You are working in New York, but don’t have the proper papers or I.D. to show that you are living in the U.S. legally.
If you or someone you know fits the above description, you or they should know about employer sanctions. This is one of the most important parts of the new immigration law-and the most controversial.
In the early 1980s, when the new immigration law was being proposed and debated, there was high unemployment in the United States. Many people felt that illegal immigrants, especially those coming from Cuba, Haiti, and Southeast Asia, were taking jobs away from American citizens and causing the economy to fail.
To address this concern-even though it hasn’t been proven yet-employer sanctions were included in the new immigration law.
Employer sanctions are warnings, stiff fines, and/or jail terms given to employers who hire illegal immigrants (those people who don’t have the proper papers that say they are able to work in the U.S.).
The law doesn’t apply to illegal immigrants who were hired by employers before November 6, 1986 (called “grandfathered employees”), nor to those who can prove that they are legally able to work in the U.S.
How Can I Prove That I’m Legal?
You’re probably now asking, “How does one prove that they can work in the U.S.? can’t anybody who is able to work, work?”
NO!
You have to be an authorized worker to work in this country. This means that you have to have the proper papers or identification to show you are a legal resident of this country.
In other words, if you are an illegal immigrant, it is against the law for an employer to give you a job.
If you are in the process of applying for amnesty or any of the other ways of becoming a legal resident, you can work. You should have a card that says this (such as a temporary work authorization card or a temporary legal resident card).
If you are an illegal immigrant working in this country and you are not a “grandfathered employee,” then you and your employer are breaking the law.
Everyone, including American citizens, has to show their employer some sort of proof that they are a legal resident of the country and that they can legally work here.
What can you show? Below is a list of things which can prove that you are a legal worker:
1) U.S. passport.
2) Citizenship or naturalization certificate. (This is a form you get when you apply for and are made a citizen of the U.S.)
3) A legal resident card (temporary or permanent)-the card you get when you are in the process of applying for amnesty.
4) An immigration registration card (also known as a “green card”).
5) Foreign passport that hasn’t expired.
6) State driver’s license.
7) Federal or state identification card (such as from your former employer).
8) Social Security card.
9) U.S. birth certificate.
10) Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) reentry permit (a form the INS gives you if you have left the United States and then come back).
If you have any of these forms of identification or others that prove you are a legal resident of the U.S. and are able to work in this country, you will have no problem being hired for a job.
Of course, there are employers who want to avoid the whole issue of checking your ID. There are those who are afraid to hire anyone who seems to be an immigrant because of the way they talk or look.
Employment Discrimination
To stop things like this, an anti-discrimination measure has been included along with employer sanctions. It says that it is against the law for an employer to discriminate against anyone because of their race, ethnicity, national origin, or legal resident status in the U.S.
So if you are in the middle of the amnesty process, you can’t be refused a job because you are not a citizen.
The law says the following acts by employers are considered discrimination:
1) Firing or not giving jobs to people who “look foreign.”
2) Giving jobs only to American citizens.
3) Giving jobs only to people who have certain types of papers. (An employer can refuse your foreign passport but cannot to refuse to accept a Social Security card.)
4) Not hiring people who have an accent.
5) Requiring all employees to speak English on the job at all times.
6) Giving jobs only to people who speak English well.
If you believe that an employer has done any of these things to you or to someone you know, you can report this to a Special Counsel set up by the U.S. Department of Justice. (This is called filing a “charge” or “complaint.”) You have 180 days to file your complaint.
However, no Special Counsel offices have yet been set up to receive complaints. If there is no Special Counsel office set up by the time the 180-day deadline is almost up, you can send a complaint letter with the facts of what happened and the names of the employer and victim to: Special Counsel for Immigration Discrimination, Department of Justice, P.O. Box 65490, Washington, DC, 20035-5490.
Someone can make the charge on your behalf if they are “directly affected” by the discrimination. This includes friends, relatives, union representatives, lawyers, and even the INS. The Special Counsel itself may wish to look into the charges made by you.
Proving that you have been discriminated against is not easy. Under the old discrimination law (not specifically aimed at immigration-related discrimination), all you have to do is prove that an employer’s action, such as having special requirements or giving special tests, was discriminatory-even if the discrimination that happened was not intentional.
But the new anti-discrimination law in the new immigration bill says that you have to prove “beyond a shadow of a doubt” that the employer meant to discriminate against you.
This is harder to do, especially if it is a case where the employer accepts only certain types of identification as proof of your legal residency. They can easily deny that they did this.
But don’t let this stop you from taking your complaint to the Special Counsel. If you have been discriminated against, you have the right to sue the employer.
Taking Legal Action
The Special Counsel will have 120 days to decide whether or not you or the person you represent was discriminated against. If they think so, they will give your complaint to an administrative law judge (ALJ), who will then decide on your case.
If the Special Counsel decides that you or the person you represent wasn’t a victim of discrimination, you have the right to take your complaint to an ALJ yourself, as long as it is done within 90 days after the Special Counsel has decided on the case.
If the judge also decides that you were not discriminated against, you may appeal this decision. You must bring the case to a U.S. Court of Appeals judge 60 days after the ALJ made her decision on the case in order to have it heard.
If the U.S. Court of Appeals agrees with the ALJ, you have lost your case. If not, you have won-unless the employer decides to appeal this decision.
The government hopes that employer sanctions will force illegal immigrants to apply for amnesty or the other types of legalization. If illegal immigrants can’t get jobs because employers aren’t allowed to hire them, they will have to come forward and apply to become legal residents of this country if they expect to work here.
But many immigration experts argue that these laws will cause even more discrimination, and that the anti-discrimination part of employer sanctions won’t help matters at all.
The government has said that they will remove the anti-discrimination law and/or employer sanctions if research proves that they are causing more discrimination and confusion among employers.
The U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO) will be doing reports for the next three years on the employer sanctions and anti-discrimination laws. If they find problems in the workplace and Congress votes to accept their findings, the anti-discrimination law will be removed.
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) is also looking into the effect the two laws are having on the workplace.
If you have questions about the law, or if you or someone you know has been discriminated against, you can call the ACLU’s Immigration Task Force at 212-944-9800.
It is better to be able to work in this country without being exploited or used by an employer. If you or anyone you know is an illegal immigrant, and you are working, you and your employer are taking the risk of being caught by the government.
You don’t have to be in this situation. Applying for amnesty would be the best thing for you.
Employer Sanctions and the New Immigration Law
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.