Budget Cuts, Tuition Hikes, Student Protests: CUNY Crunch

Last spring, CUNY (City University of New York) students were told that their tuition was going to be increased because of city and state budget cuts. In a dramatic attempt to protect affordable higher education, students took over buildings and shut down campuses. In spite of their protests, tuition was hiked and financial aid and other services were cut back. Now, one year later, students say that staying in school is a real struggle.
“Tuition increases are devastating to CUNY students,” said David Ryan, 23, a junior at Brooklyn College. In fact, most CUNY students come from low-income families and have to work their way through school. In addition, a large number are single parents with families of their own to support.
Kim Ray, a single mother who is president of the day student government at Hunter College, said, “CUNY is the last stop for a lot of people who want a higher education.” Both Ryan and Ray said that the tuition increases are forcing lots of students to drop out. And students who can’t afford CUNY probably won’t be able to go to college at all.
Hanging In
Those CUNY students who manage to stay in school are having a hard time making ends meet. A lot of them have had to increase the hours they spend earning money and decrease the amount of time they devote to their studies. Some have been forced to take a semester off or change their student status from full- to part-time.
L. Anthony Nieves, a first semester senior at City College, is one of those who switched to part-time studies. He’s started working full-time as a security guard to make ends meet. He’s managing to stay in school, but he feels that his financial condition is being “drained.”
The tuition increases and budget cuts have affected every CUNY student. But some people feel that minority students, who make up 63% of CUNY’s enrollment, have been hit the hardest.
Kim Ray feels that the tuition increases and the budget cuts have racist overtones. “For 129 years there was no tuition [at CUNY],” Ray said. “There were wars, depressions-no tuition. During the 70’s when people of color started coming into CUNY-boom!-tuition.”
The worst part is that students think they are paying more but getting less. In addition to raising tuition, CUNY has also made cutbacks that are affecting the quality of education.
Getting Less For More
Last semester, in an attempt to save money, CUNY offered an early retirement plan to its most experienced and highest paid professors. About 1,000 faculty members took it. CUNY’s administration originally planned to replace everyone who retired with a less experienced teacher who would get a lower salary. But in the end, the system couldn’t afford to replace most of the people who retired.
Because there are fewer teachers on staff, fewer courses are being offered this year. Students say that it is becoming harder and harder to get into the classes that they want, and need, to take.
“People are taking courses they never dreamed of taking just to keep their full-time status,” said Solomon Eljashev, 23, a senior at Brooklyn College.
The classes that are available tend to be overcrowded. Some class sizes have doubled and desk space is a problem. Students say these conditions make it harder to learn.
“When you go into a class where one professor has to handle so many students, students get less education,” said Antonio Cavallaro, 20, a junior at Brooklyn College. “There are restrictions on the amount of questions that can be asked…restrictions on the amount of assignments, restrictions on the amount of time the professor has [to spend with students] outside the classroom.”
Another problem with large classes is that they make it harder for a teacher to gauge how well students understand the subject matter. In a small class, a teacher usually assigns more papers and gives more essay exams. In a large class, a teacher simply doesn’t have the time to read and mark that many papers or essay tests. Instead, they may assign only one paper a semester and give multiple choice tests.
While this may sound good on the surface, students said that it really isn’t. Not only are they not learning as much, but there are fewer chances to make up for a bad grade.
Rita Rodin, a spokesperson for CUNY, explained that last year the administration tried to keep the budget cuts out of the classroom by cutting back in other areas, like maintenance of buildings. But now, she said, “there are no frills left to cut out.” In fact, 1,000 teachers may be dismissed next year if the financial situation does not improve.
What can be done to save the CUNY system? With every state and city agency screaming for more money, what should our leaders, both state and city, do? And what can we, as concerned citizens and students, do?
It’s Our Right
Most students agreed with L. Anthony Nieves, who said that “education is a right, not a privilege.” They feel that politicians have to make education a priority and take money from other areas and funnel it into CUNY.
Antonio Cavallaro suggested that the state build one less jail and funnel the money it saves into CUNY. He said that the priorities of the governor and state legislature are not in order if they believe that “the training of an educated and capable work force” takes second place to building prisons which are “filled with people who had no other choice but to turn to crime.”
Kim Ray said that CUNY’s chancellor and board of trustees need to change their priorities too. Ray said there would be more money for important things like teachers if some administrative positions were eliminated or reduced.
“At Hunter we have a dean of this and a dean of that,” she said. “Divisional deans, vice presidents of this and that…Why are they all here?”
Despite all the problems, CUNY students still recommend their schools to high school students who want to go to college. “It’s still a bargain,” said David Ryan. “I would still encourage people to come here.”
“But come in fighting,” warned Ian Aisenberg, president of the student government at Brooklyn College. Kim Ray agreed that students have to be willing to stand up for their rights. “[The government] thinks that students are sleeping and that students are stupid,” Ray said. “You are a consumer paying for a service. You’ve got to know what’s going on.”
What We Can Do
To protest CUNY budget cuts and urge that more money be put into the CUNY system, write to the following officials:
Gov. Mario Cuomo
Executive Chamber
State Capitol
Albany, NY 12224
Hon. Saul Weprin
Speaker of the Assembly
Legislative Office Building
Albany, NY 12248
Hon. Ralph Marino
Senate Majority Leader
Legislative Office Building
Albany, NY 12247
Hon. Edward Sullivan
Chair, Assembly Higher
Education Committee
Legislative Office Building.
Albany, NY 12248.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.