City School Fights Freaked Me Out

City School Fights Freaked Me Out

(Some names have been changed.)
I’m originally from Haiti and lived there until I was 12. The schools I attended in Haiti were strict and peaceful, as opposed to what I’ve experienced in New York City schools.
Here, I’ve seen students fighting and cursing each other like it was no big deal. That freaked me out when I first arrived.
Between the ages of 2 and 5, I attended a private school. I learned early on to never hit and never curse at a teacher or other kids, and most importantly, do my homework and study my lessons.
Rules for Tomorrow
When I started my primary grades at the College Saint Louis de Bourdon, these rules became more important. Since we were older, the teachers there had higher expectations and were stricter than our instructors in kindergarten.
“The things that we learn today are the things that we are going to use tomorrow,” one teacher told my class.
Growing up, that philosophy became a big part of who I am. Without it, I don’t think I’d have the focus to finish high school and go on to college.
I Was a Good Girl
In Haiti, I liked being the careful and well-behaved Sabrina. She got positive feedback for following adult instructions and caring about her future.
My teachers gave me compliments for being quiet in class and always doing my homework. They called my mother in just to tell her how well I was doing.
But there were times my school’s rules felt overwhelming. Students who didn’t follow our school’s code got punished by their parents and teacher. That was a lot of pressure.
I Felt the Pressure
I sometimes felt like a slave because I didn’t feel free to mess up, particularly after seeing what happened to Stacie, a girl who cursed out one of our teachers.
The principal was upset because of the example Stacie set for the younger kids and wanted to expel her, but her mother begged for a second chance. The principal gave it to her.
So Stacie got suspended for two days. She told us her mother beat her for getting in trouble and talked all day about how, if she was kicked out of this school, she’d be barred from other schools.
Even though the incident with Stacie may not seem like a big deal, she was the only student I knew who got into major trouble. But that was enough for me.
My oldest cousin, Guerdy, who was a teenager, told me that students in higher grades had to be even more respectful. She knew a girl who got kicked out of school for doing the same thing Stacie did. Unlike Stacie, she wasn’t allowed to come back because she was older and considered mature enough to know wrong from right.
Unrest in Haiti
Even though I was generally comfortable back in Haiti, by the time I was 11, my mother wanted us to go to America, partly for my education and safety. There was a lot going on in Haiti, with workers protesting against low salaries. There were teacher boycotts that sometimes caused me to miss school.
People were also unhappy with Haiti’s government. There was violence in the streets because of the political unrest. Even though I felt safe at school, my country wasn’t stable.
My mother thought if I stayed in Haiti, I’d fall behind in my learning because of the boycotts. She wanted me to finish school when I was supposed to and have the career I wanted.
When I knew I was coming to the United States, I expected that I’d have to adjust to a different educational system. I just didn’t realize how rough it would be.
Free to Cut Class
My first year in America, I attended Middle School 61. There, some kids were all about breaking the rules because they had more freedom. They cut classes to hang out with their friends like it was nothing.
One time, some people asked me to cut school; there would be two other girls and three boys. They were thinking about having a make-out party.
I said, “No thanks.” I didn’t want to do that, because, if caught, I could’ve ended up suspended and in trouble with my mom. I wouldn’t have had this option in Haiti because once you’re in school, the doors are closed and you’re not allowed out until dismissal.
I realized I prefer strict rules to guide me. Otherwise, I might slack off.
Gang Warfare at School
But having more freedom to cut class wasn’t nearly as traumatic as watching kids fight. In 7th grade, two gangs went at it. A member of one gang looked at a member of a rival gang wrong.
Two guys told other gang members, and soon there was a gathering of thugs in the yard. These two guys got into each other’s face and started cursing each other out. I was watching from a doorway.
Fists started flying everywhere. So many boys were fighting, I couldn’t keep count. Most of them got suspended for fighting on school property.
After the fight, I was frightened because I thought, “What if someone started a fight with me?” I didn’t go to school the next day because I was scared.
The Cursing Twins
It wasn’t just boys who caused trouble. A set of twin sisters in my school cursed at teachers and students whenever they felt like it. Once, my friend Amy was walking down the hall and one sister bumped into her.
The other twin said, “Why did you push my sister and didn’t even tell her sorry?”
“Because she bumped into me,” Anne said.
“F-ck you!” a twin said.
“F-ck your mother, b-tch,” Amy replied. Then, one of the sisters jumped on her and punched her in the face. Amy pushed her off and punched her back. The fight ended because a security guard came and stood between them.
I was watching from the doorway of my native language class. Some of us tried to jump in because Amy was our friend, but my teacher stopped us.
They Weren’t Even Suspended
Amy and the twins had to go to the principal’s office. But they weren’t even suspended. They were all in school the next day. This would’ve been unheard of where I’m from.
I felt unsafe and worried that some day I might get beaten by some school hooligan. I was also scared that the discipline I learned in Haiti would leave my head and new ideas would creep in, like having sex and being vulgar.
Even though I liked some of the freedom I experienced here, like having teachers who weren’t so strict, I was worried that I’d start acting like someone who doesn’t care about her future.
So, one day, as I was eating in my kitchen, I asked my mother, “Mommy, can we go back to Haiti? I don’t like the fact that the kids here are always getting in trouble.”
“If you go, you will be going alone,” she said.
I didn’t want to stay here, but I didn’t want to go back to Haiti without my mom. So I said, “Fine. I’ll stay.” But I was angry at her for making me stay in the middle of all these school fights.
For about a year, I kept asking her if we could go back. She said that we would in a matter of time.
Better Opportunities Here
After a while, though, I got used to the idea of staying here and learning new things. As I finished junior high, I thought more about the opportunities that this country has to offer.
My mother explained that there are more jobs available here than in Haiti for people who graduate from college. She also explained that there are more scholarships, grants and loans available for students here to make education more affordable. Plus, my education here hasn’t been interrupted by boycotts or violence in the streets like it was back home.
I also realized that my fears were made larger because I hadn’t felt that connected to people.
I’m now a sophomore attending Brooklyn International HS and I’ve grown more accustomed to New York school culture. The school feels calmer than my junior high because there isn’t as much fighting and the students are friendlier with each other.
But I Almost Had a Fight
Still, I feel freer to get into fights after being here for four years.
One day, I argued with my mother before school, so I was in a bad mood. Then, a Haitian girl came up to me in chemistry class who thought I was talking about her.
She said, “If you ever talk about me, you won’t go home with your mouth.” I was so enraged that I attempted to jump on her, but some boy held me back.
After the incident, my chemistry teacher, Mr. Rousselin, gave me a long speech. “We’re supposed to be setting an example,” he said, since he’s also Haitian and believes we should stick together.
A part of me agreed with what he was saying, but part of me didn’t because I was angry. Still, I should’ve found a better way to handle my anger.
Here to Stay
Despite having to deal with school violence, I’ve made up my mind to make New York my home and take advantage of its opportunities. I plan to become a pediatrician.
I told my mother I’m giving New York a chance, even though I still think that the kids here have too much freedom. I will go back to Haiti, just not that soon. After all, I have school to think about.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.