You have probably heard of foster care and you may even know someone who has been placed in “out-of-home” care-because there are over 35,000 young people in foster care in New York City right now.
Young people who are in foster care are placed in another home, a group home or an institution. “The removal of a child from his regular home to any sort of foster care can be either voluntary or non-voluntary,” according to Jon Bradley, a social worker at the DOOR, a multiple service youth agency in Manhattan. If a parent feels that they can’t cope with their child they may voluntarily place the child in the foster care system. However, any time a parent decides to voluntarily submit their child into foster care an advocate should always be present to explain the conditions of the situation,” says Jim Morrisey, an attorney at the DOOR.
Involuntary placement is more common than voluntary placement. It occurs when the state intervenes to take a child away against the parents’ wishes. The most common reasons for the state to remove children from the family’s care are abandonment and neglect which account for 80% of all removals. Another 10% of children are removed because their parents abuse them. Additional reasons for foster care include death of the parents or serous physical or emotional handicaps.
There are over 500,000 children in some type of foster care nationwide. This is only a rough estimate because of inadequate record-keeping by foster care agencies. Though foster care is supposed to be temporary, approximately half of the children in foster care are not permanently placed for over four years and 20% were still not placed after six years. Eighteen percent of the children are moved more than three times before finding a permanent placement.
The foster care system is also expensive-it costs the taxpayers almost 500 million per year.
Problems For Children and Parents
Efforts to see that children are placed properly and receive good care are often ineffective. For example, the social workers who usually decide a child’s fate have impossibly large case loads: an average of 50 to 150 children each. The paperwork necessary for all those cases is time consuming and prevents the social worker from getting to know the child and his parents. Most social workers don’t have enough training in the problems of families that cause difficulties for children. As a result, many social workers are frustrated. This makes high turnover, which makes it especially difficult to provide satisfactory care for foster children.
When a child is placed out of home the parent is generally not encouraged to see them. For example, according to Jon Bradley, “A family may live in the City and many foster care facilities are in Westchester. Most parents cannot afford the trip and it is rare that an agency provides money for transportation.
Many parents are discouraged because first their child is taken away and then they are inaccessible; they feel powerless against the system.” In most cases parents are not even notified when their child is moved. Once a child is taken from home, his case is reviewed. During that period the parent may know nothing of the child’s progress.
It would seem natural to place the child with relatives, but that idea is not taken seriously. “A relative would have to be deemed a special foster parent and this takes extra time and effort,” said Jon Bradley. Mr. Morrisey added that, “A case worker would be hesitant to do this because if the relative lives down the street, the parent could go down and abuse the kid.”
Parents are also not helped with the problem which caused the removal of the child in the first place. “Agencies are paid to help the children, not the parents,” said Mr. Bradley. This certainly hampers a child’s chance of returning home.
When Should Parents’ Rights Be Cut Off?
A major reason children stay in foster care so long is that that courts are reluctant to cut off the legal rights of biological parents-even if it is clear that the child will not return to them. If parental rights cannot be terminated there is no chance of finding a permanent home through adoption.
Even if a child is finally put up for adoption certain circumstances can make them hard to adopt. The hardest children to find homes for are minorities, those who are physically or emotionally handicapped, and older children.
“Older children are certainly the hardest to place. Most people want children they can mold, not teens who are already molded,” said Bradley. Morrisey added that “Most teens prefer to be in a group home because it focuses more on treatment.” Incidentally, the average age of children in foster care is nearly 12, and is rising.
In 1976 Harrison Goldin, Comptroller of New York City, released a report stating that out of 35,657 children in foster care only 5,431 (15%) were discharged to permanent homes (parent, relatives, or adoption). Presently 80% of New York City’s foster children are Black or Hispanic and they stay in care several years longer than children in other parts of the country.
One reason for long stays may be that institutions can lose up to $2,000 a month if the child leaves. For example, a report by the National Commission of Children in Need of Parents described a county welfare department in New York that refused to give up a retarded, heart-damaged child to a New Jersey agency that found an adoptive home for the child. County welfare officials argued they would lose federal aid if the child were given up.
Such a financial system encourages the higher-cost option of continued foster care over adoption. Foster care institutions that are supported by payments for each child in their care have little incentive to place those children elsewhere.
In addition, much of the money spent on foster care may be wasted. According to Comptroller Goldin’s report, in New York City $28 million goes to unappropriated expenses, including excessive administrative costs.
Working For Change
The Edna McConnell Clark Foundation is one organization working to find permanent solutions for children in foster care. Children nowadays who grow up in foster care have little stability. This lack of permanency can lead them to become negative about themselves and distrustful of other people. Then at 18 they are thrust into the world. Many go into the army, or just end up on the street to get into trouble, and are put into jail.
“The system works on dollars and cents; the child is not put first. The child could be put first if the government paid agencies to find permanent homes for children instead of keeping them,” said Jon Bradley.
According to Barbara Randloff-Baldwin at the Clark Foundation, “We want to increase the number of children in care who are returned to parents or adopted when appropriate. We also, support agencies that have similar objectives, such as Family Builders, a network of agencies that support permanent families through adoption. This is just a small target that we are aiming at. There is still a lot of other work that is needed.”
Does Anyone Care About Foster Care?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.