Barack is Black

You are not black. You are not white. You are not Asian. You are not whatever race you thought you were when you began reading this article. Why not? Because I just decided that you don’t fit the stereotype. You’re too “out of touch with your demographic.” In fact, you’re a lot like presidential candidate Barack Obama.
Apparently, Obama isn’t black. At least that’s what New York Daily News columnist Stanley Crouch and others have been suggesting since February when Obama announced his presidential bid.
I disagree. I believe that Barack Obama is “black enough” and that no one has the right to question his race. I should know. I’m black, and people have been calling me things like “white girl” and “Oreo” my whole life.
‘Talking White’
The argument against Obama’s “blackness” starts when he opens his mouth. Because he speaks elegantly, he’s “talking white” in some people’s eyes.
I can relate. Back in 5th grade, I got called white whenever I answered a question correctly that no one else got right or when I had all my homework ready to hand in. I didn’t use much slang and that made it worse. Even now, when I speak to some black teens-acquaintances and neighbors-they say I talk like a white person.
People attack Obama’s wardrobe, as well. Because he dresses professionally, he’s accused of “dressing white.” He defies the stereotype that all black man wear clothes that are three sizes too big and can’t form a sentence without the words “yo” and “nigga.”
I know what that’s like too. I get told I’m not black enough because I wear H&M and Aeropostale instead of Rocawear and Baby Phat and because I like more pop and rock artists than R&B and rap artists.
Black Enough for Racism
Another argument against Obama’s blackness is that he’s the child of a black immigrant and not a true member of black America, so he can’t “Identify.” That idea implies that the experience of thousands of black immigrants in the U.S. is insignificant, like they don’t also experience struggle and discrimination.
I was raised by Jamaican immigrants. Like Obama, the way that I live, dress and speak is different from some black Americans. The culture my parents raised me in isn’t exactly like the one that many black children here were raised in. But as much as the black kids called me “white” growing up, I wasn’t white and I’ve had to deal with racism just like any black person in this country.
Like me, if Obama were to walk down the street of any city in any state in this country, as a regular citizen and not as the potential president, he would be classified as black. Not as a black immigrant, but simply black. Like me, he would face the same hardships as any other black person on those streets. To the people he walked past, he would be black enough.
Proving He Cares
The argument about Obama’s race picks up speed when the critics examine Obama’s upbringing. Obama was born to an African father and a white mother, his stepfather is Indonesian, and he grew up in Hawaii and Indonesia. Critics say that he can’t sympathize with the average black family because he was never in one.
It’s true that Obama grew up differently from most Americans-black or white. But that doesn’t mean he doesn’t care about the issues important to many black and/or low-income families. In fact, he’s been proving they matter to him for his entire career. One of the first things Obama did after graduating from college was move to Chicago to help direct a non-profit program that helped provide job training for residents of poor, largely black neighborhoods.
Today, Obama continues to focus on issues that benefit lower-income families, including lowering tax cuts for the wealthy and ending the Iraq war.
Let’s Lose the Stereotypes
The most troubling thing about the argument that Obama isn’t black is what it implies about our country’s definition of blackness. Does being black simply refer to the color of your skin or do you also need to adopt a certain type of speech and certain views? Do you only qualify as black if you fit the stereotype of what some Americans consider black: a thug who lives in poverty? Why did my 10- and 11-year-old classmates, who called me white for being smart, associate educational success with white America?
In 5th grade, I cried or got fiercely defensive when someone questioned my race. Now I ignore it because the people questioning me are set in their opinions, so I see no point in arguing. I like the person I am and that person is 100% black. I can look in a mirror and verify that fact, and I don’t think anyone else has the right to take that away from me. They can’t take it away from Obama, either.
Sure, Obama attended Occidental College, Columbia University and then Harvard Law School, while a lot of black people don’t have the chance to go college at all. But why does being extremely educated lower his status as a black man? We should be celebrating his education-and everything else about his success in life-not using it as evidence that he’s not part of the black community.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.