Don’t Shut Us Out: Teach Us English Faster

Until 1974, even if you had arrived in this country not speaking or understanding a word of English, you would still have had to take all your classes in English.
That’s because there was no requirement for Bilingual Education or English as a Second Language (ESL) instruction in New York City. When Xavier Xacta, 16, a student at the International HS, first came to the United States, he went to a junior high school that didn’t offer any bilingual classes. All of his classes were in English, and he didn’t understand at all.
‘I Felt Like a Nobody’
“I felt frustrated because I was like nobody. I used to go to school and stay quiet all the time. At the start, I did not do anything because I didn’t understand English. The teacher didn’t know Spanish, so she could not help me,” Xavier said.
After a month, Xavier switched to a bilingual program.
For students like Xavier and me, who came to this country unable to speak any English, a school system without bilingual education would have been an enormous problem.
Luckily, for students arriving now, the city’s educational system was forced to accommodate the growing number of new immigrants in the city.
Bilingual Classes Can Help
In the early 1970s, people brought lawsuits on behalf of students who needed to be taught in their own language while first learning English.
As a result, the Board of Education created bilingual education to provide the non-English speakers with classes in their native languages, while also teaching them English.
At the start, bilingual education was just offered in Spanish. But after a while, people brought lawsuits to have bilingual education in other languages.
There are now 14 bilingual programs, including Chinese, Spanish, Haitian-Creole, Russian, Korean, Bengali, Polish, French and Arabic.
About 85,000 students are now in bilingual programs, and an additional 70,000 take ESL classes.
Which languages are taught is determined by the number of immigrants speaking that language in the community. In New York City, the predominant bilingual program is still Spanish. There are about 72,000 Spanish bilingual students.
Reform the Program
But as bilingual education in New York City approaches its 25th anniversary, a debate is simmering around the country over whether it is serving its purpose.
In California, some people are pushing to do away with bilingual education. And others around the country agree that it doesn’t work.
But I don’t think bilingual education should be eliminated, because as Mr. Defazio, a linguistics teacher at the International HS said, “bilingual education is important to keep our roots.”
It is a great help for students who have recently come to this country. But I do believe it needs to be reformed.
Based on my experience and the experiences of many other students I spoke to, the system doesn’t seem to teach immigrant students English as fast as it could, and it hurts their education as a result.
And with strict new rules being proposed for the city university (CUNY) system, these students could be prevented from attending college if they don’t master English sooner.
Too Slow a Pace
My bilingual classes taught so little English that I felt forced to teach myself. This makes me wonder if officials are really aware of the problems with bilingual education.
When I first came to this country and enrolled in a bilingual program, I found it really helpful to continue studying my subjects in Spanish while I began learning English. And many other non-English speakers like it because it helps them adjust more easily.
Sonia Huerta, 16, a junior at International HS said, “It helped me learn some English, because I was new to this country.”
But after almost a year in school, I felt I was learning too slowly. The only time I was studying English was in ESL, which was only one period a day.
Sonia had a similar experience.
“I had one class in English and the rest of the classes were taught in Spanish,” she said. “Also, all my classmates spoke Spanish, and I spoke Spanish with them.”
Xavier said even his ESL class was taught in Spanish, although it was supposed to be his English lesson.
Not Enough English
So why does bilingual education offer so little English instruction? To find out, I interviewed John Acompore, the deputy director of the Office of Bilingual Education.
Mr. Acompore said beginners should take most of their subjects in their native language. In the second year, students should take half of their subjects in Spanish, and the other half in English.
But Mr. Acompore acknowledged that some bilingual programs don’t follow the rules.
And my and others students’ experiences confirm this, because in our first two years of bilingual education, we got only one English class per day.
Some students are not getting as much English as they should because schools often have many different levels of English speakers all together in one class. This is because they don’t have enough teachers to offer more classes.
Learning From Each Other
The Board of Education hopes to hire more bilingual teachers so they can teach separate classes for the more advanced students.
Unfortunately, there aren’t enough qualified bilingual teachers.
So the Board of Education is also working to improve bilingual education by trying out different programs, such as the “two-way program.”
In the two-way program, a class of half English speakers and half non-English speakers is taught in English. This way, students who know English can teach students who don’t.
Also, English-speaking students can learn from the students whose native languages are different.
Push Us Toward Fluency
As it is now, it should take a student in bilingual education five to seven years to learn “academic English,” which means enough fluency to be able to understand, write and read English in all subjects, Mr. Acompore said.
But I cannot understand how a student is going to be able to understand English in five to seven years if she is receiving only one English class a day.
Also, I think teachers should put more pressure on students to learn English. Some students just get too comfortable being in bilingual classes and do not put a lot of effort into learning English.
Many students feel the current system holds up their progress. Melissa Perez, 16, said she doesn’t think she would have become fluent in English if she had stayed in a bilingual program.
“They didn’t teach me enough English. I had one class in English, and I couldn’t use the little English I knew because in my class nobody spoke English.”
A system like the two-way program would at least have given Melissa the chance to converse in English.
If bilingual education is reformed, newcomers to this country might be able to go to a bilingual program for two years and then transfer to an all-English school like I did.
To achieve this goal, bilingual programs need more classes taught in English, and at all different levels. To be able to do this, the Board of Education needs to hire more qualified bilingual teachers.
By improving bilingual education, the city can help immigrants learn English faster and spend fewer years feeling frustrated and isolated from English-speaking American life.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.