Backstabbers

When we girls see each other walking down the street, why are we always “hating?”
My friends and I are always talking about how other girls look and, even if they look good, we will still find something wrong with them.
If we are walking down the street and see some other girls, one of us will always pick out some little thing to criticize. Like, “Oh, look at her jeans. They have a bleach spot on them. How can she go outside like that?”
Older women do this too. One evening, when I was in a restaurant with my aunt and my cousin, a woman and her date came and sat beside us. The woman had on a floral shirt, plaid pants and snakeskin shoes.
‘How Can She Go Outside Dressed Like That?’
During our entire dinner, my aunt kept on talking about how this lady’s outfit did not match, saying things like, “Didn’t her date criticize her outfit when she came out the house?” and “Doesn’t she have no shame?” and “Doesn’t she know that plaid and floral don’t match?”
I do not like when girls talk about other girls, but I have to admit that I do it myself and so do most people I know. I think that it is just a part of everyone’s nature. Even people who say that they do not gossip-I know that they have done it once in their life.
For me, it is just like an urge. When I see something that doesn’t look right or isn’t appealing to me, I have to talk about it with someone. It just seems like a natural thing to do.
Speaking Without Thinking…
It’s not that I get enjoyment out of it. It is just that I don’t think about what I am going to say-I just come out and say it. I don’t think about the other person’s feelings at that particular moment.
Sometimes after I do it, I say to myself that maybe the girl or woman whose clothes I was criticizing could not afford anything better than what she had on. If I think that, then I kind of feel sorry for the person. Then maybe I’ll say something nice to make up for the mean comment.
That’s me. But there are some girls who probably do feel better about themselves when they have a chance to criticize someone else.
…Or Just Jealous?
And some girls do it because they’re jealous. If they want something and can’t have it, they start talking about the people who do have it.
For example, if you want a certain pair of sneakers and you can’t get them and you see another girl with them on, you might say something about how her toe is popping out of her sneaker or how they would look better on you than on her.
Sometimes I see harm coming out of this because when one girl sees another girl talking about her, it might lead to a fight and someone could get hurt or even killed.
Are Guys More Trustworthy?
I also think it makes it harder for girls to trust each other and become friends. I know many girls who say they trust guys more than girls and would rather have guy friends because other girls are more likely to back-stab.
But I also think there are some things that girls don’t feel comfortable discussing with guys. If you only have guy friends, who do you talk to about guys?
I think girls need to have more unity with each other. But this won’t happen as long as we continue to gossip and back-stab.
Stop the Meanness!
When we find ourselves saying something mean about another girl, I think we need to remind ourselves that everyone has something wrong with them. And nobody likes it when someone else says something mean about them.
If you would not appreciate it if you were the one being talked about, then you should not talk about other people. It might hurt their feelings and then your own feelings will get hurt when they dish out some of your own medicine.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.