Down and Dirty to the Truth

A trip inside Manhattan Family Court.

Recently some Represent writers and I came together to take a tour of Manhattan Family Court, to get down and dirty to the truth about what really goes on. We wanted to be face to face with judges and lawyers, asking questions to get a better perspective on what their jobs are all about.
As we walked through the doors I remembered the last time I was in family court. I didn’t want to be there because it usually takes so long, and sometimes I get real impatient. But this time I was a reporter.
‘It’s Never Boring’
We met with Lou Sartori, who is in charge of the Legal Aid law guardians that are assigned to kids in care. We also met with a social worker named Peg O’Marra. They both were really nice and they weren’t stuck up like a lot of people in that field.
We asked what their days were like. “It’s never boring,” Lou told us. “It’s different every single day.” As a supervisor, he helps the law guardians solve problems they’re having with young people’s cases.
Peg said that as a social worker she helps young people and their families and works with lawyers to help them understand the issues that kids in court are dealing with.
“Sadly, we have a lot of emergency situations,” she said. “Questions about whether kids should stay or be removed, and what the child wants and whether or not that’s possible.”
What I liked best was when Lou told us he became a family court lawyer because he wanted to help people. “I thought working in family court with children made the most difference to the most people,” he said. “I liked the freedom I had to represent my clients the way they really want to be represented.” You’re supposed to like what you do, not just do it for the money, so that’s cool.
Some Judges Do Care
When we were done, Peg and Lou took us to a courtroom and we sat in on a few cases. I found the cases interesting, especially one about a kid in college who wasn’t getting the money he needed from ACS to pay for room and board.
The judge, Sheldon Rand, demanded that the ACS worker come to the next court date. It seemed like he would make sure that the kid got the money from ACS. That was incredible to see, because it made me think that some judges do care.
Then we meet a referee (like a judge) named Ms. Susan Doherty. She was so nice and she also made me think that not everyone in court is who we perceive them to be. Some of them do listen and understand our feelings and try to help as much as they can.
A Tough Case
Susan told us that one case that caught her was a young boy whose mother was not good to him, but he still wanted to be with her. “I said no more visits,” Susan told us. “I felt it would undermine his self-worth and close his mind to other options.” But the boy begged her to put the visits back on. It was up to Susan to make the decision.
“It was the most important thing in his life – I felt he was going to suffer if he didn’t get those visits,” she said. “So I told him,’OK, but you are never going to live with her.'” Susan seemed to care about her cases and that’s what I liked about her.
One Last Tip
Finally, we spoke with a couple of other social workers who told us that if you’re not comfortable talking to your law guardian, you can tell things to your social worker and your social worker can pass it on to your law guardian.
I found out a lot from our trip inside the court, and to my surprise I really liked everything that went on. It was a hot day, but everything I saw was cool.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.