Book Review: Teen Angst in a Hijab

I know I’m not the only one with insecurities. Sometimes I think my hips are too curvy, my nose is too big and my facial expressions look awkward. But imagine actually making the choice to do something that adds to your insecurities, like following a religious practice that makes you stand out. That takes guts.
That’s the kind of choice that the main character, Amal, makes in Does My Head Look Big In This?, a novel by Randa Abdel-Fattah. A Muslim girl in a mostly white private school in Australia, Amal decides halfway through her junior year to start wearing a hijab, or headscarf, full-time.
A hijab is a piece of material worn by many Muslim women to cover their hair, and sometimes face. Before, Amal only wore it when she was in a Muslim school, and even then she would take it off as soon as she left school grounds. Now she decides to wear it in school, in the mall, everywhere.
Insecure in Her Hijab
She wants to show her dedication to Allah (God) and also prove to her parents, who are concerned that she won’t be able to handle it, that she is capable of dealing with people’s reactions to the hijab. But at first she’s hesitant. What will people say? How will they react? Will they think she’s a terrorist? She even makes a list of people who will support her wearing it vs. those who won’t, just to see what she’s up against.
From the very beginning, Amal made me laugh and feel like I was with her in the day-to-day routine of her life. I felt her happiness and giddiness when she received a phone call from the boy she liked and I felt her pain and depression when her friend Leila ran away from home.
Amal is the most outgoing and self-assured person in her circle of friends. You know the one-the friend who, if you have a colossal pimple hiding under your bangs, will tell you in front of your very cute study partner, “Hey, did you know you have this really gross pimple underneath your bangs? You should really see it, it’s huge.” Amal is outspoken like that. But she’s still insecure about wearing the hijab. She tries to make her face look prettier by picking delicate fabrics to use as her hijab.
I Could Relate
Throughout the book Amal tries to help her friend Simone with her weight insecurities and supports her friend Leila, whose mom is only interested in marrying her off to some rich Muslim man. She learns from her friends that everyone has insecurities of their own, some even worse than hers. This helps her learn how to be content with herself and her own hang-ups, despite some people teasing her about wearing the hijab.
Before I started the book, I expected to read about a girl who thought her morals and religious beliefs were superior to others. I was pleasantly surprised to find I was wrong. I related to Amal in every sense of the word. She was a normal teenager with similar habits to mine, like going to the mall with her friends and trying to get sympathy from a parent when she has cramps so that she’ll be allowed to watch TV.
Most of all, I related to Amal’s insecurities. When I was younger, I felt insecure about having short hair. I first had to cut my hair short when I was 10 because it would get extremely tangled and knotted. I hated it short and sometimes I cried when I had to get a haircut.
But as I got older, I tried to work it. It sounds corny, but getting ready in the morning, I would just tell myself that I was hot with short hair. I also tried letting more of my personality show through, and eventually, I stopped feeling insecure about it.
I felt like Amal wasn’t only talking about her own personal struggle, but mine as well. When she would walk down the street and wonder what people thought or if they were staring at her because she looked horrible, I felt like she was describing my experience.
Curious About Islam
The only thing about Amal that I couldn’t relate to was how someone so similar to me could be so devoted to God. How could she be so strong as to stick with it?
Her struggle with whether or not to wear the hijab also made me think about other Muslim girls who live in a place where Muslims are a minority. I wondered if many of them have reservations about wearing it. And if they don’t, where do they get the confidence to wear it on their own?
The only way I would improve the book would be to include even more details about Amal’s religion and traditions. I was really interested in learning more about it. I would recommend the book to anyone who can read. Yeah, it’s that good!

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.