Fixing the Welfare System: Can We Make It Fair for Everyone?

Ever since I came to this country from Russia three years ago and found out about this thing called welfare I’ve thought the system should be changed. I don’t have anything against helping people who lose their jobs or are too sick to work. But the current system discourages people from going back to work even when they can, and allows them to become dependent.
A few people I know have become too lazy to look for jobs or gain the necessary skills because they don’t have to. They can receive welfare for years and years without lifting a finger. Some families even stay on it for generations. It seems to me welfare isn’t only a safety net; for many, it’s an easy way out.
Well, this summer the federal government passed a sweeping welfare reform bill that addresses many of my concerns. It will deny benefits to many people and change the way the system works. When I first heard this, I was glad. But now that I’ve found out more about it, I’m not so sure.
Turning Down Perfectly Good Jobs
When my family got here, my parents didn’t care what job they took as long as they could find one. But I’ve seen other Russian immigrants who were too lazy to even look for a job and lived on welfare for years even though they were more than capable of working.
Not long ago, a man I know was actually offered a job-something like designing chairs, I think-and he turned it down. He said it was too far from his house and didn’t pay as much as he thought he deserved. He used to be an aerospace engineer and thought he could do better, so he stayed on welfare.
People like him say they will take any job, but what they really mean is any job where they have their own office, a secretary, and earn $40,000 a year. They come here with years of experience but along with it they bring foolish pride. They think they will be able to get the same position they had in their country (in many cases without even making an effort to learn English), and won’t accept anything less.
Other people cheat the system. One of my friends knows a family in which both parents work for cash. The mother sews and the father drives a cab. Together, they earn about $700 a week but they also receive welfare.
Taking Advantage of the System
Many people accuse women on welfare of having babies to increase their benefits. While that might be illogical, since welfare doesn’t exactly give you golden mountains for each child, there is some truth to it.
When the president announced that he would sign the new welfare bill in August, I read an interview in The New York Times with a 28-year-old nurse who worked two jobs to support her kids. She said some women are having baby after baby and expect the state to take care of them. “If you can’t afford the baby,” she said, “don’t have one. You can get birth control for free.”
I agree. Why can’t more women be as responsible as she is? I think the reason why so many people live on welfare for generations is simply because they can. The current system allows that.
Of course I am not talking about everybody. I don’t have anything against people who need help. I could very well be in the same situation one day. Things happen. Hunger is scary, and one day it might be as real as our heartbeats.
Help the People Who Really Need It
It’s not that I’m against the idea of having any welfare system at all. In fact, I’m for it. Everyone needs help at some point in their lives. And 70% of people on welfare receive it for no more than two years. But if you saw your parents willing to take any job, no matter how overqualified they are, and then see someone else turning a job down because it takes him more than an hour to get there by subway, you might get a little bit upset too.
My idea of welfare is helping people who lose their jobs or can’t find one; people who just came to this country and discover they don’t have the necessary skills to find work-like knowing English, for example; single parents who can’t support their kids on their own or people who are too sick to work.
Welfare should help people get back on their feet so they don’t end up on the streets. But there is also a point when you have to work, a point which takes many people I’ve seen too much time to reach.
A Way to Get People Off Their Butts
When I said I wanted the government to change the welfare system, I meant breaking the cycle of people who are dependent on welfare for years, people who are too lazy or irresponsible to get off their butts, and people who cheat. Well, this summer the government actually did something about that.
According to the new welfare bill that was signed into law in August, you can no longer live on welfare for more than five years in a lifetime. I was glad when I heard that. That man who turned down a job would have to think twice before doing so again. And people would stop cheating.
But there was a lot about the bill that I didn’t know. Legal immigrants who aren’t citizens (people with “green cards”) will no longer be eligible for any benefits at all-not welfare, not food stamps, not even Medicaid. Immigrants who work and pay taxes, who contribute to the society just like citizens, will no longer be treated the same.
Ironically, I am a legal non-citizen. Both of my parents are lucky enough to have jobs, but they may not have them forever. My mom works as a home attendant, and the amount of work she does depends on her patients. If something happens to one of them, she might not have a job anymore. Her agency will try to help her find a new one, but many of the people they take care of are immigrants themselves. Now their Social Security Insurance (SSI) will be cut off, and there will be fewer patients and less of a chance for my mom to find work.
But Where are the Jobs?
My dad’s salary alone is not enough to support our family. If just one of my parents loses his or her job we could end up on the streets.
The people who argue for the bill say that if people get hungry enough, they’ll find jobs. But where can they find jobs if there aren’t any?
According to Liz Krueger, associate director of the Community Food and Resource Center, a group that advocates for poor people, there are currently 50,000 jobs available in New York City, and it doesn’t look like that number is going to increase. Meanwhile, this new welfare bill will bring the number of people looking for work up to 700,000. That’s at least 14 people for every job.
The bill does not require states to make jobs available nor does it provide any money to create them. What are all these people going to do?
I can’t say that I’m against the bill altogether, though. The current system discourages work and has allowed people to be dependent on welfare for generations. And so many people were complaining about it that somebody was bound to do something sooner or later. I’m glad that it happened sooner.
It’s Unfair to Immigrants and Children
But I’m not exactly for the bill, either. It’s not fair the way it treats immigrants and children. And according to Liz Krueger, there will be a lot more crime and poverty because of the bill. The hospitals will be overcrowded because people won’t be able to afford to go to the doctor or pay for medicine until they’re so sick that they have to go to the emergency room.
It’s hard for me to form a definite opinion about this bill. Almost every aspect of it has a negative and a positive side. For example, if a single mother does not name the father of her child, she will lose 25% of her benefits. The government wants to go after the father or at least have his name on the record, so that even if for some reason he can’t pay to support the child right now, he will have to in the future.
On the one hand, it’s only fair that a father should have to support his child instead of the state. On the other hand, a mother might be afraid that the father will hurt her if she names him or she might not even know who the father is.
I’m Stuck in the Middle
More importantly, everybody agrees that a person who lived on welfare for a very long time and is more than capable of working, should work. But where can she find a job? That’s what’s missing from the welfare bill.
If the government created jobs for everybody and did not take the benefits away from immigrants, I would have been all for this bill. But it doesn’t, so I’m standing in the colorless area in between ‘yes’ and ‘no’ (though I’m leaning towards a ‘no’). I don’t know what’s going to happen to me and my family next year. Hopefully, my parents will not lose their jobs. But if they do, my family, along with many others, might be facing very tough times.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.