It’s April 2001. This is my first season playing high school baseball and I’m already a starting player on the Lab School varsity team, the Gators. I’ve been playing Little League baseball since I was 6 and I’m excited to be playing on a more competitive high school varsity level. I’m looking forward to the challenge and the chance to prove to myself and my school that I can play in such a tough division.
Our second game, we’re playing against Bread and Roses HS at Riverside Park.
The other team looks pretty intimidating since most of our team is made up of smaller than average Jewish boys, so everyone looks big to us.
Still, I psyche myself up as I approach the plate. “This pitcher really has nothing on me,” I think. “I can get a solid hit off of him.”
Blinded by the Light
I step into the batter’s box. I’m temporarily blinded. It’s as if the baseball diamond is actually made up of polished diamonds glistening in the sun. Then I notice that the entire field is covered in glass and it’s reflecting the sun that’s just starting to set.
Of course, I struck out. I couldn’t believe that after being so confident I had to return to the dugout empty handed. I felt cheated. I knew that if the field hadn’t been covered in glass I could’ve gotten a clear view of the ball and got a hit. But I think that anyone playing on a field as poorly maintained as that one would’ve experienced the same thing.
Starting in April, we play our games on fields all over Manhattan. In many of the fields, like those in Inwood Park and Morningside Park, glass, rocks, and uneven playing fields are common. It’s not until May that Central Park fields open and we’re allowed to play there, although it’s no guarantee that we’ll play our remaining games at those fields.
No Field of Our Own
Like most teams in Manhattan, we don’t have our own field. Surrounded by a vast expanse of concrete, we have no place to play except on fields that are sometimes more than 100 blocks away from our West 17th St. school. Sometimes it takes us 45 minutes to get to the game site. This year, we’ve been late to two games and for most of the rest, we get there with a few minutes left to spare before game time.
But more troubling than the distance we have to travel is the condition of the fields. Most of them seem neglected by the New York City Parks Department, which is in charge of tending them.
Recently my team played on a field at 128th St. and 3rd Ave. There was less glass on this field, but what it didn’t have in shattered bottles it made up for in lack of grass and an uneven playing field. One of our players stepped on a battery when he was trying to field a ground ball and almost lost his balance.
Garbage on the fields poses a safety hazard to the players. It’s possible to slip while you’re throwing, and litter just increases that problem.
Another field in Dewitt Clinton Park, on 54th St. and 12th Ave., has almost no grass anywhere and a batter’s box with a deep rut in the middle of it. It could just be me, but it’s really hard to try and hit a ball when you’re standing in the middle of a hole.
Relief in Central Park
Since there are so few fields available, sometimes the competition is over the space as much as about the game. Once at Morningside Park, we shared the already undersized field with two girls’ softball teams practicing. The field was so cramped that our umpire swore at one of the softball coaches to move his team out of our way. We had a scheduled game; they were only practicing.
When we finally get to play in Central Park, in May, it’s such a welcome change because the fields are well maintained there. The field is flat and it’s actually covered in grass. There’s no rut in the middle of the batter’s box.
Playing on a well-tended field after dealing with a crappy, torn up field is like replacing your tattered Nikes with a new pair of sneakers. You don’t want to go back to the old ones once you’re wearing shoes in much better shape.
Playing on a good field also helps bring up the level of play. You don’t have to worry as much if the ball is going to take a bad hop off a rock or dip in the ground, or if you’re going to cut yourself sliding on glass or rocks that shouldn’t be there in the first place. (That’s my knee in the top left corner photo.)
On a field with grass and smooth paths between bases, you can concentrate on the game. If you screw up, you can’t blame it on the field.
Less Fun for All of Us
I’d like to be able to play on a nice field with lots of grass that’s much closer to my school than 101st St. I used to be excited about playing for my school team until I realized that half the battle of playing was actually getting to the field. Now, while I still appreciate the opportunity to play, I don’t feel excited. Even if we do get there on time, we still face playing on poorly kept fields.
I don’t look for the challenge of competition any more, though some teams are certainly worthy opponents. Instead, it feels like the challenge is dealing with the run down fields and still having a satisfying game.
I realize that we can’t expect more fields because there just isn’t enough room. But why isn’t something being done to better maintain what few fields there are? Playing on inadequate fields disrupts the quality of play and makes it less fun for all of us. The city should either open up the fields at Central Park in April or at least clean up the other fields that have needed tending for so long.
Fields of Glass
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.