When my good friend Ufa told me that Mrs. Lenore (Lenny) Roseman, our former health and sex education teacher, wanted us to be on a television show with her, I jumped at the opportunity.
I was invited, along with three other students from Beach Channel High School, to be a guest on the Jane Wallace Show, which is aired on the Lifetime cable channel.
The topic of discussion: should there be school-based health clinics in high schools and should teens be taught about sexuality in school?
We were also hooked up via satellite to the St. Paul Ramsey Medical Center in Minneapolis, Minnesota, which sponsors a school-based health clinic. The main speaker there was Sandra Naughton, the clinic’s director.
Jane Wallace introduced us to the panelists in the studio. Those for the clinics and sex education were Dr. Joycelyn Elders, from Little Rock, Arkansas, and Mrs. Roseman.
Those against sex ed and clinics were Mrs. Julie Wright, also from Little Rock, Arkansas (representing a parent group) and Ms. Annmarie Morgan.
Does Sex Ed’Promote’ Sex?
As public high school students who have had sex education and know its value in our lives, we were ready with our arguments and excited to present them on television.
Opinions quickly surfaced when Mrs. Wright and Ms. Morgan said that it was up to the parents to teach their children about sex and that school-based clinics weren’t effective and promoted sex.
Mrs. Wright said: “If a girl were to go in for a headache wanting an aspirin, she would be asked all sorts of questions on her sexual activities and such, so that when she leaves the clinic she’ll come out with aspirins in one hand and birth control in the other.”
Mrs. Wright said that sex education should promote abstinence.
Ms. Naughton, who spoke for the clinic in St. Paul, stated that “when teens use contraceptives, they’ll use them incorrectly.” That’s why, she said, school-based clinics are important, because teens need to know the facts!
Dr. Elders was very articulate about the clinics. She felt very strongly that teens need others besides their parents to give them information on family planning. She interrupted Mrs. Wright many times to clear up the facts.
Making Responsible Choices
The studio audience seemed pretty much on the side of the clinics and sex education in schools. An important part of the program was having teenagers (including me) voice their opinions.
One point that Mrs. Wright used in her attack against sex education was that they are “How To” courses that teach teens to have sex. This more than shocked us, because we thought it was ridiculous.
One teen who commented on this was Patty Hempel, a senior at Beach Channel High School: “In our health class, which Mrs. Roseman taught, we were taught to realize what our values are, and even though we talked about values, we weren’t forced to think one way or another. If we felt we wanted to have sex, fine. And if we don’t, that’s o.k. too. She said it’s our decision and we have to make responsible choices.”
Mrs. Roseman agreed, saying that that’s why it’s important to have sex education courses, to help teens realize their values and to teach us to be safe and healthy, especially in this age of AIDS.
It was a heated argument to the very end of the show’s taping. People were obviously agitated and excited by the discussion.
A Distorted Quote
I was able to speak with Mrs. Wright afterwards and she showed me a book that she claimed is pornographic. It’s called “Changing Bodies, Changing Lives.” It’s used in a school district in Chicago.
She quoted from the book on the show: “…incest is an enjoyable and pleasurable experience for a child.” She used the quote to say how bad sex education is.
In reality, what the book said (I read it for myself) was that incest victims, out of confusion and fear, often feel that it is a pleasurable and enjoyable experience. Mrs. Wright used the quote out of context.
There seemed to be a lot of inconsistencies and misconceptions in what Mrs. Wright and Ms. Morgan were saying. Sandra Naughton, speaking for the school-based clinics, said, “How could we be a comprehensive health clinic if we ignore everything from the arm pits to the knees?”
When I had my health class with Mrs. Roseman, there were no objections to sex education from anyone. The class was informative, helping us to come to terms with our value systems and decision making. And yes, we learned about birth control (condoms, spermicides, “the pill,” etc.) because we need to know how to prevent against pregnancy and, most importantly, to protect our lives. AIDS and other infectious diseases are being spread among teenagers through sexual activity.
I think I speak for Mrs. Roseman and the others when I say it was an incredible experience to see how much ignorance there is about sex education and school-based clinics.
Debating Sex Education on the ‘Jane Wallace Show’
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.