Catfish: Tricking People to Feel Alive

catfish [kat-fish] verb
To pretend to be someone you’re not online by posting false information, such as someone else’s pictures, on social media sites. usually with the intention of getting someone to fall in love with you.
-MTV’s website for its hit reality show Catfish.

The show is based on a documentary, which came out in September of 2010. The movie Catfish is about a guy, Nev Schulman, who believed he was writing-and falling in love with-a young woman named Meghan who he “met” on Facebook but never in real life. Nev’s brother Ariel and his friend Max Joseph convinced him to investigate “Meghan” because she seemed like a fake. They recorded their text messages and phone calls.
When Nev went to meet “Meghan” (with cameras), he found she was a much older married woman named Angela Wesselman. She’d been using a random picture. Nev met her family and even her husband, who knew about this online affair but didn’t know it was serious. At first, Angela said that Meghan was her daughter but wasn’t around. Eventually she came clean: Meghan was just a made-up person. It was all a lie.
Watching the movie, we never really understand WHY Angela did this, but her husband at least explains where the movie’s title comes from. Vince Wesselman tells the story of how seafood suppliers had trouble shipping live cod from Asia to North America-the meat would end up mushy by the time it got received. But the suppliers found that if they placed the cod’s natural enemy, catfish, in the tank, the cod stayed active. The exercise from struggling with their enemy made their skin tougher and the meat tastier. So he related people who produced fake profiles to the catfish-and the victims to the cod. “Catfish keep you on your toes, keep you guessing, keep you thinking, keep you alive.” As if you’re doing people a favor by fooling them.
Some viewers thought the movie was a sham, not really a documentary. I personally believe the documentary was real. If it was fictional, Nev should receive an Oscar for his performance.
After the movie, MTV created a TV show also called Catfish, hosted by Nev and Max. It became one of cable’s highest rated new shows in 2012. People who are suspicious about their online correspondents contact these guys, and then Nev picks an e-mail to build a show around. He films the “catfishee” explaining how he or she started online dating the person they suspect. Then they try to find out who this person really is.
I watch every episode covering this epidemic because it’s fun and very dramatic. People blindly fall for the bait despite the catfish’s refusal to meet or video-chat, which I find utterly na•ve. The confrontation of the catfish and catfishee at the end is enlightening. Since most of the people are not who they say they are, the catfishees are pissed at first; then they emotionally break down. The show also has a good lesson: don’t fall in love with a stranger online-all they are is words on your screen.
Why?
Why do so many people catfish? Why create a fake Facebook page to trick others? Watching the show helps me understand some things about myself and other teenagers.
On one episode of the show, Tyler engaged in a two-year online relationship with “Amanda.” Nev found out that “Amanda” was really Aaron, who said he considered being Amanda “better than being myself.” He tells the camera he is gay but doesn’t want to be. He actually had feelings for Tyler: Aaron catfished because he wanted to be someone else.
In another episode, a girl catfished her ex-friend who she said had taken her boyfriend from her, so that was out of revenge. Another girl catfished her best friend as a guy, thinking it would help her get over the death of her father. Those two even got engaged online!
Watching the show, you learn ways catfishees could have protected themselves from this humiliation and heartbreak. Warning signals include:
1. If they are alone in all their pictures.
2. They keep making excuses not to video-chat with you.
3. They tell you that they work as a model! (What model wouldn’t date in real life?)
In most of the episodes I’ve watched, the catfisher always says he/she is a model and has beautiful pictures. It seems so obvious, so why do so many people fall for it? Or are they letting themselves fall for it? Do people actually want to be catfished?
A Test
To test the idea that people want to be fooled, I catfished my friend Cindy. I created a fake Facebook page as a 17-year-old boy Ayden and got the pics from one of my friends on tumblr. (I had permission!) I added a couple of friends and strangers and of course Cindy. I waited a day and I started writing her. We talked about things that interested us and what kind of people we like. I told her she was cute.
Later that day (I didn’t want her to be too invested in him), I told Cindy that it was a project. She was mad, but when I told her I was going to deactivate the account she asked me not to because she wanted to keep talking to “Ayden.” I asked her why, and she said, “It left me with someone to talk to at the end of the day. It wasn’t like I was telling him anything intimate, and he seemed nice.” She obviously had me to talk to so I asked what she meant. “I know you already, but I don’t know Ayden.” I guess she just wanted to meet someone new.
She wanted to be catfished. That experience, plus all the people on the show, makes me think that a lot of other people are lonely. They just want someone to be there for them, even if it’s a random stranger online.
The Fear of Being Yourself
Technology has given us a chance to conceal ourselves behind our computer screens and become a whole new person with a completely different identity. People catfish for revenge, fun, curiosity, or boredom, and people fall for the fakes. But all of us who are online catfish to some extent.
Wait, just listen! We create pages on social networking sites like Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, and we put up stuff there that’s different from how we really are. On Instagram, we make ourselves prettier, blurring out blemishes or whitening our teeth. We might be upset one day but put up a picture of us smiling on Facebook. My Facebook and Tumblr blog give the perception of a crazy and wild teen, but in person I’m shy and quiet. We edit out the parts of ourselves and our lives we don’t like.
Being Ayden made me realize that I could go further than being a prettier, happier, bolder version of myself. Being’Ayden’ felt amazing. I was someone new; I could change everything about myself.
Catfishing made me more creative. For Ayden, I had to think of a good name, a good picture, a good background story. I had to imagine everything and I also had to look up to see if anyone else had his first and last name, so I also improved my research skills. It was fun creating this new human being.
Making Ayden was fun, but fooling Cindy made me feel bad. What if someone had done that to me? How would I have felt? That’s also the question catfishers need to keep in mind. Knowing that anybody could do this online makes me nervous about whom I talk to so, I don’t put all my information out there. I don’t connect my phone number to any of my networks, and I don’t put the school I go to on them either. The most an online stranger would get from me is the city that I
live in.
Anyone can catfish. Knowing that makes me wary, but it also gets me thinking about loneliness and the desire to connect and the fear of being yourself. What if these people who catfish are also scared? Scared to show their true selves to the people they are talking to. And how many people, like Cindy, know they’re being fooled but still like talking to the fake person?
Vince Wesselman is right: Catfishing keeps us thinking, keeps us guessing, keeps us alive.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.