Barack is Black…But Not African-American

Barack Obama is not African-American. At least, not to me he isn’t.
This may be confusing to some. If you take the two words that make up the term “African-American” at face value, then you might assume he is. Yes, his father is a black Kenyan, and Obama was born in Hawaii, so it would seem that he fits the description. But the literal definition of a word, and what people take it to mean, can be worlds apart.
If you’ve picked up a newspaper or watched a news program recently, you probably know who Obama is. Currently a U.S. Senator from Illinois, he recently announced his campaign for the Democratic presidential nomination. He’s regarded as the first black person, male or female, to have a serious shot at winning the presidency. And on the U.S. Senate website, Obama is described as the fifth African-American senator. But what exactly does “African-American” mean? And does Obama fit the definition? I don’t think so.
Descendents of Slaves
In no way am I saying that African-Americans shouldn’t consider voting for Obama, or that he shouldn’t get their vote in the Democratic primaries. But when a publication like Time magazine runs a story titled, “Can Obama Count on the Black Vote?” (January 2007), it implies that the black American vote is somehow more Obama’s than any other Democratic candidate’s by right, simply because he’s African-American like them. To me, this is at best half-true.
The term African-American came into use as early as the ’60s, during the civil rights movement. During his famous “The Ballot or the Bullet” speech in the 1964, Malcolm X referred to “Twenty-two million African-Americans-that’s what we are-Africans who are in America.”
As I understand it, the term, which came into more widespread use in the ’80s, refers to blacks whose ancestors were African slaves brought to the U.S.
In 1988, Jesse Jackson, then a U.S. presidential candidate, urged Americans to use the term to refer to black Americans. “It puts us in our proper historical context,” he said during a news conference, according to a 2004 New York Times article. “Every ethnic group in this country has a reference to some land base, some historical cultural base. African-Americans have hit that level of cultural maturity.”
While Jackson never made it clear whether he meant all blacks or not, the implication that African-Americans, by definition, didn’t have a historic land base before leads me to believe that he meant the descendants of African slaves. They called themselves African-American because most blacks in America had no way of knowing which country in Africa their ancestors came from.
‘One of Us?’
Obama knows exactly where his ancestors come from. So if he wanted to, he could call himself Kenyan-European-American, since his dad is from Kenya and his mom is a white woman from Kansas.
But vocabulary isn’t the most important issue here. When I say that Obama isn’t African-American, what I really mean is that he doesn’t share the experiences that give most blacks in America (whose ancestors were slaves in this country) a common identity. African-American columnist Stanley Crouch wrote in a November 2006 New York Daily News column, “When black Americans refer to Obama as’one of us,’ I do not know what they are talking about.”
What Shapes Our Identity
Obama disagrees. He was quoted by the New York Times as saying “Some of the patterns of struggle and degradation that blacks here in the United States experienced aren’t that different from the colonial experience in the Caribbean or the African continent.” He added, “For me the term African-American really does fit. I’m African, I trace half of my heritage to Africa directly, and I’m American.”
But for many black Americans, ancestral lines from Africa are not what has shaped their identity. It’s not just race either, since most African-Americans are mixtures of black, white, Native-American or combinations of all three. To me, it’s more about shared hardships and history.
As descendants of Africans brought to the Americas during the Atlantic slave trade, we know little about our history, ancestors or culture.
Native Africans, like Obama’s father, have the same culture as their ancestors thousands of years before them. What African-Americans have now is only the result of the last 400 years. The Harlem Renaissance, the Black Power movement and musical forms like jazz and hip-hop all arose from the unique history of African-Americans.
A White Childhood
While Obama was raised in the U.S., he was raised in a very different environment than most African-American kids. More than half of African-Americans live in metropolitan areas, with the majority living in overwhelmingly black neighborhoods, according to the 2000 U.S. Census.
Obama’s parents, both college-educated, divorced when he was 2, and he lived with his white mother, who later married an Indonesian man. Obama spent four years attending private school in Indonesia, and later lived with his maternal grandparents in Hawaii.
Growing up in a white household in Hawaii is something that I’m guessing not many African-Americans can relate to. Issues that disproportionately affect African-Americans compared to the rest of the country-government aid programs, police brutality, public housing-most likely did not affect him in his youth.
He can’t Relate
As a result, many media critics have come to think that he doesn’t “get it” as well as an African-American candidate would. For example, in an opinion piece for Salon.com this year, Debra J. Dickerson wrote, “Black, in our political and social reality, means those descended from West African slaves. Voluntary immigrants of African descent (even those descended from West Indian slaves) are just that, voluntary immigrants of African descent with markedly different outlooks on the role of race in their lives and politics.”
As an African-American whose parents are from the South, I see some validity in that argument. Last year, my father told me about when my grandfather decided to move north to seek a better life from his family. The white factory owner who he worked for tried to persuade him to stay. When he realized that my grandfather wasn’t going to change his mind, he told him, “If you leave and move north, don’t even think about coming back.”
It being Alabama in the 1950s, my grandfather knew better than to take the man’s threat lightly. He moved north with his family and didn’t return until the ’80s, out of fear for his life. My father and most of his brothers and sisters never went back to the south to see their relatives and friends.
Black Like Me
That’s the kind of experience I bet Barack Obama has never had, and one I imagine he couldn’t relate to. For millions of older African-Americans, including my parents, the memories of racist Jim Crow laws and segregation are all too vivid, and might still affect their view of race and politics.
But regardless of how you define African-American, Obama does have the same views as most African-Americans on most social and domestic issues. A Gallup poll taken in 2003 showed that, like Obama, 70% of blacks favored affirmative action, compared to 44% of whites. Also, most African-Americans are Protestants, with 33% attending church regularly, as Obama does.
So, despite the differences in upbringing, Obama does have a lot in common with African-Americans. Just because he doesn’t share the same background as most black Americans doesn’t mean he isn’t looking out for them.
But it does mean he shouldn’t assume that black Americans can automatically relate to him because he’s the same race. Is Barack black like me? Of course. But he isn’t African-American like I am.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.