with each other. But they found themselves opening up a few months into the program. Darelle Gist, a transgender youth who played a boy in the show but is now known as Daniella Carter, said, “When I first started TPP I didn’t want to tell nobody nothing. But the day before we started the show outlineâ. I told The Possibility Project about myself because after a while you begin to feel like they’re your family-like the family you never had.” Claribelle Pagan added, “When I started here, I was looking for support and someplace I could just be myself. And I found that.”
The bonding process may be especially intense because the actors, all youth in foster care and adoptees, have rarely been with a group of kids like them. Michael Dew said, “When I first came to this program, my heart was as cold as iceâ. After the first year, I learned that there are other people that went through the same things I went through. And my heart softened. I became more compassionate. And I actually started to care about other people besides myself.” Michael, Daniella, and Claribelle are all Production Team members, meaning they are responsible for program oversight. Most members of the Production Team have been in the program for at least one year.
The Possibility Project let me attend several rehearsals. During the second one I went to, the group worked on two dance numbers and one song. The choreography was an eclectic mix of modern and hip-hop dance. A young choreographer, Maiysha Cade, created the steps and led the whole cast through the dance over and over (they let me dance with them). The song, the opening number, was upbeat and bouncy, but the lyrics were about what most foster kids go through-abuse, neglect, and family dysfunction. One memorable line is “The simple fact of your life/Is that there were no good old days.” I cried a lot as they worked on that song because I recognized things from my life.
Commitment
All the Possibility Project plays are musicals. The big group numbers are created by the group writing together. Those words go to the adult musical director, Seth Rothschild, who composes the music in the style that the group agreed on. Rothschild also helps the soloists write their individual songs. A standout in A Place for the Night was a powerful rap about “fighting in the RTC” by Deshawn Brown.
The rehearsals are intimate and everybody is comfortable. Paul and Elizabeth make a laissez-faire environment for the cast, not stressing them out. There seems to be a mutual understanding: The youth can be themselves and carry on as they like, as long as they show up for rehearsal and take everything seriously.
And they do take it seriously; a full-length play is a huge undertaking. In the group interview, we asked everyone to say one thing they gained from being in the program. Ana Enriquez said, “I found commitment. In school before, I would do good for like two months and then hit rock bottom. Then I came here, and I have tried my best to come to every rehearsal. I guess it’s not just about rehearsal; it’s about all these people and the show we are going to do. I don’t even think about it like it’s my story; I think about it as the people I am helping portray and to be able to help people tell their stories.” The discipline comes from finding yourself in something bigger than you.
Show Time
The Possibility Project performed A Place for the Night on four different nights in December. The theater was packed to the brim, abuzz with anxious chatter. It opened beautifully with the song I had heard in rehearsal. The five story lines covered most of the issues that foster care youth face.
I was impressed with how the storyline of Kendal, the girl battling with her mother, was resolved with Kendal finding strength in herself. When Kendal gets pregnant, she is kicked out of her home by her mother. She calls her mother from the ACS office, begging for her help, but her mother, again, tells her she’s on her own.
In the group home, Kendal has a miscarriage, but she secures her role in her new setting. She goes back home to pick up her things, where her mother tries to get her to come back home (her boyfriend has dumped her again). But it’s too late. Kendal has excused her mother one too many times. She leaves her mother’s house sadly but with dignity and independence. I saw what Kelly Claus meant about “no easy solutions.” A Place for the Night ended with the message that “life must go on”-not a fairy tale happy ending.
The whole play was an excellent portrayal of what foster care kids really go through. It was well written and sharp, mirroring the way teenagers talk today. It was emotional but not overdramatic. It was raw and real, and yet the young cast seemed to really understand their craft.
Going to the rehearsals and talking to the cast made me see that the play was an outlet of help and love for the cast mates among themselves. But seeing the play, I realized it was also a gift: They were giving the audience a voice. I left in tears, feeling, “Wow this is my story too.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.