Becoming American (Part II)

Becoming American (Part II)

[This is Part Two of an article begun last month in NYC.
Every immigrant I spoke with said that she had great expectations of what America was supposed to be like.
Isabel Hernandez, a Seward Park HS student from the Dominican Republic, explained to me that when Dominicans get to New York, it is totally different from what they imagined.
Julio Abreu, 19, a Dominican from Eastern District HS, heard that if you went outside you would get mugged or shot.
And Min Huynh, 15, from Vietnam, was expecting to see “tall women with long blond hair.”
Dionne Mitchell, 18, from the Caribbean, felt that “New York was going to be exciting and fast-paced.”
But they all knew that the city was going to be quite different from the lands they had to leave behind.
Yonilda Rojas, 15, a Dominican from Seward Park HS, said that in New York, “you’re closed in, you don’t have the freedom of the outside.”
Kirpaul Ramdass, 14, from Guyana, said that the one thing he missed about Guyana was “there was a lot of space. If it was hot, you could go to the beach.”
In addition to not having the freedom of the outdoors, many immigrants feel that the family unit is no longer as close as it would be in their old countries.
Martine Lominy, 18, of Washington Irving HS, claims that in Haiti, “everybody is close. That’s the way they were brought up.”
Isabel Hernandez says that in the Dominican Republic she was able to attend parties, but over here she cannot because she has too many things to do. If she were in Santo Domingo she could share her responsibilities with the rest of her family, which was very united.
A Dangerous City
But this can lead to another problem: parents are paranoid about letting their children go out in a “dangerous” city.
Rosa Cabrera, 18, lives in Brooklyn and feels that her parents are possessive because “they’re afraid something is going to happen to me if I go out.”
Isabel Hernandez explained that she too had a problem with “confinement” because of the “dangers.” Here, she is forced to stay in her apartment.
Many of the immigrants interviewed came from climates much warmer than ours. In fact, many had never seen snow before.
Heng Wong, from Cambodia, says he doesn’t like our weather (“Too hot, too cold”) or snow (“It’s the strangest thing I’ve ever seen”).
Roger Solomon, 20, from Guyana, had never seen snow before, either. “It looked so nice, beautiful, so I went and played in it. Then my hand started stinging. That made me want to go home,” he said.
When Kirpaul looked out the window of his airplane, he saw snow for the first time and huge buildings. “It was weird,” he recalls.
The many tall buildings and crowded streets shock many newcomers to our country. A lot of immigrants are also not used to sidewalks.
“In Cambodia, everything was dirt-you just walk barefoot,” says Bun Hen Cheng, 15. “When I came here I walked barefoot and cut my foot.”
The First Subway Ride
Another great shock to foreigners is our subway system. The trains are confusing enough for New Yorkers. Can you imagine what it’s like for someone who doesn’t read or speak English?
It stunned Isabel to see a train for the first time. And when Yonilda’s parents took her on a train for the first time, she was frightened and she didn’t want to get on. “I was afraid, because in Santo Domingo they told me it was dangerous, and I was afraid to get stuck in a tunnel,” Yonilda says.
On the other hand, Julio found it very exciting-but when riding it he got sick.
Not only do they have to adjust to a fast-paced city life, but they have to make changes within themselves.
Dionne said, “My pace of life was increased. It’s not as relaxed as it is in the islands.”
And Roger had to adjust to people making a problem out of his stuttering, for back home it wasn’t a problem.
Many immigrant teens said that they had to assert themselves to be noticed, and had to learn to be more confident so that they weren’t pushed aside by fast-paced New Yorkers.
Besides these mental changes, there are physical changes as well.
“I changed my clothes, I changed my hair,” said Cjiang Hong Hanh, 17, from Vietnam, in describing how she tried to be more American.
Hard To Be Accepted
But even after making these changes, immigrants find it very hard to be accepted into American society. Many feel like foreigners always.
Isabel doesn’t feel good being a Dominican in America because she feels that Americans have a low image of Dominicans.
And when Heng, a Cambodian, moved to Philadelphia, “It was great, but the people are prejudiced. They threw snowballs at us,” he says.
Even after immigrants become U.S. citizens, some people still insist that they are foreign and treat them as such.
But on the funnier side, there are quite a few things which Americans do that immigrants think are silly.
“Most Chinese are used to eating very well-done meat,” explained Charlie Lai, from Hong Kong. “When I got a hamburger, it was very rare. I bit into it. . . blood-yuch!”
Martine, from Haiti, and Roger, from Guyana, both couldn’t understand how two people of the same sex could fall in love with each other.
Americans Dress Funny
Rosa Cabrera says that Americans dress funny and always wear the same clothes. And Julie doesn’t like the punk style of dressing or the crazy haircuts that people get.
Also, many seem to feel that Americans are always looking for trouble.
But that’s about as bad as the complaints get.
The immigrant teens were asked if they wanted to raise their children as Americans.
“Over here kids have too much freedom,” says Roger. He’s worried about raising his own children because he thinks old-fashioned is better. “If I stick close to how my parents taught me, that’s how they’ll survive,” he says.
Wendy Rondon, 15, says she’s going to let her children know they’re Dominican, but also show them the American way.
Cjiang Hong says, “I’ll teach them to speak Vietnamese. But I will teach them to look like Americans.”
Dionne wants to give them the best of both worlds, while Julio says he’s going to raise his children his own way.
As for themselves, most want to be American and are only going to their old countries to visit.
Do You Feel American?
I asked Roger if he feels American.
“I’m starting to feel American, just starting to fall in. I’m more into discos than calypso or reggae, which I used to listen to. But I feel proud to be from Guyana in America,” Roger says.
Some want to become American for personal reasons, like Rosa, who wants to be a citizen so she can bring her mother here.
But Charlie says growing up to be an American was the thing to do: “To be a Met fan and see people go to the moon.”
Wendy Rondon says that it’s going to be “fun being American. Learning how to speak other languages, knowing different races.”
To Wendy it might be fun, but to others it is a long, hard struggle, and one that some have to fight alone.
Many would rather be in their old countries, but due to their situations they’re forced to stay here.
Do you want to be American?, Isabel Hernandez, from the Dominican Republic, was asked.
“No,” she said, “I have no reason.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.