“It’s funky and slamming, it’s hype. It makes you do a dance that you never did before,” said Damon, 16, from Adlai Stevenson HS, describing heavy metal, his favorite type of music.
Heavy metal is a fast, loud, upbeat music, dominated by guitars and screaming songs. With their long, teased hair, ripped jeans, and black leather jackets, heavy-metal musicians have a reputation for racism, sexism, profanity, and drug use.
The general perception is that heavy metal encourages violence, racism, drug and alcohol abuse, satanism, and sexism. Recently, Cardinal O’Connor blamed this kind of music for attracting young people to Devil-worship. He cited the song “Suicide Solution” by Ozzy Osbourne as a prime example.
But many teenagers identify with heavy-metal musicians. As Damon said, “They express the way I feel. It makes me feel like the baddest person in the world.”
“When they sing slow songs, I feel that they are singing to me-like Ratt’s album’Invasion of your Privacy,'” said Lynn Manning, 17, also from Stevenson HS.
Unfair Reputation?
Jon Nardachone, program director of radio station WSOU in South Orange, New Jersey, feels that heavy-metal musicians are being blamed unfairly for encouraging violence, racism, and sexism. “They have nothing to do with it,” he said.
Nardachone also feels that teenagers misinterpret the lyrics of heavy metal music. “Maybe they’re getting the wrong idea, but that’s not what the artist is saying. It’s the way the artist expresses the way he or she feels and it deals with life experience,” he said.
Lynn Manning said that listening to heavy-metal music has less impact on teens than most people think.
“They don’t influence me. They don’t rule me… heavy-metal, it doesn’t make me crazy,” she said.
But she agreed that some teens take the lyrics too literally. “If the song is saying kill the Black man, kill the White man, they go out and do it,” she added.
When asked about heavy metal’s reputation for causing violence, Manning admitted that it was partly true: “At Motley Crue’s concert, the cops were fighting with the teens. It seems the kids were wild…no control.”
Damon said that heavy metal, which is dominated by White musicians and audiences, has no more problems with violence than rap music, which is dominated by Blacks. “When it comes to slam dancing and temper tantrums,” heavy-metal expresses anger and desperation rather than violence, Damon added.
Damon also defended the use of profanity in heavy-metal music: “Yeah, it’s the way I express myself. [But] I won’t curse in public like Guns’N Roses did at the American Music Awards.”
Should Albums be Rated?
On the issue of rating albums which use profanity, Nardachone expressed disagreement.
“Is there a label when you rent a movie? No, the artist should have the right to express the way they feel. Why should they be limited?” he asked.
But Nardachone also believes that there are limits: “I think that some bands should be banned because some songs have no class.”
Heavy metal also has a reputation for turning teens on to drugs and alcohol. But according to Damon, this reputation is not deserved.
“I don’t do drugs,” he said. “Yeah, I drink on New Year’s Eve, a little Ripple…[but] I rarely drink.”
Manning also said that she did not drink or do drugs and neither did her friends. Oscar Tirado, 17, admitted that his friends drink and do drugs, but said, “It has nothing to with the music.”
“Nine out of 10 rock or heavy-metal bands like Ozzy Osbourne and Metallica are against using drugs. Through life experience, they’re saying this is not the answer-like Ozzy Osbourne’s “Suicide Solution” and Metallica’s “Master of Puppets,” claimed Nardachone.
Asked if these bands influenced the way he dressed, Damon answered, “In a way, but not tattoos. I’m just having fun.”
“I can’t see myself in tight leather pants [like many heavy-metal musicians]. It’s too sissy for me,” said Tirado.
‘Satanism is Stupid’
On the controversial subject of heavy metal’s glamorization of satanism and Devil-worship, Damon responded, “It’s against my belief. If they [other teens] do it, they’re a-holes.”
Lynn agreed: “It doesn’t expose me to satanism. I don’t believe in it. I think anyone who’s into satanism is stupid.”
How do parents feel about heavy metal?
Lynn said that her parents “don’t care as long they don’t have to hear it…I think that [most parents] are afraid that their children will become sexual or violent. They think their kids are going to do what the song says: `kill the father and stab the mother.'”
“They don’t like it because it’s so loud,” Damon said of his parents. He said most parents don’t like heavy metal because they feel that it makes their kids “act crazy and dumb and drop out of school.”
Manning had the following advice for our teenage readers: “Just be careful about what you hear and know what you are listening to. don’t do what they say, be your own person. It’s just a song.”
Does Heavy Metal Influence Teenagers?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.