Black? White? Both?

My friend QueenTeera Tate is light skinned, with long, silky, black hair. She is part Chinese, Jamaican and South American.
If you were to ask her what race she is, she would say, “I’m Jamaican and Chinese.”
But mostly, QueenTeera, who lives in East New York, Brooklyn, thinks of herself as Black.
“My mother is Black and she raised me, and I live around a whole bunch of Black people. I don’t even have friends from any other race,” she said.
So when QueenTeera has to fill out forms that ask for her ethnicity, she doesn’t get into the details-“I check ‘Black’,” she said.
But this year, the Census will allow people who are of mixed backgrounds like QueenTeera to get into detail-by checking any race boxes that apply to them. That may not seem like a big deal, but it has been making some people very angry and others just feel confused.
Showing Their Colors
The Census Bureau made the change because there has been a growing number of mixed race people in the United States, and in 1990, when the last census count was held, they spoke out against having to choose between, say, “White” or “Black,” when they are both.
“Many of them wanted to identify with their races and not just pick one or the other,” said Tawana Jacobs of the Census Bureau in Washington. So the census decided to allow people to check more than one box.
That means there are now 240 possible racial and ethnic combinations. But the government still wants to keep track of the basics-like how many Whites, Asians, Blacks, Hispanics and Native Americans there are. So no matter what they pick, the census is going to put most of the people who pick several race choices into five main categories.
That may seem like it’s no change at all, but Tawana said, “It’s good because it lets people in Congress and in the Senate know that there is a growing number of mixed races in the United States.”
Angry With the Change
But many minority advocacy groups, like the Asian American Legal Defense Fund (AALDF) and the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), have objected to the change. They say non-Whites will end up being undercounted, and will therefore lose the federal funding and protection they need.
And many multiracial people aren’t too happy, either, because the government is going to basically pick a box for them, anyway. They wanted a box that just said “mixed race.”
Still, despite the hype, the changes may not mean much. In 1998, a dress rehearsal for the Census 2000 was conducted across the country, and of the people surveyed, only 2% checked more than one race.
Pick One or the Other
QueenTeera, like many other mixed race people, said she’s not sure which boxes she will check.
“Sometimes I wish that I could check more than one box on forms because I am not only Black, I am mixed. People should know that just like they know that some people are only Black and that other people are only Asian,” she said. But to avoid confusion, she might just check one.
“Really, what’s the difference?” she asked.
The AALDF and NAACP say it’s important to pick only one racial category on the census. Otherwise, these groups are afraid it will end up looking like there are fewer minorities living in this country than there are-and that could hurt minority communities, said Glenn, an advocate for the AALDF.
“The census is a government survey. It is not about affirming very complex notions of racial and ethnic identity. It is about the distribution of political power, resources and the enforcement of civil rights law,” Glenn said.
In other words, there isn’t anything wrong with wanting to identify with your racial and ethnic background, but checking off many races might make it harder for Blacks, Asians and Hispanics to get federal money and political power.
The more people who check several boxes, the fewer people might end up being counted as “Black” or “Asian.” That would make it hard for leaders of those communities to advocate for what they need.
“The issue for us is to try to get the numbers,” said Glenn. “The numbers are going to be broken down to [a few different ethnic groups]. In that process, we are concerned that the number of [minorities] will be diminished.”
Why Not a ‘Mixed Race’ Box?
You might think people of mixed race would be happy with the changes, but now, there are debates and even talk of protests over whether people should check more than one box.
On a web site called “Interracial Voice,” some people have been calling for a “civil disobedience” type protest. They encouraged mixed race people to either check only “Black,” or check every box on the form, or check “American Indian,” or not return a census form at all.
None of those choices are a very good idea. It’s important that the government-and everyone outside the government who uses census figures-knows how many people of each race live in this country, where they live, and what their lives are like.
The Census Bureau rejected a “mixed race” category because then every mixed race person, whether they were White and Asian or Native American and Black, would show up as the same thing. That would defeat the purpose of asking about race in the first place.
The government needs census data in order to provide services for people with many different problems and needs. If the census ends up with a bunch of “mutiracial” people, that still does not help the government figure out what services are needed and for whom.
Recently, the Justice Department used racial data from the census to investigate the cases of racial profiling by the police. Investigators assumed that if police are being fair, they’ll randomly stop the same percentage of Whites and minorities who live in the community.
Let’s say a neighborhood is 50% White and 50% Black, but they find that cops are randomly stopping Blacks 80% of the time and Whites only 20%. That shows there’s a problem.
And city and state planners study the information to give money for things like after school programs for teenagers or services for the elderly to needy communities.
Those little boxes on the census serve an important purpose. “Once tabulated, the census will have an effect on public policy decisions,” said Tawana. So regardless of which boxes on the race question you choose to check off, it’s important to fill the census out and get counted.

SIDEBAR: Race Matters
You might be wondering: Why does the government need to know my race? The census asks for basic information about who is living in America so that the government, and private companies who use the census statistics, can provide the services we need. The government provides money for everything from building housing and schools to developing poor neighborhoods and giving out food stamps. Our politicians need to know whether poverty is increasing or decreasing, and whether cities and suburbs are growing or shrinking. Race is important because if a certain group is struggling, they should be getting extra help from the government. Census figures are often used to show why we need affirmative action-because 13% of this country is Black, but only about 8% of students at elite colleges are Black. The census statistics help the government figure out whether specific areas or groups of people are in need of special services, like bilingual manuals and classes in schools, or job training for people who can’t find work.
New Immigrants, New Needs
For instance, I read an article in The New York Times about the area of Harlem that is now being settled by West Africans. The number of West Africans in this neighborhood doubled between 1990 and 1996, from 44,000 to 84,000, according to the census. (And I wouldn’t be surprised if there are way more than that, because new immigrants often don’t return the census.) Most West African immigrants speak French, and they might need the government to provide things like tax forms or applications for foodstamps in French. The schools in that area may also need more French-speaking bilingual teachers. But few services in Harlem are available in French now. And if the government doesn’t know that a growing number of French-speaking West Africans are moving to Harlem, then it is not going to change. That’s why people need to fill out the census-even if they are illegal immigrants. (The census information is confidential and cannot be used against you.) Then local politicians can advocate for what the people in the area need.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.