Have you ever found yourself at the end of a long journey feeling like you’re right back where you started? Finding My Voice is a novel that leaves you wondering if it was worth the trip.
It’s about the trials and tribulations of Ellen Sung, a high school senior in Arkin, Minnesota. Arkin is predominately White and Ellen is the only Asian in her school. She has to put up with girls like Marsha Randall, who repeatedly calls her names like “Ching Chong Chinaman.” Ellen competes with Marsha on the gymnastics team and for the attention of a cute football player with “shaggy blond hair and a cleft chin” named Tomper Sandel.
Like many high school seniors, Ellen is also faced with the college application process. She is constantly being pressured by her father to follow in the footsteps of her older sister who attends Harvard. But during the course of her college search, Ellen discovers that Harvard might not be the best school for her.
I am also Asian and a senior in high school. At times, when she encountered racism or had a problem applying to colleges, I could see myself in Ellen. But I was disappointed by how she fails to confront her problems. In one part, Ellen’s chemistry teacher cracks a rude joke about Asians in front of the class. Ellen is embarrassed and angry immediately after it happens but, after telling her best friend, she never brings it up again. In fact, she doesn’t think about it for the rest of the novel.
There are things about Ellen that I couldn’t relate to at all. For example, she doesn’t find out that her mother never went to college until midway through the story. Most of us are aware of such basic things from our parents’ pasts before we reach the age of 17. Ellen doesn’t even know if she has relatives living in America and that doesn’t seem to bother her. It bothered me that she had never wondered about these things but can still be accepted to Harvard.
In spite of the title, Ellen never finds her voice. She never really deals with her problems either, she just puts them aside and, by the end of the book, she hasn’t changed very much. Her only victory is becoming Tomper’s girlfriend.
Marie G. Lee brings up important issues in this book, but Beverly Hills 90210-style. In the end, the characters are happy that their ordeal is over, but somehow it doesn’t ring true. In too many teen novels the key to happiness always seems to be a boyfriend named Tomper with shaggy blond hair and a cleft chin.
Finding Yourself Beverly Hills 90210-Style
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.