Brokeback Breaks Hearts-and Stereotypes

When I first heard about “Brokeback Mountain” in my English class last December, my teacher wasn’t referring to the movie that’s now up for eight Academy Awards. She was talking about the short story about two cowboys in love by Annie Proulx. The story inspired the movie.
My teacher told us to read the story and highlight what parts we thought best captured the love between Jack and Ennis, the two main (male) characters. Some people chose lines the characters said, while others focused on explicit sexual descriptions.
When we discussed the relationship between the two men in class, a few kids giggled at the love scenes. One quote that sparked laughter was when Jack says to Ennis, “Why can’t I quit you?”
I wasn’t surprised by their behavior. The students who laughed were still stuck in 4th grade, a time when many kids think being gay is funny and wrong.
I thought “Brokeback Mountain” was a powerful and provocative story. It breaks common stereotypes about gay men-the main characters are masculine cowboys-and it’s moving.
When the book was turned into a movie recently, there was a lot of controversy about showing a loving relationship between two men. I felt the movie was something I had to see so I could form my own opinions.
Uneasy in Love
In the movie, like the book, Jack and Ennis meet one summer in the 1960s while herding sheep together on Brokeback Mountain, and they fall in love. At first they’re hesitant and uneasy about expressing their feelings for each other, but slowly they allow their emotions to take over.
After the summer, Ennis (played by Heath Ledger) marries his fiance, and Jack (played by Jake Gyllenhaal) eventually meets a woman whom he gets pregnant and marries. The men try to deny their emotions for each other for a while, but they can’t stay apart.
For the next 20 years, the men continue to meet secretly every few months to quench their desire for one another. They leave their families periodically to continue their love, telling their wives they’re going fishing together.
Both still try to be husbands and fathers to their families because they want to be straight, but they suffer trying to accomplish that task. And they always return to the place where they first met: Brokeback Mountain.
Resisting Their Desire
One scene that vividly stuck out to me was at the end of their first summer together. It depicts their emotions bubbling up inside them-a mix of loving each other and hating the homosexuality that they’vestumbled upon. To express this, they start fist fighting each other. This shows their manliness trying to prevail and prevent them from being gay. But their love for one another eventually emerges.
I already thought there was nothing wrong with being gay before I saw the movie. I believe that within 10 years, gay rights will have been recognized and people will realize how ignorant it was to discriminate based on sexual orientation, just like segregation is viewed now. (Of course, there will still be homophobes who linger on in future generations, just like there are still racists today.)
Still, I was unsure how far Ang Lee, the movie’s director, would decide to go to show the love between the two men. When I first saw where some scenes were headed, I felt a bit peculiar because gay sex is something that isn’t often shown in books or movies.
But after I saw those scenes, I felt fine. I’ve always believed that love between two people of the same sex is entirely natural. I thought of the love scenes between Jack and Ennis the same way I think of love scenes between a man and a woman: just part of the movie.
Fighting Stereotypes
I know many teens, including a couple of classmates at school, are apprehensive about reading a story or seeing a film like Brokeback Mountain. They think it’s gross because ever since elementary school, the words “gay” and “f-got” have been thrown around as insults. They associate being gay with being lewd and immoral, even though it’s as predetermined as being male or female.
I thought portraying gay people as cowboys was a great way to show there’s no shame in homosexuality, since cowboys are considered the pinnacle of manliness. It’ll help people to dismiss the stereotypes about gay men just being feminine. Jack and Ennis drink and smoke like many straight men do.
This movie was great for many reasons, from the cinematography to the acting to the costume design. I recommend it to anyone, especially someone who’s uncomfortable with homosexuality. Reading “Brokeback Mountain” (the short story) or seeing Brokeback Mountain (the movie) could make you think twice about your feelings. It’s a love story. So what if it’s between two men?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.