City Girl, Mountain Music

I was ashamed of my love for folk music

It’s an average Friday night in 8th grade, and my friends and I are splayed out in one of our bedrooms, eating junk food, gossiping, giggling at the sex tips in Cosmo magazine, and flirting with boys on iChat.
Someone opens up YouTube on a computer and says to the group, “Guys, let’s have a dance party or something.” Someone else chimes in, “Oh my God, wait, play the new Katy Perry.” Everyone else echoes in a chorus, “Yeah, definitely!”
I think to myself, “Katy Perryâthat sounds familiarâ” I’ve seen her face in gossip magazines on newsstands, but I don’t think I’ve ever heard one of her songs. Still, I bluff and pretend that I have, chiming in and saying, “Oh my God, I looooove her.”
Everyone starts jumping around and singing to the annoying, auto-tuned pop beat: “You’re hot then you’re cold! You’re yes, than you’re no! You’re in, then you’re out! You’re up then you’re downâ,” acting out the lyrics as they sing. I pretend like I know the lyrics, copying the other girl’s dance moves, but I must be pretty bad at it, because, when the song ends, someone turns to me and says:
“Dude, you’ve never, like, heard that song before, have you?”
I start to blush and say, “Noâ no, I have, I probs just forgot some of the lyrics or something.”
She says, “Uh, that song has the easiest lyrics to remember, like, ever.”
I start feeling seriously embarrassed, and for lack of anything better to say, mumble “Whatever.”
She says, “God, Margs, sometimes I think you live under a rock or something.”
My Own Musical World
The truth is I hate that type of music. Sure, it might be fun to dance to with my friends and at parties, but I don’t get anything out of it. It doesn’t make me feel anything. For me, the music that is most popular today is empty, devoid of meaning, emotion, and beauty.
I have always loved music, though, because I know music can contain all of those elements. When I was younger, some of my happiest memories were with my dad in his car, listening to his music playlists. He played all types of music for me, from blues to country bluegrass to old school hip hop to classic rock-I loved it all. Today, I still love listening to R.L. Burnside, Ernest Scruggs, Biz Markie, and Frank Zappa, but my favorite genre of all has to be folk music.
The first folk music I ever heard was with my dad. He played the Carter Family’s version of “Will the Circle Be Unbroken?” one day, and I fell in love with the raw beauty of the song and the timelessness and vividness of the story it conveys. My grandpa, who died when I was young, also loved folk music. In his high school yearbook, in response to a question about what his hobbies were, he said “collecting folk songs.” The same could be said of me now.
However, back in 8th grade, I didn’t feel comfortable with my music tastes. It seemed weird that a Jewish 13-year-old who lived in New York City would like old music from the South that often has Christian themes. If I told my friends back then that I actually didn’t like Katy Perry and instead liked this type of music, they’d think it was really weird, so I kept my mouth shut about it.
Quietly, though, I started to develop my tastes in music on my own, separate from my friends. I would spend some time listening to Top 40 music for when I hung out with them, but I also explored music I liked however I could.
A Sense of Community
What really opened the door to folk music for me was checking out the American Anthology of Folk Music from my school library last year. That big red box was like a treasure chest for me. A man named Harry Smith went around to rural communities in the south from 1927 to 1932 and recorded the locals singing and playing instruments. I discovered some of my favorite artists like Dock Boggs and Clarence Ashley.
To me, the history behind the music gave it an authenticity that the pop music my friends loved lacked. The music on the anthology wasn’t performed by beautiful celebrities with perfect voices for large audiences; it was recorded by ordinary but talented people, playing along with their friends for their communities to enjoy.
The sense of community that folk music gives me is valuable, especially living in a big city in an apartment building where I don’t even know who my neighbors are. The images the music conjures up of community gatherings structured around music that reflect a common history is something that is lacking in my own life.
No Longer Embarrassed
As I’ve gotten older, I’ve come to recognize and accept that my taste in music is part of what makes me unique as a human being. Listening to the music that I love makes my life so much fuller than it would be if I stifled this part of myself to fit in with a group of friends.
This past year, I’ve gotten even more involved in the music. I’ve started to learn to play some folk instruments: the acoustic guitar and the Appalachian dulcimer, a three-stringed instrument played on one’s lap that originated in the mountains of Appalachia.
The Jalopy Theater in Brooklyn has inexpensive folk music performances from local musicians as well as music workshops for the dulcimer and other instruments. I love going there, because there is a sense that everyone there is in the same boat as me: with a genuine love for and interest in this type of music.
I’ve started my own music blog on tumblr where I share music I like with people who share my tastes. The tumblr community is special to me because it is all young people like me who are interested in folk music.
One of my favorite blogs is run by a teenage boy who finds old fiddle tunes and posts videos of himself playing a different one each day. I look forward to coming home from school and finding my tumblr inbox filled with recommendations, and people asking me to recommend different songs and artists for them.
I’ve found that my friends have matured since 8th grade as well, and many are developing their own specific musical tastes. I’ve drifted apart from some of my more rigid friends, but the friends I’ve stuck with have all started to define what they enjoy for themselves.
Some of my friends who seemed to worship Top 40 stars (like I pretended to) now love indie music, or classical, or opera. In high school, meeting new and older students with different, varying perceptions of what is interesting has allowed us to branch out from our middle school views of what “cool” is. We’ve all grown up a lot since then.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.