Boy meets girl. They become friends. Boy and girl grow up to be man and woman. Then they fall in love. It’s a familiar plot for many run-of-the-mill romantic comedies. But even though Brown Sugar shares this exhausted storyline, it’s still entertaining.
The movie tells its love story from an interesting perspective: the birth of hip-hop as a subculture in New York City. Dre (Taye Diggs) and Sidney (Sanaa Lathan) are two kids who witness how hip-hop changes their Bronx neighborhood in the 1980s.
They’re moved as they join a crowd of heads bobbing to the beat boxing and freestyling of hip-hop pioneer Slick Rick. The two grow up loving hip-hop culture as it gradually makes its way into the mainstream.
Hip-Hop Editor And Executive
They maintain their close friendship as adults with careers in the music industry. Dre’s a discouraged record executive while Sidney’s an influential hip-hop music journalist. Dre begins to lose some of his fiery passion and admiration for the music as he sees hip-hop being consumed by commercialism and materialistic values.
He even begins to question his own lifestyle, including his new bride Reese (Nicole Ari Parker), who seems more concerned with maintaining a posh, upper-class image than supporting his pursuits.
Meanwhile, Sidney obtains the editor-in-chief position at a prominent hip-hop magazine and falls for Kelby (Boris Kodjoe), a professional basketball player.
Despite their new relationships, Sidney and Dre’s attraction for each other lingers, and they eventually realize why they fell in love with hip-hop in the first place.
Metaphor Drags On
The premise of the film is appealing. Hip-hop is celebrated in flashbacks as an innovative new culture while being criticized and parodied for its more recent predictability.
Sidney’s constant question of “When did you first fall in love with hip-hop?” is answered in lots of cameos within the first five minutes of the film.
Yet the constant use of hip-hop as a symbol for the love between Dre and Sidney made me lose interest in the love story. The film drags out the metaphor, including a closing sequence that’s over the top.
The film also doesn’t address various issues concerning hip-hop today, including the female-bashing and violence that’s pushed the fun-filled lyrics of early rap to the background. Brown Sugar’s lighthearted and funny, and dealing with the politics of hip-hop didn’t seem to be on the filmmakers’ agenda.
Latifah and Mos Def’s Comedy Relief
Although originality may not be one of its strong points, Brown Sugar’s still an enjoyable film that will draw nostalgia and laughter from old-school hip-hop heads. There’s your usual urban romantic comedy crew, including a Black and White rap duo named Rin and Tin.
Queen Latifah’s also on board as wisecracking cousin Francine who attempts to convince Sidney to go for her true love. And Mos Def, as charming cab-driving lyricist Chris V, revitalizes Dre’s faith in hip-hop.
Though the characters aren’t necessarily deep, the film still maintains a charm and pace that makes it easy to like. Yes, Brown Sugar is a recycled, cliched love story that can be used with interchangeable themes (i.e., basketball in Love and Basketball), but it’s also trying to use hip-hop to sell its film to urban audiences who might not necessarily go see a “date movie.” So for some laughs and a fun time, maybe you should try a taste of Brown Sugar.
Brown Sugar: Fresh Ingredient Helps Save Tired Recipe
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.