Art Cuts Limit Our Freedom

The New York State Council on the Arts, which indirectly funds thousands of arts groups and individual artists throughout the state, is facing an unprecedented $24.8 million in cuts- more than half of its total budget. The Council has a hand in funding everything from outdoor summer concerts to alternative art exhibits.
Governor Cuomo’s proposed cuts would be particularly devastating for the small dance and theatre companies, and the local bands and writers collectives which help to provide alternative voices in our society. State and city cuts are also expected to hit hard in a public school system where the arts curriculum is already virtually non-existent. And dozens of libraries will have to lay off workers and reduce service hours.
A Form of Censorship
But these cuts have a far greater impact than fewer library hours and summer concerts. They are a subtle and extremely dangerous form of censorship.
At the same time that it is reducing spending, the government is availing itself of the opportunity to, in effect, subdue our freedom of speech. The arts are integral to that freedom. They help us see ourselves and our society in fresh new ways. Through a painting, song, or poem, we can find ways to express the anger and frustration of the times we live in.
John Lennon is one example that comes to mind. In addition to being a poet and musician, he was also an artist. He went to art school and published books of drawings. He even made his own film called “How I Won the War.” Lennon inspired a generation but, more importantly, he used his music to mobilize people against war and injustice.
This is one way a mastery of the arts strengthens and preserves our freedom of speech. By learning to both create and appreciate music, art, literature, or drama, we are able to keep open channels of self knowledge and expression that are as old as the human race.
As Old As We Are
Ten thousand years ago, our ancestors felt the need to communicate what they saw around them by painting figures on the walls of their caves. These primitive paintings have survived to remind us in part who we are. Given half a chance, we can expect our paintings, sculptures and books to outlive us, and to leave for future generations a picture of our own troubled times.
The arts have survived centuries of ignorance, censorship, and persecution. They are always first to get axed, but not because they’re considered insignificant or expendable by the powers that be. Quite the contrary. They consider the arts an obstacle and a threat.
A decade after his death, John Lennon’s legendary song “Imagine,” for instance, continues to touch us so powerfully with its theme of world peace and unity that US Armed Forces Radio reportedly banned its airing in the Persian Gulf during the recent crisis there. They thought it would be bad for morale.
If young people never learn how to make their own music, art, or poetry they will never be able to adequately convey their thoughts and feelings. They will have to rely solely on the spoken word, a resource few ever adequately develop in New York City public schools.
Cutting arts classes and cultural programs may actually be the most effective way of silencing public debate and suppressing dissent.
Limiting Our Options
In his masterpiece, “1984,” George Orwell describes a rigid society where even to think against the principles of the government leads to certain death (thanks to the “thought police.”) Most people fear the consequences of dissent and practice “righthinking” in order to keep themselves out of trouble. But that isn’t good enough for the government.
They design a language called “Newspeak” to constrict one’s vocabulary and, by extension, one’s very thoughts. The rulers hope to eventually weed out every word that implies or results in free thinking. After all, they reasoned, if a person can’t find a word for her thoughts and feelings then she must necessarily stop having them.
Music, too, is its own kind of language. So are dance, photography and painting. Coupled with recent congressional efforts to destroy the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) and anti-obscenity laws, these budget cuts hint at a deeper national campaign to undermine our free speech.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.