Does Sex Make A Relationship?

(All names in this story have been changed.)
I was hanging out with Anthony, one of my male friends, and we started talking about the difference between a relationship and a friendship. Anthony summed up the difference in one word: sex.
I didn’t respond at the time, but Anthony really threw me off track with that answer. I’m not used to having a friend who feels that sex makes a relationship. For some reason I took it personally, and I wondered if most other guys felt like he did.
So to find out, I asked two of my male co-workers, John and Eddie, and two of my male friends, Al and James. First I asked them what they thought made a relationship. They basically said the same thing, “Communication and commitment.”
Sexual vs. Emotional
Then I asked them about the difference between a relationship and a friendship. None of them said sex, but they did say there is a difference in how physical you get with the person. They said you obviously get more physical in a relationship.
Some guys think like Anthony, but for John and Eddie, sex wasn’t the answer that came straight out. “Getting physical” doesn’t always imply sex. It could also imply kissing, holding hands, and touching certain places that you wouldn’t on a friend.
I found other guys who don’t think like Anthony. Like my friend Al, who told me that a relationship is deeper than a friendship. That’s the difference. I completely agree with him.
So my question to you is, “Is it sex that makes a relationship? Or is it that unique emotional feeling you get from your partner?”
The feeling I’m talking about is love. Whenever you hear that person’s name, you get all warm inside-that special person who you can talk to about personal stuff and who you don’t have to worry about going behind your back or betraying your trust. The love you have for him that keeps you faithful, and the love he has for you that calms you down in stressful times.
I totally disagree with Anthony that sex makes a relationship. If what he said was true, then all relationships without sex are just friendships. And all one night stands are relationships. It just doesn’t sound logical.
Finding Ryull
There was something in the way Anthony said it that made me look at my own relationship. The way he said it made my relationship look fake.
I’ve known my boyfriend, Ryull, for almost three years. (We met October 3, 1994.) About three weeks after we met, we started getting serious about each other. We started doing stuff we didn’t do as friends, like holding hands, kissing, looking forward to the next Monday with a little more enthusiasm (we met at the same time and place every Monday), and using the ‘L’ word a lot.
We went out for about eight months. After we broke up, we still remained friends. In July of 1995 Ryull dropped by my house and that was the last time I saw him. We lost contact and in November of 1995 I moved from Long Island to Queens.
Something was telling me to call Ryull, so I decided to call him on his birthday in February of 1996. His aunt kept on telling me that he wasn’t home. Since I wasn’t looking to rekindle anything, I didn’t think that much of it. It didn’t hit me that there was something wrong until his aunt asked for my address and phone number, and said she’d give it to him the next time she spoke to him. Even then she didn’t tell me Ryull had moved out of state to a group home.
At that time I began to wonder why Ryull was never home. No matter how early or late I called, whoever answered the phone would tell me he was out. They never could tell me the best time to call so I could reach him. Around this time I moved again. This time from Queens to Manhattan.
About three months after I moved, my old foster mother Delores called to tell me that a letter just came for me. She told me it was from Ryull. I took down the phone number and address of where Ryull was living. It took me a while, but I finally called him. It took me so long to call because he was now living out of state and it was no longer a local call.
Telepathic Communication
We talked as friends throughout the summer. On September 2, 1996 something hit me and these words came out from my mouth: “Do you want to go back out with me?” Ryull’s answer was an instant… “yes.” And we’ve been back together ever since.
From when we first met in 1994, Ryull and I never had sex. What makes this a relationship is the feeling I get from Ryull. But even though he lives in another state (Ryull is in Durham, Connecticut, and I live in the Bronx), I can feel him near.
I can’t explain it. When something is wrong, I just know that Ryull can feel my pain. In one of his letters he wrote, “I have pain like God is telling me something is wrong.” During that same week I was having really bad headaches. Or if I’m about to do something I shouldn’t do, I can feel him pulling me back.
It’s a special feeling that I have for him. And since we are living in different states, our relationship is based on the love we have for each other, not on the sex that we never had. When we first started going out while we both were living in Long Island, we didn’t have sex because I was a virgin and Ryull respected my decision to wait. Now that we are in different states, we can’t (and I don’t believe in phone sex).
I guess that for some people it’s sex that makes a relationship different from a friendship. And for others it’s the emotional feeling that makes the difference.
As for Ryull and me, I’m not saying that the topic of sex doesn’t come up. But since we are living in separate states, other issues, like when we’re going to see each other again, are much more important than sex. We talked about it a couple of times when we first got together, but in the same sentence we also talked of marriage.
A True Relationship
I love Ryull. In a world filled with emotional roller coasters, it’s good to know there is one person who I can turn to, at any given time, and have stability. And he is mine-all mine. I don’t have to share him with any other girl (besides his mother).
As for me, a person has to make me happy in a mental way before I could truly enjoy sex with him. Despite everything, we are still together because we love each other, and the time we’ve spent apart made us realize this even more.
You don’t have to have sex in order to be in a relationship. You just have to truly love a person.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.