On the cover of his first album in five years, Michael is dressed in black with this “trying to be bad” look on his face. But “Bad” isn’t that good, and the same can be said for the video.
The video tells the story of a youth named Daryl (played by Jackson) who returns to his neighborhood in Harlem after a semester at a preppie school. He is challenged by his three buddies, who feel he has forgotten that he’s Black and comes from the ghetto.
Daryl has the chance to prove that he is “down” by setting up an elderly man for a mugging in a subway station. But he foils the crime on purpose and almost comes to blows with his friends over it.
Then the mini-movie, which is filmed mostly in black and white, turns to color as Daryl and a gang of youths who come out of nowhere break into song and dance.
After the musical sequence, Daryl questions his buddies’ ways (“You’re doing wrong! Who’s bad?”), and they walk away and leave him standing in the station alone.
First off, I admit that the song “Bad” isn’t that bad-the beat is heavy and hot.
But most of the dancing is outdated and doesn’t do the song any justice. It’s like Michael decided to take the gang theme from “Beat It” and mix it with steps from almost every Janet Jackson video.
Martin Scorcese’s direction is gritty: the locations used-New York’s Harlem and downtown Brooklyn-give the video a hard, urban look. The dialogue is real and grabs you. And all the actors in the video give convincing performances-except for you-know-who.
Michael looks out of place in his own video. His being at a prep school is believable, but hanging out with homeboys? Can you imagine Daryl committing crimes before he went off to prep school? I can’t.
The all-black outfit and chains can’t hide Michael’s high-pitched voice and reconstructed face. This is why I almost died laughing watching him get into scuffles with his hoodlum friends and grabbing his crotch. I could see LL Cool J in these situations, but Michael? No way!
For Michael to get tough with guys more than twice his size is too amusing. Also, his ghost-like features make him appear “neutral”-he can be either Black or White, male or female, depending on who you talk to.
I think Michael wants to prove his manhood, which has been questioned often. Also, by making an appearance in two mostly-Black areas in New York to film a video, he’s no doubt saying, “Look at me. Yes, I’m still Black.”
When Daryl is left alone in the subway station, most see him as a hero who chooses not to do something wrong. But to me it represents Michael’s strained relationship with many Blacks, who find his “whitened” face to be a bit too much.
The “Billie Jean” and “Beat It” videos, both from the “Thriller” album, made strong statements about teen violence and pregnancy. “Bad” could have been a strong message about resisting peer pressure, but the unrealistic and unbelievable performance makes the video just another of Michael’s fairytales.
Bad’ Is Not That Good
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.