Caught Between Two Colors: Being Black, “Acting White”

When I was a little girl growing up in the Bronx, I would sit on the front steps of my apartment building and watch people walk by. White people, Spanish people, Indian people, and of course, Black people. A world full of color, each person unique and special in her own way.
And I began to wonder: why, with all this beauty in the world, must we hurt one another? Why must we call each other names like “Wh-tey” and “Sp-c” and “N-gger?” Why can’t we love our differences, rather than hate each other for them?
Which brings me to the subject of my story. If anyone knows anything about being hated for being different, it’s ME.
From the time I was three, I was always told by friends, teachers, and even family that I was “different” from “everyone else.” They didn’t tell me exactly how I was different or who “everyone else” was, but when I was seven years old I found out.
A Personal Bully
There was this girl at school named Maxine who would pick fights with me every day and do her best to get me yelled at. Whenever she got herself in trouble, she would find a way to blame me. I seemed to be the only person she ever picked on and she made my life miserable. She was, in a sense, my own personal bully.
One day after school, Maxine and her friends caught up with me while I was walking home. She tapped me on the shoulder and said, “Hey Shaniqua, what you get on the history test?”
“I got an 80. Why?” I asked.
She pinned me against a car and yelled, “Well, I only got a 65, b-tch! You should’ve let me see your test paper, but you had to be Ms. Goody Two Shoes, didn’t you?”
“Let go of me! At least you passed!” I said.
She pulled back her hand like she was ready to slap me, but instead she turned to her friends and said, “You ain’t even worth it.” Then she shoved me. “Bye, you wanna-be White b-tch!”
I don’t know why, but when she said that, something inside me clicked. As Maxine was walking away I said, “I’m not a wanna-be White B.” (I was never comfortable cursing.)
She turned back around and started to laugh. Then she said, “B-tch, who you think you foolin’? You walk White, talk White, and you dress White, too. With all that preachin’ you be doing at school about love and understandin’, I thought at least you’d act like your own people. But no, you gotta be Ms. Proper.”
Maxine snickered. I glared at her and said, “I never said I was proper and I don’t go around preaching anything.”
“Do you listen to yourself?” she asked me. Her friends said they had to go, which left me alone with Maxine.
“Listen to you. Don’t nobody in school talk like you ‘cept the White kids. Instead of sayin’ ‘Yeah,’ you say ‘Yes.’ Instead of sayin’ ‘F-ck you,’ you say ‘Forget you.’ I don’t know if you know it or not, but you is different with a capital D! If you ain’t realized that yet, you’s one blind b-tch!”
I am Black
I didn’t want to say that I’d been hearing I was different for a long time now (especially since the way Maxine said it made me think it was really true).
So instead I said, “Oh, so you’re saying that I’ve got to dress in tight clothes, get bad grades, and talk with broken English in order to be normal.”
“B-tch, I ain’t sayin’ sh-t ‘cept this. Before you start talkin’ about Black this and Black that, find the Black in you first. Bye b-tch, see ya tomorrow.” Then she walked away.
So that’s what everyone meant when they said I was “different.” They thought I acted White and not Black. Was that a bad thing?, I wondered.
I thought about what Maxine said as I walked the rest of the way home, and I tried to convince myself that I was Black. I kept on repeating to myself, “I am Black, I am Black.”
Wasn’t I?
Looking for an Answer
When I finally got home my brothers were watching TV, but when they saw me they jumped up and said, “Nica, we hungry.”
I went over and gave them a kiss and said, “Daddy never came over to make dinner for you?”
“He in kitchen,” Lewis said. “But he cook too slow.”
“What about mommy?” I said.
“She no come home,” Lewis said. He had this sad, faraway look in his eyes.
I hugged him and told him everything was going to be alright, although I wasn’t so sure myself. I knew why she wasn’t home, and, even though they were young, so did my brothers.
She was out getting high and it was no secret to us. I wish she knew what kind of pain she was putting us through. Maybe if she did know, she wouldn’t have been out there sniffing and shooting-up her life away.
I went in the kitchen and saw my father searching in the fridge. When he finally looked up and saw me, he said, “Hey girl, what’s up.”
“Nothing much,” I said. “Could I talk to you for a sec?”
“Sure honey. Just a sec.” He looked in the fridge and sucked his teeth. “Looks like you’ll be going to grandma’s house tonight to eat.” Then he closed it. “O.K., what’s up?”
“Well, there’s this girl named Maxine in my school and she told me that I act White. People say that I act different, and I think that’s what they mean. Do you think there’s something wrong with me?”
“Sweetie, come here.”
I sat down in the chair in front of him.
“Now, there’s nothing wrong with you. You’re a smart young lady for your age. There is nothing wrong with the way you act. Just because you don’t talk or walk like everyone else, that’s no reason to feel uptight about yourself. There is no one way to be, anyway. So if someone teases you about something, don’t listen to them. Just believe in yourself.”
“Thanks daddy,” I said, and hugged him.
Believing in Myself
After my little talk with dad, I was no longer afraid to express myself, whether I “sounded White” (whatever that means) or not. I got over my fear of being “different” by believing in myself.
From that point on I avoided Maxine. Whenever she tried to start trouble with me, I would tell her to leave me alone.
If someone like Maxine ever happens to come along and harass you because they find you different, then just tell her: “You can harass me if want to and call me names, but no matter what you do, I’m gonna be who I am.”
My message is clear: whether you are White and “act Black” or are Black and “act White,” we all bleed, cry, laugh, and die the same way. It doesn’t matter what people say about you or what’s on the outside. It’s what’s on the inside and what you think about yourself that counts.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.