Last year ACS announced a plan (not yet in effect) to restructure foster care into neighborhood-based networks. Children would be placed in the same neighborhoods where they were removed to prevent disruption in schooling and family ties. In addition, more preventive services would be made available in these neighborhoods to better assist at-risk families and possibly prevent the children from going into care.
(What does this mean? How will it affect you? For an in-depth look, see my article on pg. 20).
On Tuesday, November 25, I participated in a panel discussion on neighborhood-based services, held in the television studio of the CUNY Graduate Center in Manhattan. ACS Commissioner Nicholas Scoppetta was present, as well as Peter Digre, director of the Los Angeles Department of Children and Family Services, who said that the neighborhood-based policy has worked surprisingly well in Los Angeles.
Also sitting on the panel were David Lewis and Rachel Swarns (reporters from the Daily News and The New York Times, respectively), who served as both moderators and questioners; Sister Mary Paul of the Center for Family Life (who has had success in her Brooklyn neighborhood offering community services to families in need); Nitza I. Vera, a parent of children in the system and community advocate; and John Courtney of Child Welfare Watch, a publication devoted to child welfare issues.
The goals behind neighborhood- based services are noble: to avoid disrupting the child’s school life and to maintain the connection between biological parent and child. Also, anything that can keep kids out of care -like preventive services-is a good idea.
But I disagree with the way it’s going to be carried out, and although the forum was an open dialogue, I saw very little opposition to neighborhood-based foster care besides my own.
Since I was the only youth panelist in a televised discussion, this quietly unanimous sentiment became more than a little disturbing. I say this because I noted that myself and Ms. Vera, the community activist who had kids in foster care, were the only panelists who had personal experience with the current system and yet, for the most part, we were basically cast aside to make room for the “expert” analysis, as well as everyone else who had their own personal qualms about the policy.
It seemed as though James Dumpson (from the New York Community Trust) and Sister Mary Paul were the only speakers, besides myself, who realized that the social ills (violence, poverty, drugs) existing within the neighborhoods that produce the abusive situations leading to foster care must be dealt with first.
If children are placed in the same neighborhoods where they lived before removal, ACS is liable to send a child into the hands of the next door neighbor who, quite possibly, is suffering from the same problems and difficulties as the people they temporarily stripped of parental rights.
I was disappointed that not enough people raised this point. Although I understood the desperation to get something done, I also thought this was the main reason why these reforms often lead us in circles. In the haste to make change, not many folks stop to really examine the matter.
I would also have been delighted to take issue with one of the audience questioners, Edith Holzer of the Council of Family and Child Caring Agencies (although time was running out), who professed to be “setting the record straight” about foster parents when she claimed that they commit abuse less than 0.5% of the time. I really wonder what her working definition of “abuse” is.I have to admit I was pretty flattered with the audience acclaim that greeted the few good points I got in. Even though an overall youth point of view was not prevalent (and although I initially had slight problems with the microphone they had clipped on my shirt), I could still sense the effect I was having on the crowd because of the loud murmuring.
When the matter got too deep into finances and complicated policy, I brought it back to common sense by saying things like: “When you take me from my home, I’m assuming you’re going to put me in a better place.” And after the panel discussion ended, some people even came up to me and told me I was saying things they basically wanted to scream out in frustration.
As can be expected, however, this was primarily Scoppetta’s game (not that he was winning, mind you), for he was the one getting most of the audience questions at the end.
Nevertheless, being on the panel was a real educational experience, even though I couldn’t help but feel the futility of it all. Mr. Dumpson put it perfectly when he said metaphorically, “We can keep predicting the storm or we can start building the ark.”
(And I’d like to add that we’d probably have a nice sturdy ark in no time if foster youth were more involved in building it.)
So I guess the big question is: will neighborhood-based reform solve the problems of foster care? It will certainly be a huge step in a new direction for the system. Whether or not it leads to better conditions is another thing entirely. I certainly have my reservations, but only time will tell.
Common Sense From A Foster Youth: Face-to-Face With the `Experts’
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.