I recall many conversations I’ve had with different girls, either girls I’ve met on the street or at school, where I’ve asked them this question: What do you like in a guy? What do you expect or look for? Their answers are not identical but usually similar; they say stuff like, “I want my man to be cute, look good, have nice swag (style), and be funny and faithful.”
That last word is always somewhere in their answers: faithful. I sometimes ask if their boyfriend fits that description, and they always say yes. In some cases, I’ve known for a fact that their boyfriend wasn’t faithful. But even if I don’t know anything about their boyfriend, I still assume these girls are nave.
That’s because, based on my personal experience and my observations of other males in my circle, I think it’s almost impossible for teen boys to be faithful. When a teenage girl says, “My man is different,” I always say, “I hope so,” because it is too hard to convince them otherwise. They need to find out for themselves. Or maybe they don’t want to know.
Too Trusting
I think most teen girls would in fact be shocked at how little respect teenage boys show when on their own. One example is the way guys always ask girls to send them nude photos. For some reason the girls do it, saying, “don’t show it to anyone, OK? Not even your friends.”
The guys convince the girls that they won’t, but really they’re just telling the girl what she wants to hear. The guy will show or send his friends the pictures as soon as he gets the chance, and in return he gets recognition. This only makes the guy more cocky and less respectful.
Generally, guys telling girls what they want to hear-and girls believing it-is a common pattern in teen relationships. Guys aren’t honest because they can get away with not being honest: Girls are too trusting. They fool even themselves by telling themselves that what they have with their guy is true love.
I am not refuting the fact that a guy may fall in love or have strong feelings for his girlfriend, but that does not preclude the cheating and the lies. Guys may call one girl their “girlfriend” even though they have others on the side. Maybe that one girl is more presentable, or likes him more than the others do. Or he may truly have strong feelings for this girl.
But most guys I know still find it more than difficult to be exclusively with one girl, at least if they are tempted. In other words, a guy may be “faithful” because he hasn’t had the opportunity to cheat. But if he gets a clear, easy shot at another girl, he will be more than likely to take it.
As we grow from teenagers into young men, I hope we’ll eventually behave more maturely. I think it’s likely, if not guaranteed. For now, though, I think teenagers-both guys and girls-will be happiest if they aren’t romantics.
Say’No’ to Romance
Teens should look at love or relationships, or whatever they may call it, as a game where the rules entail not believing in love or romance. If they play by these rules, they suffer fewer heartbreaks.
Some girls seem to see it this way, too. Last summer I was at the beach and I saw this girl I thought was attractive, so I went and asked her if she had a man in her life. Her answer was, “No, are you crazy?! It’s summer!” I took that to mean that she was looking for fun, nothing serious. I was surprised-and impressed. I thought she was right to play the game this way.
So maybe it’s becoming less of a guy thing to play the field. But those who live in their romance bubbles, reading romantic stories, will eventually get a wake-up call and that romance bubble will explode.
Burst That Romance Bubble
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.