More and more, I find that college guide books sound like fairy tales. “As the first snow blankets upstate New York each winter…” reads The Insider’s Guide to the Colleges entry about Cornell University. I was waiting to hear about Santa Claus and his 12 reindeer.
College guides like this one and The Best 286 Colleges pride themselves on telling you what students really think about their schools. Unfortunately, sometimes they tell you different things.
For example, The Best 286 Colleges gives the reader the impression that all students at Cornell do is study. The book quotes one student saying the college has “little interaction with the town down the hill.” The Insider’s Guide, on the other hand, says that “Cornell and nearby Collegetown offer opportunities for socializing any night of the week.”
Other books like The College Handbook and Barron’s Profiles of American Colleges deal mostly with statistics. They’ll tell you about tuition, admission requirements, and room and board. But you will not see a single paragraph about what a college campus is like.
Take Seton Hall. We all know that they have a great basketball team but you won’t see anything in either of these books that suggests that they even have a basketball team.
Statistics v. Daily life
If you look at the section called “Student Life,” in the Barron’s book, you’ll find information about where students come from, but nothing about what they do in their free time. (The College Handbook does have a list of extracurricular activities.)
Almost any college guidebook will include information about tuition and the average SAT score of the students who attend the school. This information varies, however, depending on the source.
When I first looked at Boston University’s catalog I thought I needed combined SATs between 820 and 1020 to get in. The college books, however, said B.U. students’ average scores ranged from 1130 to 1160-over 100 points higher. I was confused. It turned out that in the catalog I was looking at the statistics for a special two-year program that the college books never mentioned.
Gillian Rosenfeld, director of the Options college counseling program on Manhattan’s Upper West Side, says too many students look at these books and make wrong judgments. “The students look at the data and they think that they can only get into certain places,” she said.
The information in the college guidebooks can be misleading and isn’t always up to date. The data for 1994 was probably collected in 1992; statistics can change. The average SAT score could go down, tuition could rise. Rosenfeld encourages students to “read guides that talk about colleges rather than [statistics]…Try to get the broadest information and don’t discount yourself.”
Visit!
According to Rosenfeld, there’s no one perfect book. She suggests looking at several as well as informing yourself in other ways. Colleges have something called a bulletin or course catalog that you should look at. This is not the same thing as the glossy viewbooks that schools send you with the application.
Course catalogs go in-depth and tell you about the campus, the specific majors and courses offered, and even the professors. They provide you with information about different schools within the college or university, study abroad programs, transportation, extracurricular activities and just about anything else that you might have questions about.
Bulletins are available through the college or university by request only or at some college counseling centers. They are a good complement to big guidebooks once you’ve narrowed down your choices. But no book can tell you what the best colleges for you are. Use them as guides, not to make a final decision. “It’s not the bible,” said Rosenfeld.
Don’t get me wrong, guidebooks are important. They give you information about hundreds of different colleges and allow you to do comparison shopping. But they should by no means be used alone.
The best way to get to know a college is to visit. There is no guide or catalog that could ever compare to seeing the place yourself. As Rosenfeld put it, “You can’t ask the book questions.”
College Handbooks: Don’t Be Mis-Guided
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.