Does Downloading Free Music = Freeloading?

There’s only one thing I like better than music, and that’s free music. I think most teenagers will agree with me that music costs a lot of money, money that we don’t have. CDs can cost upwards of $15, and concert tickets as much as $50. That’s why I thank God for Napster.
Basically, Napster is a way for people to swap music for free using their computers. Developed by 19-year-old Shawn Fanning, the Napster program gives users access to thousands of songs.
Once you’ve downloaded the Napster software, free from the Napster.com website, you become one of over 20 million Napster members. (It takes only a few minutes, but a lot of your computer’s hard drive space.) Then you can make any or all of the MP3 music files on your computer available to other members to download, and you can download their music files.
Free Music in Minutes
The process of downloading music can take as little as five minutes, depending on the speed of your modem. You’ll get a list of Napster users who have what you’re looking for, and a link to their computers. As long as you have a computer with web access, the music won’t cost you a dime.
But downloading free music, like most good things in life, doesn’t come without controversy. Not everyone agrees that Napster is a godsend. Napster’s opponents, who include lots of recording artists and record companies, argue that downloading songs with Napster is the same as stealing, and are trying to shut the service down.
But Is it Legal?
Is it legal-or ethical-to download copyrighted material without asking the artist’s permission and without paying a cent? That depends, in part, on your understanding of copyright law.
Copyright is the right of the creator of a piece of work to control the reproduction and use of that work. If someone wants to copy some or all of a copyrighted work, they have to ask permission to do so if they intend to sell the results.
For example, rappers, hip-hop artists and other musicians are supposed to get permission for any song samples they use on their own recordings. If they don’t get permission, they may get sued.
But it’s considered “fair use,” and therefore legal, to tape a song off the radio or photocopy a magazine article for your own personal use.
Bizkit and Love Support Napster
Napster’s supporters see Napster as a perfectly legal service that doesn’t violate copyright laws as long as the music downloaded isn’t used for personal profit. Most people in favor of Napster are the users of the service, but also include Courtney Love and the band Limp Bizkit. To show their support, Limp Bizkit even gave free concerts on a Napster-sponsored tour this summer.
Those who are against Napster say that since Napster and its members haven’t gotten the artists’ permission to exchange their music online, what they’re doing is the equivalent of stealing from the artists. For every album that is sold, the artist gets a certain percentage of the profits. Artists lose out if fans acquire music for free online and don’t buy the albums.
Getting Paid, Keeping Control
The anti-Napster crowd includes artists like Metallica and Dr. Dre, who have been very vocal in their opposition to free online distribution of their music. They’re not only angered by what they claim is lost income, but also by the fact that they no longer have control over the distribution of their music.
Lars Ulrich, the drummer for Metallica, told the U.S. Senate in July that Napster didn’t ask the band’s permission to make Metallica’s music accessible on the web. Ulrich compared the service to walking into a music store and just taking any CDs you want without paying for them. He said that Metallica is not against new technology and web access to music, just against piracy. The band hopes in the future to sell downloadable music on the web, but under their control.
Record companies are also in an uproar over the service. The companies claim that sales figures show consumers are buying fewer CDs because people can get the songs they want free through Napster.
Taking it to Court
The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), a trade organization representing roughly 90% of the music industry, filed the first lawsuit against Napster in December of 1999.
The RIAA claims that Napster is a haven for online piracy, and should be shut down. “Napster and other online sites that built businesses on copyrights of others are not good,” says Doug Curry, a spokesman for the RIAA. “They’re benefiting off the sweat of other people.” Napster lost their effort to have the case dismissed, and the RIAA court case is scheduled to take place this fall.
Napster has been hit on other fronts, too. In May, Metallica and Dr. Dre demanded the right to kick off those Napster users who had made their songs available for downloading. Napster agreed and banned those users, who had to struggle to get reconnected.
Metallica and Dr. Dre then took their position one step further. They each filed a lawsuit against Napster in an effort to shut the company down. The lawsuits led to a surge of anti-Napster publicity, with artists jumping on the bandwagon to oppose the fairly new company.
‘Get Our Permission!’
More than 50 acts, including Blink 182, DMX and Faith Hill, banded together to give concerned artists a unified voice on the issue. This coalition, called Artists Against Piracy, doesn’t want music distributed without the artists’ permission.
“Artists deserve compensation for their work,” said Noah Stone, of Artists Against Piracy. “We are not against the technology [used by] Napster, but are against the company Napster,” because its system does not offer the recording artists any compensation.
Stone favors online music distribution, but with compromise, stating that “music on the Internet should be priced in line with the costs of making it and the demand, but not [priced] as high as CDs.”
Napster, however, says that downloading songs online without paying for them is legal. The website’s lawyers argue that the principle of free media through new technology is nothing new.
When VCRs first came out, Sony sued the VCR companies, saying that taping movies from TV was illegal. Sony lost in 1984, when the Supreme Court decided that some non-commercial copying is protected by law, as long as it’s for personal use.
Based on this case, Napster says that as long as its users don’t download songs for commercial use, such as selling the songs to others, it’s not illegal.
Napster also argues that anything that may be done illegally by its users is not the company’s responsibility. It states explicitly on the Napster website the terms and conditions of using the software: “Napster does not, and cannot, control what content is available to you using the Napster browser. Users are responsible for complying with all applicable federal and state laws…including copyright laws.”
Napster says that there is no way the company can enforce these rules, since the songs are not actually on their website, but are on other users’ computers. Napster argues that it isn’t in a position to control what people download and how they use those files.
Nothing’s Settled Yet
The battle between those in favor of free music and those opposed to it isn’t likely to end soon. Because of the RIAA, Napster was almost shut down in the summer.
Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, the judge who announced a court injunction against Napster, stated that “the fact that Napster users get for free something they ordinarily would have to pay for suggests that they reap an economic advantage from Napster use.”
She said that since a majority of Napster users downloaded copyrighted music without the permission of the artists or their record companies, Napster was running an illegal operation and should be shut down.
The injunction would have stopped Napster from operating until the case is settled, but Napster’s lawyers got the injunction repealed so, at least for now, Napster remains up and running.
More Users Than Ever
Despite-or even because-of the website’s problems, Napster’s popularity continues to rise. According to NetValue, a company which provides reports on internet surfers, Napster experienced a 480% increase in users between February and June of this year. And when Judge Patel ordered Napster to shut down in July, nearly twice as many people as usual rushed to use the service. Even if its future is threatened, all the fuss over Napster has given it tons of free publicity and attracted lots of new users.
I confess, I first heard about Napster in February in the newspapers and on television. Of course, I joined and quickly got addicted to it. The first song I ever downloaded was “Bent” by Matchbox Twenty, and I eventually bought the CD. My Napster “library” now has over 15 songs and is continuously growing. The number of songs I have, though, is limited by the amount of space available on my hard drive.
Sampling New Sounds Online
Napster is by far the easiest way to sample music and get introduced to new artists-easier than going to the music store, and even easier than ordering CDs or cassettes online.
About half my collection of online music consists of popular songs sold in music stores, and half is made up of new artists who I had not heard of before Napster.
Other music fans love Napster so much that they’ve started to turn against the artists who oppose it. Ever since Metallica and Dr. Dre took on Napster, many Napster users have spoken out against these artists, viewing them as money-hungry, with only their self-interests in mind.
Have CD Sales Been Affected?
Former Metallica fans write in chat rooms about their anger toward the band, calling for a boycottt of the band’s CDs. “With everything being so expensive nowadays, who can afford to waste money on trash records like Metallica?” says “Swakoo,” who posted his opinion on a Metallica message board. It’s hard to tell, though, whether people have actually retaliated against Metallica and Dr. Dre by not buying their records.
On the same note, there’s no hard evidence to support the artists’ claims, and the RIAA’s claim, that Napster is responsible for lowering CD sales. Indeed, Wired News reported a study indicating that 59% of people who have listened to an artist’s music on Napster for the first time will buy the artist’s CD.
When Music Costs Too Much, Everyone Loses
Even though I wish for Napster to stay in operation as it is, I have strong doubts that it will be able to. Napster will probably have to compromise with the recording industry on what can and can’t be traded.
It may end up paying a licensing fee to the record companies, and it might then pass along that cost to its users.
The outrage of music companies and artists is too strong for a court to permit Napster to continue operating without such changes. On the other hand, the online music industry is continuously growing, so even if Napster shuts down, there are other Napster-like services, like Scour, Freenet, Gnutella and Spinfrenzy, that may keep the free music going.
But until free versions of copyrighted songs are banned from the Internet, Napster will continue to be a staple in many music-loving houses throughout the world.
Artists are entitled to get paid just like any other worker, but when music companies charge too much for music, everyone loses: the artists, the consumers and eventually the music companies.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.