Is It A Choice? Answers to 300 of the Most Frequently Asked Questions About Gays and Lesbians, By Eric Marcus, Harper San Francisco, $10.
How do you become a homosexual? Are you born gay? Is homosexuality a mental illness?
These are a few of the many questions that I had about homosexuals. Until recently, all I knew about gays were the stereotypes. My images of gay people were men who spoke with lisps and women who didn’t shave their legs.
But lately, a lot of my friends have been telling me that they have feelings for people of the same gender. Most of them think it’s a phase and believe they’re going to get over it but they have a lot of questions. They come to me for advice and support. I’m great at rooting for them, no matter what, but answering their questions about homosexuality is out of my league.
I wanted to help my friends, but how could I when I knew absolutely nothing about homosexuality myself? And where could I go to get that kind of information?
Believe it or not, I found the answers I was looking for in a book-Is It A Choice? Answers to 300 of the Most Frequently Asked Questions About Gays and Lesbians by Eric Marcus.
Real Life Answers
The book follows a question and answer format. Marcus, a gay journalist, introduces the book with the statement: “There’s no such thing as a stupid question.” He then goes on to answer everything from “What do kids call their two same-sex parents?” to “If you’re a teenager and think you’re gay or lesbian, what should you do?”
Before reading the book, I wrote down all the questions I had about homosexuals. If the book answers my questions thoroughly and logically, I thought, then the book is cool. If not, then it sucks.
Frankly, I didn’t have high expectations. I thought the book would be dull and boring, full of statistics and psychoanalyst’s reports. I also worried that it would leave me with more questions than answers.
But when I read Is It A Choice? I was amazed. The book is the complete opposite of what I thought it would be. Instead of being boring and too hard to read, it was straightforward and compelling. Marcus explains things by giving you examples from real life. For example, in answer to the title question, Marcus quotes what a friend of his says when people ask him why he chooses to be gay: “Why would I choose to be something that horrifies my parents, that could ruin my career, that my religion condemns, and that could cost me my life if I dared to walk down the street holding hands with my boyfriend?”
Something You Can’t Control
Marcus also describes what it was like for him, growing up knowing that “the most horrible thing you could call someone was f-got” and how he came to realize that being attracted to someone of the same gender is something that gay men and lesbians can’t control. It would be like asking a straight guy to force himself not to be attracted to women-he couldn’t do it.
Marcus’s answers convinced me that a lot of the stereotypes I had about gays and lesbians weren’t true. Remember how I used to think that gay men talked with lisps? Well, according to Marcus, “Some gay men lisp, as do some heterosexual men. A lisp is a type of speech defect.” Marcus quotes Richard, a straight man, who had a lisp as a child: “The other kids would call me f-got and I’m not even gay.” Do more gay men than heterosexual men lisp? That, Marcus says, is “one of those human mysteries that remains to be answered.”
Do Lesbians Wear Make Up?
How about that other stereotype I had, the one about lesbians not shaving their legs? I expected a really exotic answer like “the reason why lesbians don’t shave is because they took an oath never to shave their legs under any circumstances.”
But the book explains that there are no rules about not shaving or not wearing make up that all lesbians follow. One lesbian that Marcus interviewed said that she doesn’t wear makeup because “It runs on my face. I can’t be bothered.” Another said she does wear it because “I look so much better.” The same applies to shaving-some do and some don’t.
I also learned many things from the book that I didn’t know before. The thing that fascinated me the most was the explanation of why many gays wear upside-down pink triangle pins. It’s in memory of the thousands of homosexuals who were persecuted and killed by the Nazis during the Holocaust. The same way that Jews were forced to wear yellow stars on their jackets to identify themselves as Jews, gays and lesbians had to wear pink triangles.
Before reading that, I didn’t think gays were recognized at all before the 1970s. The book explains that in recent years “Gay and lesbian people began wearing the inverted pink triangle symbol to publicly identify themselves as homosexuals, as a symbol of pride, and as a way of commemorating those who died in the concentration camps.”
Human Beings, Not Freaks
Is It A Choice? burst my bubble in a good way. It showed me that gays are not trying to be different or weird, the way a lot of straight people think. They’re not freaks of nature or mutants or aliens from outer space. They’re human beings who have to worry about bills, work, school, socializing, and death just like everyone else.
The book is great for anyone who needs a better understanding of homosexuals and homosexuality. It’s also great for teens who are in the process of coming out. The book will help them to appreciate who they are and how they can move on with their lives without being ashamed of their sexuality.
Don’t Be Afraid to Ask
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.